The PICS project: II. Circumnebular extinction variations and their effect on the planetary nebula luminosity function

  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • Similar Papers
Abstract
Translate article icon Translate Article Star icon
Take notes icon Take Notes

For decades, the theoretical understanding of planetary nebulae (PNe) has remained in tension with the observed universal bright-end cutoff of the PN luminosity function (PNLF). The brightest younger PN populations have been observed to be fainter in their [OIII] emission than expected. Recent studies have proposed that circumnebular extinction is a key ingredient in bringing their brightness down to the observed level. In this work, we use the recently introduced PICS (PNe In Cosmological Simulations) framework to investigate the impact of different circumnebular extinction treatments on the modeled PNe and their PNLF for a large range of stellar ages and metallicities. We test how different slopes in the observed relation of extinction versus central star mass modify the bright-end cutoffs of the PNLF, finding that steeper slopes lead to large changes for young stellar populations. In contrast, the differences for older PNe are much smaller. However, for individual PNe, the extinctions observed in nearby galaxies appear to be much higher than the models predict, showing that improvements on both the modeling and observational sides are needed to gain a better understanding of the brightest and strongly extincted PNe. These findings further advance the theoretical foundation for interpreting observed extragalactic PN populations coming from more complex composite stellar populations in the future.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 9
  • 10.1051/0004-6361/202141890
On the most luminous planetary nebulae of M 31
  • Jan 1, 2022
  • Astronomy & Astrophysics
  • Rebeca Galera-Rosillo + 8 more

Context.The planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF) is a standard candle that comprises a key rung on the extragalactic distance ladder. The method is based on the empirical evidence that the luminosity function of planetary nebulae (PNe) in the [O III]λ5007 nebular emission line reaches a maximum value that is approximately invariant with population age, metallicity, or host galaxy type. However, the presence of bright PNe in old stellar populations is not easily explained by single-star evolutionary models.Aims.To gain information about the progenitors of PNe at the tip of the PNLF, we obtained the deepest existing spectra of a sample of PNe in the galaxy M 31 to determine their physico-chemical properties and infer the post-asymptotic giant branch (AGB) masses of their central stars (CSs). Precise chemical abundances allow us to confront the theoretical yields for AGB stellar masses and metallicities expected at the bright end of the PNLF. Central star masses of the sampled PNe provide direct information on the controversial origin of the universal cutoff of the PNLF.Methods.Using the OSIRIS instrument at the 10.4 m Gran Telescopio Canarias (GTC), optical spectra of nine bright M 31 PNe were obtained: four of them at the tip of the PNLF, and the other five some 0.5 mag fainter. A control sample of 21 PNe with previous GTC spectra from the literature is also included. We analyze their physical properties and chemical abundances (He, N, O, Ar, Ne, and S), searching for relevant differences between bright PNe and the control samples. The CS masses are estimated with Cloudy modeling using the most recent evolutionary tracks.Results.The studied PNe show a remarkable uniformity in all their nebular properties, and the brightest PNe show relatively large electron densities. Stellar characteristics also span a narrow range: ⟨L*/L⊙⟩ = 4300 ± 310, ⟨Teff⟩ = 122 000 ± 10 600 K for the CSs of the four brightest PNe, and ⟨L*/L⊙⟩ = 3300 ± 370, ⟨Teff⟩ = 135 000 ± 26 000 K for those in the control set. This groups all the brightest PNe at the location of maximum temperature in the post-AGB tracks for stars with initial massesMi = 1.5M⊙.Conclusions.These figures provide robust observational constraints for the stellar progenitors that produce the PNLF cutoff in a star-forming galaxy such as M 31, where a large range of initial masses is in principle available. Inconsistency is found, however, in the computed N/O abundance ratios of five nebulae, which are 1.5 to 3 times larger than predicted by the existing nucleosynthesis models for stars of these masses.

  • Research Article
  • 10.1051/0004-6361/202557218
Towards precision cosmology with improved PNLF distances using VLT-MUSE
  • Dec 1, 2025
  • Astronomy & Astrophysics
  • Azlizan A Soemitro + 7 more

Aims. Distance measurements using the planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF) rely on the bright-end cutoff magnitude ( M * ), which is defined by a number of the [O III ] λ 5007-brightest planetary nebulae (PNe). In early-type galaxies (ETGs), the formation of these PNe is enigmatic; the population is typically too old to form the expected M * PNe from single star evolution. We aim to provide a viable solution to this problem. Methods. We selected five ETGs with known MUSE-PNLF distances. The MUSE instrument allows us to calculate the PNLF and consistently investigate the underlying stellar populations. Using stellar population synthesis, we derived the population age, star formation history, metallicity, and alpha abundance. We compared these parameters to the PNLF variables: the absolute magnitude of the bright cutoff ( M * ) and luminosity-specific PN number at the top 0.5 mag of the PNLF ( α 0.5 ). We also compare our results with PNe In Cosmological Simulations (PICS) model applied to Magneticum Pathfinder analogue galaxies. Results. The average mass-weighted ages and metallicities of the stellar populations in our datasets are typically old (9 < Age < 13.5 Gyr) and rather metal rich (−0.4 < [M/H] < +0.2). We find the value of M * to be independent of age and metallicity in these ages and metallicity intervals. We observed a positive correlation between α 0.5 values and the mass fraction of stellar population ages of 2–10 Gyr, implying that most of the PNe originate from stars with intermediate ages. Similar trends are also found in the PICS analogue galaxies. Conclusions. We show that when ∼2% of the stellar mass present is younger than 10 Gyr, it is sufficient to form the M * PNe in ETGs. We also present observing requirements for an ideal PNLF distance determination in ETGs.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 25
  • 10.1051/0004-6361/202038366
The survey of planetary nebulae in Andromeda (M 31)
  • Mar 1, 2021
  • Astronomy & Astrophysics
  • Souradeep Bhattacharya + 6 more

Context.The Andromeda (M 31) galaxy displays several substructures in its inner halo. Different simulations associate their origin with either a single relatively massive merger, or with a larger number of distinct, less massive accretions.Aims.The origin of these substructures as remnants of accreted satellites or perturbations of the pre-existing disc would be encoded in the properties of their stellar populations (SPs). The metallicity and star formation history of these distinct populations leave traces on their deep [O III] 5007 Å planetary nebulae luminosity function (PNLF). By characterizing the morphology of the PNLFs, we constrain their origin.Methods.From our 54 sq. deg. deep narrow-band [O III] survey of M 31, we identify planetary nebulae in six major inner-halo substructures: the Giant Stream, North East Shelf, G1 Clump, Northern Clump, Western Shelf, and Stream D. We obtain their PNLFs and those in two disc annuli, with galactocentric radii ofRGC= 10–20 kpc andRGC= 20–30 kpc. We measure PNLF parameters from cumulative fits and statistically compare the PNLFs in each substructure and disc annulus. We link these deep PNLF parameters and those for the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) to published metallicities and resolved stellar population-age measurements for their parent SPs.Results.The absolute magnitudes (M*) of the PNLF bright cut-off for these sub-populations span a significant magnitude range, despite being located at the same distance and having a similar line-of-sight extinction. TheM*values of the Giant Stream, W Shelf, and Stream D PNLFs are fainter than those predicted by PN evolution models by 0.6, 0.8, and 1.5 mag, respectively, assuming the measured metallicity of the parent stellar populations. The faint-end slope of the PNLF increases linearly with decreasing fraction of stellar mass younger than 5 Gyr across the M 31 regions and the LMC. From their PNLFs, the Giant Stream and NE Shelf are consistent with being stellar debris from an infalling satellite, while the G1 Clump appears to be linked with the pre-merger disc with an additional contribution from younger stars.Conclusions.The SPs of the substructures are consistent with those predicted by simulations of a single fairly massive merger event that took place 2–3 Gyr ago in M31. Stream D has an unrelated, distinct origin. Furthermore, this study provides independent evidence that the faint-end of the PNLF is preferentially populated by planetary nebulae evolved from older stars.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 25
  • 10.1051/0004-6361/201730463
The halo of M 49 and its environment as traced by planetary nebulae populations
  • Jul 1, 2017
  • Astronomy & Astrophysics
  • J Hartke + 6 more

The galaxy M49 (NGC 4472) is the brightest early-type galaxy in the Virgo Cluster. It is located in Subcluster B and has an unusually blue, metal-poor outer halo. Planetary nebulae (PNe) are excellent tracers of diffuse galaxy and intragroup light. We present a photometric survey of PNe in the galaxy's extended halo to characterise its PN population, as well as the surrounding intragroup light (IGL) of the Subcluster B. PNe were identified based on their bright [OIII]5007 \AA\ emission and absence of a broad-band continuum. We identify 738 PNe out to a radius of 155 kpc from M49's centre from which we define a complete sample of 624 PNe within a limiting magnitude of m_5007=28.8. Comparing the PN number density to the broad-band stellar surface brightness profile, we find a variation of the PN-specific frequency (alpha-parameter) with radius. The outer halo beyond 60 kpc has a 3.2 times higher alpha-parameter compared to the main galaxy halo, which is likely due to contribution from the surrounding blue IGL. We use the Planetary Nebulae Luminosity Function (PNLF) as an indicator of distance and stellar population. Its slope, which correlates empirically with galaxy type, varies within the inner halo. In the eastern quadrant of M49, the PNLF slope is shallower, indicating an additional localised, bright PN population following an accretion event, likely that of the dwarf irregular galaxy VCC1249. We also determined a distance modulus of mu = 31.29+/-0.08 for M49, corresponding to a physical distance of 18.1+/-0.6 Mpc, which agrees with a recent surface-brightness fluctuations distance. The PN populations in the outer halo of M49 are consistent with the presence of a main Sersic galaxy halo with a slight (B-V) colour gradient of 10${}^{-4}$ mag/arcsec surrounded by intragroup light with a very blue colour of (B-V)=0.25 and a constant surface brightness mu_V=28.0 mag/arcsec${}^2$.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 7
  • 10.1088/0004-637x/703/2/l95
COMPARING SYMBIOTIC NEBULAE AND PLANETARY NEBULAE LUMINOSITY FUNCTIONS
  • Sep 8, 2009
  • The Astrophysical Journal
  • Adam Frankowski + 1 more

We compare the observed symbiotic nebulae (SyN) luminosity function (SyNLF) in the [O III] lambda5007 A line to the planetary nebulae (PN) luminosity function (PNLF) and find that the intrinsic SyNLF (ISyNLF) of galactic SyNs has-within its uncertainty of 0.5-0.8 mag-very similar cutoff luminosity and general shape to those of the PNLF. The [O III]/(Halpha+[N II]) line ratios of SyNs and PNs are shown to be also related. Possible implications of these results for the universality of the PNLF are briefly outlined.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 32
  • 10.1086/510897
Calibrating Type Ia Supernovae Using the Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function. I. Initial Results
  • Mar 1, 2007
  • The Astrophysical Journal
  • John J Feldmeier + 2 more

We report the results of an [O III] lambda 5007 survey for planetary nebulae (PN) in five galaxies that were hosts of well-observed Type Ia supernovae: NGC 524, NGC 1316, NGC 1380, NGC 1448 and NGC 4526. The goals of this survey are to better quantify the zero-point of the maximum magnitude versus decline rate relation for supernovae Type Ia and to validate the insensitivity of Type Ia luminosity to parent stellar population using the host galaxy Hubble type as a surrogate. We detected a total of 45 planetary nebulae candidates in NGC 1316, 44 candidates in NGC 1380, and 94 candidates in NGC 4526. From these data, and the empirical planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF), we derive distances of 17.9 +0.8/-0.9 Mpc, 16.1 +0.8/-1.1 Mpc, and 13.6 +1.3/-1.2 Mpc respectively. Our derived distance to NGC 4526 has a lower precision due to the likely presence of Virgo intracluster planetary nebulae in the foreground of this galaxy. In NGC 524 and NGC 1448 we detected no planetary nebulae candidates down to the limiting magnitudes of our observations. We present a formalism for setting realistic distance limits in these two cases, and derive robust lower limits of 20.9 Mpc and 15.8 Mpc, respectively. After combining these results with other distances from the PNLF, Cepheid, and Surface Brightness Fluctuations distance indicators, we calibrate the optical and near-infrared relations for supernovae Type Ia and we find that the Hubble constants derived from each of the three methods are broadly consistent, implying that the properties of supernovae Type Ia do not vary drastically as a function of stellar population. We determine a preliminary Hubble constant of H_0 = 77 +/- 3 (random) +/- 5 (systematic) km/s/Mpc for the PNLF, though more nearby galaxies with high-quality observations are clearly needed.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 1
  • 10.1017/s1743921323005458
PICS: Planetary Nebulae in Cosmological Simulations – Revelations of the Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function from Realistic Stellar Populations
  • Dec 1, 2023
  • Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union
  • Lucas M Valenzuela + 3 more

Even after decades of usage as an extragalactic standard candle, the universal bright end of the planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF) still lacks a solid theoretical explanation. Until now, models have modeled planetary nebulae (PNe) from artificial stellar populations, without an underlying cosmological star formation history. We present PICS (PNe In Cosmological Simulations), a novel method of modeling PNe in cosmological simulations, through which PN populations for the first time naturally occur within galaxies of diverse evolutionary pathways. We find that only by using realistic stellar populations and their metallicities is it possible to reproduce the bright end of the PNLF for all galaxy types. In particular, the dependence of stellar lifetimes on metallicity has to be accounted for to produce bright PNe in metal-rich populations. Finally, PICS reproduces the statistically complete part of the PNLF observed around the Sun, down to six orders of magnitude below the bright end.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 36
  • 10.1086/171150
Planetary nebulae as standard candles. VIII - Evidence for a change in the luminosity function cutoff at low metallicity
  • Apr 1, 1992
  • The Astrophysical Journal
  • Robin Ciardullo + 1 more

view Abstract Citations (41) References (30) Co-Reads Similar Papers Volume Content Graphics Metrics Export Citation NASA/ADS Planetary Nebulae as Standard Candles. VIII. Evidence for a Change in the Luminosity Function Cutoff at Low Metallicity Ciardullo, Robin ; Jacoby, George H. Abstract We search for a change in the [O III] λ5007 planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF) with metallicity by combining the planetary nebula (PN) observations of four metal-poor galaxies in the Local Group: M32, NGC 185, NGC 205, and the Small Magellanic Cloud. We show that the most likely magnitude cutoff for the PNs in our sample is 0.28^+0.11^_-0.17_ mag fainter than the value of M^*^ observed in the bulge of M31, but consistency with the M31 measurement cannot be ruled out beyond the 70% confidence level. The data suggest that PN-based distances may depend slightly on the underlying stellar population, with a factor of 10 in metal abundance translating into an apparent shift in the value of M^*^ by 0.25 mag (D(PNLF) is proportional to Z^-0.05^). However, because this variation is small, and population differences among luminous early-type cluster galaxies are usually slight, the effect is not important for cosmological distance determinations. The observed shift in the luminosity function is in good agreement with the theoretically derived metallicity dependence of Dopita, Jacoby, & Vassiliadis. Publication: The Astrophysical Journal Pub Date: April 1992 DOI: 10.1086/171150 Bibcode: 1992ApJ...388..268C Keywords: Galactic Bulge; Local Group (Astronomy); Luminosity; Planetary Nebulae; Red Shift; Andromeda Galaxy; Magellanic Clouds; Metallicity; Virgo Galactic Cluster; Astrophysics; GALAXIES: DISTANCES AND REDSHIFTS; GALAXIES: LUMINOSITY FUNCTION; MASS FUNCTION; GALAXIES: LOCAL GROUP; ISM: PLANETARY NEBULAE: GENERAL full text sources ADS | data products SIMBAD (5) NED (4) Related Materials (10) Part 1: 1989ApJ...339...39J Part 2: 1989ApJ...339...53C Part 3: 1989ApJ...344..704J Part 4: 1989ApJ...344..715C Part 5: 1990ApJ...356..332J Part 6: 1990ApJ...365..471J Part 7: 1991ApJ...383..487C Part 9: 1993ApJ...416...62M Part 10: 1996ApJ...462....1J Part 11: 1997ApJ...479..231F

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 33
  • 10.1051/0004-6361/201834579
The survey of planetary nebulae in Andromeda (M 31)
  • Apr 1, 2019
  • Astronomy & Astrophysics
  • Souradeep Bhattacharya + 6 more

Context.The Andromeda (M 31) galaxy subtends nearly 100 square degrees on the sky. Any study of its halo must therefore account for the severe contamination from the Milky Way halo stars whose surface density displays a steep gradient across the entire M 31 field of view.Aims.Our goal is to identify a population of stars firmly associated with the M 31 galaxy. Planetary nebulae (PNe) are one such population that are excellent tracers of light, chemistry, and motion in galaxies. We present a 16 square degree survey of the disc and inner halo of M 31 with the MegaCam wide-field imager at the CFHT to identify PNe, and characterise the luminosity-specific PN number and PN luminosity function (PNLF) in M 31.Methods.PNe were identified via automated detection techniques based on their bright [O III] 5007 Å emission and absence of a continuum. Subsamples of the faint PNe were independently confirmed by matching with resolvedHubbleSpace Telescope sources from the PanchromaticHubbleAndromeda Treasury and spectroscopic follow-up observations with HectoSpec at the MMT.Results.The current survey reaches two magnitudes fainter than the previous most sensitive survey. We thus identify 4289 PNe, of which only 1099 were previously known. By comparing the PN number density with the surface brightness profile of M 31 out to ∼30 kpc along the minor axis, we find that the stellar population in the inner halo has a luminosity-specific PN number value that is seven times higher than that of the disc. We measure the luminosity function of the PN population and find a bright cut-off and a slope consistent with previous determinations. Interestingly, it shows a significant rise at the faint end, present in all radial bins covered by the survey. This rise in the M 31 PNLF is much steeper than that observed for the Magellanic clouds and Milky Way bulge.Conclusions.The significant radial variation of the PN specific frequency value indicates that the stellar population at deprojected minor-axis radii larger than ∼10 kpc is different from that in the disc of M 31. The rise at the faint end of the PNLF is a property of the late phases of the stellar population. M 31 shows two major episodes of star formation and the rise at the faint end of the PNLF is possibly associated with the older stellar population. It may also be a result of varying opacity of the PNe.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 1
  • 10.1088/1538-3873/aa6ca4
A New Population of Galactic Bulge Planetary Nebulae
  • May 4, 2017
  • Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific
  • Travis N Stenborg

January 2016 – title page.%%%%The Academic Senate of Macquarie University granted this degree in 2015, but the date 2016 appears on the title page, the verso of the title page and the spine.%%%%%%%%%%%%1. Planetary nebulas - history and overview – 2. The planetary nebula luminosity function – 3. New bulge PNs – 4. Duplicate objects – 5. Other observations – 6. New bulge PNLF – 7. Results and discussion – A. Spectral features – B. Galactic bulge mosaic II survey fields – C. Galactic bulge PNs – D. Publications – References.%%%%A new population of Galactic bulge planetary nebulas is presented. Nebula candidates were discovered by systematically reviewing archival [OIII] on/off band survey imaging of the central -5⁰ ≤ l ≤ 5⁰, -5⁰ ≤ b ≤ 5⁰ region around the Galactic centre. An image segmentation and interleaving scheme was developed to facilitate this review. The resultant candidates (> 200) were then double checked against complementary archival Hα sky survey data to screen for obvious planetary nebula (PN) mimics or spurious image artefacts.%%%%Confirmatory spectroscopy of the PN candidates was pursued with thin slit, fibre multiobject and wide field spectrographs. Custom software was built to streamline interfacing with third-party spectroscopic management tools and a parallel greedy set cover algorithm implemented for efficient field selection in constrained multi-object observations.%%%%The combined imaging and spectroscopic evidence yielded true (4), probable (31) and possible (83) PNs toward the bulge. Secondary discoveries such as new PN mimics and late type stars were by-products of the confirmatory spectroscopy. Instances of literature PN duplication encountered during the investigation were noticed and documented.%%%%Spectral analysis of new PNs, including those obtained with a new optimised sky subtraction technique devised and demonstrated here, provided diagnostic data allowing radial velocity and Balmer decrement determination. Using a combined diameter and radial velocity criterion, bona fide bulge PNs were distinguished from new foreground PNs. Where Balmer decrements were available for new bulge PNs, differential aperture photometry was used to provide a modest data increment to Galactic bulge planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF).%%%%The PNLF was revised with data from some new bulge PNs, but more significantly, by a series of corrections to the data derived from previously known bulge PNs (~225), such as improved filter transmission effects, statistically justified binning and application of a uniform bulge-relevant extinction law. The result was the most rigorous bulge PNLF to date. An improvement on the legacy PNLF, the revised PNLF exhibited a form inconsistent with typical extragalactic examples, an expected result of the unusual extinction correction method used to address bulge-specific observational limitations. Issues restricting the accuracy of the bulge PNLF were identified. Until those restrictions are ameliorated, the utility of the PNLF in aiding physical understanding…

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 79
  • 10.1086/324737
A Survey for Very Faint Planetary Nebulae in the SMC. I. Identification, Confirmation, and Preliminary Analysis
  • Jan 1, 2002
  • The Astronomical Journal
  • George H Jacoby + 1 more

Using the ESO 2.2 m telescope with the 8K × 8K mosaic CCD, we have surveyed 2.8 deg2 (~16 × 17) of the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) to search for faint planetary nebulae (PNs); 34 PNs were previously known in this central region. We identified 25 new PNs, all faint and spectroscopically confirmed. Most of these are spatially extended with typical diameters of ~1 pc, but a few are as large as ~3 pc. Based on the total number of PNs previously known (~80), we can now estimate that there should be ~139 PNs in the SMC to the limits of a survey such as this one, which is complete to 6 mag down the planetary nebulae luminosity function (PNLF). For a complete survey (8 mag down the PNLF), there should be about 216 PNs. Because no new bright PNs were found in this survey, the bright end of the PNLF remains unchanged from that reported by Jacoby, Walker, & Ciardullo. Consequently, the distance modulus to the SMC, derived using the PNLF technique, is still ~19.1. However, a strong new feature is now evident in the PN brightness distribution that may be attributed to central stars evolving from a relatively young population. This feature may serve as an indicator of the ages of the PN progenitors. The survey spectra that were used to confirm the candidates as PNs also provide a clue to the nature of the very faint PNs. Statistically, the fainter PNs of our survey exhibit a high incidence (~28%) of strong [N II] emission [where I([N II])/I(Hα) > 1] relative to the bright Sanduleak et al. sample (~6%) reported by Meatheringham & Dopita, and comparable to the intermediate-brightness Jacoby sample (~26%) reported by Boroson & Liebert. This incidence of strong [N II] is higher than in the Kingsburgh & Barlow sample (~17%) of Galactic PNs, despite the ~3 times higher abundance of nitrogen in the Galaxy. We propose that the very faint SMC PNs are selectively biased toward the chemically enriched Type I objects derived from younger, more massive progenitors and are partially obscured by their own dust. This brightness-dependent population change is also seen in the Large Magellanic Cloud.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 216
  • 10.1086/342180
Planetary Nebulae as Standard Candles. XII. Connecting the Population I and Population II Distance Scales
  • Sep 20, 2002
  • The Astrophysical Journal
  • Robin Ciardullo + 5 more

We report the results of [O III] λ5007 surveys for planetary nebulae (PNe) in six galaxies: NGC 2403, NGC 3115, NGC 3351, NGC 3627, NGC 4258, and NGC 5866. Using on-band/off-band [O III] λ5007 images, as well as images taken in Hα, we identify samples of PNe in these galaxies and derive their distances using the planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF). We then combine these measurements with previous data to compare the PNLF, Cepheid, and surface brightness fluctuation (SBF) distance scales. We use a sample of 13 galaxies to show that the absolute magnitude of the PNLF cutoff is fainter in small, low-metallicity systems, but the trend is well modeled by the theoretical relation of Dopita, Jacoby, & Vassiliadis. When this metallicity dependence is removed, the scatter between the Cepheid and PNLF distances becomes consistent with the internal errors of the methods and independent of any obvious galaxy parameter. We then use these data to recalibrate the zero point of the PNLF distance scale. We use a sample of 28 galaxies to show that the scatter between the PNLF and SBF distance measurements agrees with that predicted from the techniques' internal errors and that there is no systematic trend between the distance residuals and stellar population. However, we also find that the PNLF and SBF methods have a significant scale offset: Cepheid-calibrated PNLF distances are, on average, ~0.3 mag smaller than Cepheid-calibrated SBF distances. We discuss the possible causes of this offset and suggest that internal extinction in the bulges of the SBF calibration galaxies is the principal cause of the discrepancy. If this hypothesis is correct, then the SBF-based Hubble constant must be increased by ~7%. We also use our distance to NGC 4258 to argue that the short distance scale to the LMC is correct and that the global Hubble constant inferred from the Hubble Space Telescope Key Project should be increased by 8% ± 3% to H0 = 78 ± 7 km s-1 Mpc-1.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 2
  • 10.1051/0004-6361/202553974
The PICS Project
  • Jul 1, 2025
  • Astronomy & Astrophysics
  • Lucas M Valenzuela + 3 more

Context. Planetary nebulae (PNe) and their luminosity function (PNLF) in galaxies have been used as a cosmic distance indicator for decades, yet a fundamental understanding is still lacking to explain the universality of the PNLF among different galaxies. So far, models for the PNLF have generally assumed near-solar metallicities and employed simplified stellar populations. Aims. In this work, we investigate how metallicity and helium abundances affect the resulting PNe and PNLF as well as the importance of the initial-to-final mass relation (IFMR) and circumnebular extinction in order to resolve the tension between PNLF observations and previous models. Methods. We introduce PICS (PNe In Cosmological Simulations), a PN model framework that takes into account the stellar metal-licity and is applicable to realistic stellar populations obtained from both cosmological simulations and observations. The framework combines current stellar evolution models with post-AGB tracks and PN models to obtain the PNe from the parent stellar population. Results. We find that metallicity plays an important role for the resulting PNe, as old metal-rich populations can harbor much brighter PNe than old metal-poor populations. In addition, we show that the helium abundance is a vital ingredient at high metallicities, and we explored the impact on the PNLF of a possible saturation of the helium content at higher metallicities. We present PNLF grids for different stellar ages and metallicities, where the observed PNLF bright end can be reached even for old stellar populations of 10 Gyr at high metallicities. Finally, we find that the PNLFs of old stellar populations are extremely sensitive to the IFMR, potentially allowing for the production of bright PNe. Conclusions. With PICS, we have laid the groundwork for studying how models and assumptions relevant to PNe affect the PNe and PNLF. Two of the central ingredients for the PNe and PNLF are the metallicity and helium abundance. Future applications of PICS include self-consistent modeling of PNe in a cosmological framework to explain the origin of the universality of the PNLF bright-end cutoff and using it as a diagnostic tool for galaxy formation.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 22
  • 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2010.16635.x
A new population of planetary nebulae discovered in the Large Magellanic Cloud - III. The luminosity function
  • May 1, 2010
  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
  • Warren A Reid + 1 more

Our previous identification and spectroscopic confirmation of 431 faint, new planetary nebulae in the central 25 deg^2 region of the LMC permits us to now examine the shape of the LMC Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function (PNLF) through an unprecedented 10 magnitude range. The majority of our newly discovered and previously known PNe were observed using the 2dF, multi-object fibre spectroscopy system on the 3.9-m Anglo-Australian Telescope and the FLAMES multi-object spectrograph on the 8-m VLT. We present reliable [OIII]5007 and H-beta flux estimates based on calibrations to well established PN fluxes from previous surveys and spectroscopic standard stars. The bright cutoff (M*) of the PNLF is found by fitting a truncated exponential curve to the bright end of the PNLF over a 3.4 magnitude range. This cutoff is used to estimate a new distance modulus of 18.46 to the LMC, in close agreement with previous PNLF studies and the best estimates by other indicators. The bright end cutoff is robust to small samples of bright PNe since significantly increased PN samples do not change this fiducial. We then fit a truncated exponential curve directly to the bright end of the function over a 6 magnitude range and test the curve's ability to indicate the position of M*. Because of the significant increase in the number of LMC PN, the shape of the PNLF is now examined in greater detail than has previously been possible. Through cumulative functions, the new LMC PNLF is compared to those from the SMC and a new deep local Galactic sample revealing the effects of incompleteness. The new [OIII]5007 LMC PNLF is then compared to our new H-beta LMC PNLF using calibrated and measured fluxes for the same objects, revealing the effects of metallicity on the [OIII]5007 line.

  • PDF Download Icon
  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 3
  • 10.1051/0004-6361/202244597
MUSE crowded field 3D spectroscopy in NGC 300
  • Mar 1, 2023
  • Astronomy & Astrophysics
  • Azlizan A Soemitro + 7 more

Aims. We perform a deep survey of planetary nebulae (PNe) in the spiral galaxy NGC 300 to construct its planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF). We aim to derive the distance using the PNLF and to probe the characteristics of the most luminous PNe. Methods. We analysed 44 fields observed with MUSE at the VLT, covering a total area of ∼11 kpc2. We find [O III]λ5007 sources using the differential emission line filter (DELF) technique. We identified PNe through spectral classification with the aid of the BPT diagram. The PNLF distance was derived using the maximum likelihood estimation technique. For the more luminous PNe, we also measured their extinction using the Balmer decrement. We estimated the luminosity and effective temperature of the central stars of the luminous PNe based on estimates of the excitation class and the assumption of optically thick nebulae. Results. We identify 107 PNe and derive a most-likely distance modulus $ (m-M)_0 = 26.48^{+0.11}_{-0.26} $ ($ d = 1.98^{+0.10}_{-0.23} $ Mpc). We find that the PNe at the PNLF cutoff exhibit relatively low extinction, with some high-extinction cases caused by local dust lanes. We present the lower limit luminosities and effective temperatures of the central stars for some of the brighter PNe. We also identify a few Type I PNe that come from a young population with progenitor masses > 2.5 M⊙ but do not populate the PNLF cutoff. Conclusions. The spatial resolution and spectral information of MUSE allow precise PN classification and photometry. These capabilities also enable us to resolve possible contamination by diffuse gas and dust, improving the accuracy of the PNLF distance to NGC 300.

Save Icon
Up Arrow
Open/Close
  • Ask R Discovery Star icon
  • Chat PDF Star icon

AI summaries and top papers from 250M+ research sources.