The Cosmetic/Drug Dilemma: FDA Regulation of Alpha-Hydroxy Acids

  • Abstract
  • References
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract
Translate article icon Translate Article Star icon
Take notes icon Take Notes

Should products containing alpha-hydroxy acids or similar substances be considered cosmetics or drugs under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act of 1938 (FDCA)? Under most interpretations of the FDCA with regard to cosmetics, the answer to this question would be rooted not in the chemical composition or physiological effect of AHAs but rather in how the manufacturer has positioned the product and the promises made as to its effects. The cosmetic/drug distinction has considerable implications for the cosmetics industry because of the difference in regulation between cosmetics and drugs, most notably the lack of any requirement of premarket review for cosmetic products. A decision that AHAs are to be regulated as drugs could force manufacturers to pull available products from the market and submit extensive tests as to the products' safety and effectiveness for FDA approval, clearly an undesirable result for the industry. But a decision that the products are to be treated as cosmetics means that any regulation of their safety comes completely ex post in the form of product liability suits or FDA seizure proceedings, which involve considerable government resources.

CitationsShowing 5 of 5 papers
  • Open Access Icon
  • Research Article
  • 10.12775/herb.2017.002
Hydroksykwasy organiczne w fitokosmetykach rewitalizujących
  • Oct 18, 2021
  • HERBALISM
  • Agata Kaniewska + 1 more

W artykule wyjaśniono zagadnienia związane z występowaniem i zastosowaniem hydroksykwasów organicznych w fitokosmetykach rewitalizujących i zabiegach kosmetycznych. Dokonano charakterystyki budowy skóry oraz właściwości fizycznych i chemicznych alfa-(AHA) i beta-hydroksykwasów (BHA) (kwas glikolowy, kwas mlekowy, kwas cytrynowy, kwas jabłkowy, kwas winowy, kwas salicylowy). Scharakteryzowano sposoby oznaczania hydroksykwasów, a także przedstawiono regulacje prawne dotyczące stosowania hydroksykwasów w kosmetykach. Przedstawiono wskazania i przeciwwskazania do zastosowania zabiegów z kwasami owocowymi. Opisano czynniki warunkujące skuteczność działania biologicznego alfa-hydroksykwasów (AHA).

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 8
Reading our lips: the history of lipstick regulation in Western seats of power.
  • Jan 1, 2006
  • Food and Drug Law Journal
  • Sarah E Schaffer

This paper traces the history of lipsticki?½s social and legal regulation in Western seats of power, from Ur circa 3,500 B.C. to the present-day United States. Sliced in this manner, lipsticki?½s history emerges as heavily cyclical across the Egyptian, Grecian, Roman, Western European, English, and American reigns of power. Examination of both the informal social and formal legal regulation of lipstick throughout these eras reveals that lipsticki?½s fluctuating signification concerning wearersi?½ class and gender has always largely determined the extent and types of lipstick regulations that Western societies put in place. Medical and scientific knowledge, however, has also played an important secondary role in lipsticki?½s regulatory scheme. Thus, lipstick status laws, primarily intended to protect men, long predated laws concerning lipstick safety. Safety laws, in turn, long focused solely on human safety before very recently also branching out into environmental and animal safety. In the future, Western societies should expect to see a continuation of lipstick status regulations, albeit probably informal social ones, as well as increasingly comprehensive lipstick safety regulations regarding human, environmental, and animal well-being.

  • Preprint Article
  • Cite Count Icon 3
Henna Tattooing: Cultural Tradition Meets Regulation
  • Feb 4, 2009
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Carrie Griffin Basas

In this article, I analyze the FDA's approach to regulating mehndi products. I draw on the cultural and historical uses of henna to suggest strategies for approaching the regulation of temporary tattooing products. These kinds of products have grown in popularity in the last few years. While the FDA has become concerned about the side effects caused by mehndi, it has not found a regulation strategy consistent with respecting cultural practices and protecting consumers against the greatest threats.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 3
A survey of consumer cosmetic products and salon preparations for alpha hydroxy acids.
  • Feb 1, 2002
  • Journal of cosmetic science
  • Jean C Hubinger

The Food and Drug Administration has completed a survey of consumer and salon/professional cosmetic products for glycolic and lactic acids, and product pH, to determine conformity with recommended levels established by the Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR). In twenty-five consumer products, concentrations of glycolic and lactic acid ranged from 1.1% to 8.7%. Two products had pHs lower than the recommended minimum of 3.5. In seventeen salon/professional products, glycolic and lactic acids were found at levels ranging from 0.9% to 28.5%. Two salon products had pHs significantly lower than the 3.0 recommended by the CIR. About half of the products contained either a sunscreen or a recommendation for the use of a sunscreen.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 16
  • 10.1016/j.jpba.2007.10.004
Enantiomer separation of α-hydroxy acids in high-performance immunoaffinity chromatography
  • Oct 12, 2007
  • Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis
  • Elliott J Franco + 2 more

Enantiomer separation of α-hydroxy acids in high-performance immunoaffinity chromatography

More from: Social Science Research Network
  • Preprint Article
  • 10.5282/ubm/epub.77871
Social Mobility in Germany
  • Nov 15, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Majed Dodin + 4 more

  • Preprint Article
  • 10.5282/ubm/epub.77867
Earnings Information and Public Preferences for University Tuition: Evidence from Representative Experiments
  • Nov 15, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Philipp Lergetporer + 1 more

  • Preprint Article
  • 10.17632/m4tjfjjd83.1
Circadian entry of glucose into the arcuate nucleus determines the rhythm in blood glycemia
  • Nov 5, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Betty Rodríguez-Cortés + 5 more

  • Research Article
  • 10.5167/uzh-208572
Heterogeneous Tail Generalized Common Factor Modeling
  • Oct 28, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Simon Hediger + 3 more

  • Preprint Article
  • 10.3929/ethz-b-000511510
Complementarity between labor and energy: A firm-level analysis
  • Oct 27, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Lucas Bretschger + 1 more

  • Preprint Article
  • 10.17632/p4btc9z6hy.1
The mitochondrial protease Lonp1 maintains oocyte development and survival by suppressing nuclear translocation of AIFM1 in mammals
  • Oct 27, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Xiaoqiang Sheng

  • Preprint Article
  • 10.5281/zenodo.5595548
Current Status of Indian Open Access Institutional Repositories (OAIRs) and Its Significance in Pandemic Era
  • Oct 25, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Subhajit Panda + 1 more

  • Preprint Article
  • 10.5282/ubm/epub.77854
Decomposing the disposition effect
  • Oct 18, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Johannes Maier + 1 more

  • Preprint Article
  • 10.17632/p4tbspt8fs.2
Dataset for: Evolution of Mining Employment during the Resource Boom and Bust Cycle in Australia
  • Oct 12, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Nam Foo + 1 more

  • Preprint Article
  • 10.17617/2.3345402
To Break Up or Regulate Big Tech Avenues to Constrain Private Power in the DSA/DMA Package
  • Oct 7, 2021
  • Social Science Research Network
  • Heiko Richter + 2 more

Save Icon
Up Arrow
Open/Close
  • Ask R Discovery Star icon
  • Chat PDF Star icon

AI summaries and top papers from 250M+ research sources.

Search IconWhat is the difference between bacteria and viruses?
Open In New Tab Icon
Search IconWhat is the function of the immune system?
Open In New Tab Icon
Search IconCan diabetes be passed down from one generation to the next?
Open In New Tab Icon