THE BENFORD-NEWCOMB DISTRIBUTION AND UNAMBIGUOUS CONTEXT-FREE LANGUAGES

Abstract

For a string w ∈ {0,1, 2,…, d-1}*, let vald(w) denote the integer whose base d representation is the string w and let MSDd(x) denote the most significant or the leading digit of a positive integer x when x is written as a base d integer. Hirvensalo and Karhumäki [9] studied the problem of computing the leading digit in the ternary representation of 2x ans showed that this problem has a polynomial time algorithm. In [16], some applications are presented for the problem of computing the leading digit of AB for given inputs A and B. In this paper, we study this problem from a formal language point of view. Formally, we consider the language Lb,d,j = {w|w ∈ {0,1, 2,…, d-1}*, 1 ≤ j ≤ 9, MSDb(dvalb(w))) = j} (and some related classes of languages) and address the question of whether this and some related languages are context-free. Standard pumping lemma proofs seem to be very difficult for these languages. We present a unified and simple combinatorial technique that shows that these languages are not unambiguous context-free languages. The Benford-Newcomb distribution plays a central role in our proofs.