Thalidomide and unilateral limb defects: the Italian chapter of a neverending story

Abstract

Fifty years after the event, Italy introduced legislation to compensate malformations in children - now in their sixties - born to mothers who had been prescribed the antiemetic drug thalidomide for morning sickness. However, compensation has been denied to people 'only' damaged in one half of their body as opposed to those with bilateral malformations. The present study reviews the papers describing case series of children born with 'thalidomide embryopathy' in the UK, Germany, and other countries around 1960. Most clinical series were not organized on the basis of inclusion/exclusion criteria, thus allowing for probable selection and information biases on maternal use of thalidomide. In any case, they included a sizable number of children with a unilateral limb defect born from mothers certainly exposed to thalidomide during the relevant pregnancy. In many of these children, limb defects were associated with visceral malformations, as frequently observed following exposure to thalidomide in utero. Similarly, later literature reviews were not bias-free in their choice of articles, as is the case of a recently proposed 'diagnostic algorithm' for thalidomide-caused specific malformations and of the advice by the Italian National Institute of Health ruling out the possibility of thalidomide producing unilateral limb defects. Overall, the scientific evidence suggests that thalidomide can cause unilateral limb defects.