Statement of Retraction: Next-generation -omics approaches to drive carboxylate production by acidogenic fermentation of food waste: a review

The aim of the study is to investigate the quality indicators of organic fertilizer obtained in the process of fermentation of food waste of various compositions with the preparation Baikal EM-1. Tasks: to carry out the process of fermentation of food waste; to analyze the composition of the obtained compost; to provide recommendations on the use of the obtained organic fertilizer. Experimental studies on the fermentation of food waste were conducted at the Department of Biotechnology and Food Production, the quality indicators of the obtained organic fertilizer (compost) were determined in the Agroecology research laboratory of the Kuzbass State Agrarian University named after V.N. Poletskov. The object of the study is food waste. The process of fermentation of food waste of various compositions with the preparation Baikal EM-1 to obtain organic fertilizer (compost) was studied. Baikal EM-1 is a microbiological fertilizer designed to improve the fertility of soil of any structure and composition in the garden and soil mixtures for indoor plants and seedlings. The biopreparation contains a large number of beneficial microorganisms living in the soil: lactic acid, nitrogen-fixing, nitrifying bacteria, actinomycetes, yeast and fermenting fungi. Food waste containing a protein component was poorly fermented with the enzyme preparation Baikal EM-1. The enzyme preparation Baikal EM-1 can be used for the fermentation of food waste containing a fat and carbohydrate component. A qualitative assessment of the resulting compost was made. The resulting compost fully complies with the requirements of GOST 55571-2013. The samples of the resulting compost have a fairly high content of total nitrogen (from 1.03 to 1.83 %), potassium (from 1.33 to 2.18 %), total phosphorus (from 1.41 to 1.48 %). In this regard, this compost can be successfully used as a fertilizer for ornamental and agricultural crops.

Amino acids, particularly the ones that cannot be synthesised during fermentation, are reportedly to be key nutrients for anaerobic fermentation processes, and some of the acids are also intermediate products of anaerobic fermentation of protein-rich waste. To date, particularly, there is a lack of research on the effects of some amino acids, such as cysteine, glycine, aspartic acid, and valine, on lactic production from the fermentation of food waste and also the mechanisms involved in the process. Thus, this study investigated the effects of the four different amino acids on lactic acid production during the acidic anaerobic fermentation of food waste. Firstly, batch experiments on synthetic food waste at different pHs (4.0, 5.0, and 6.0) were executed. The results harvested in this study showed that higher LA concentrations and yields could be obtained at pH 5.0 and pH 6.0, compared with those at pH 4.0. The yield of lactic acid was slightly lower at pH 5.0 than at pH 6.0. Furthermore, caustic consumption at pH 5.0 was much lower. Therefore, we conducted batch experiments with additions of different amino acids (cysteine, glycine, aspartic acid, and valine) under pH 5.0. The additions of the four different amino acids showed different or even opposite influences on LA production. Glycine and aspartic acids presented no noticeable effects on lactic acid production, but cysteine evidently enhanced the lactic acid yield of food waste by 13%. Cysteine addition increased α-glucosidase activity and hydrolysis rate and simultaneously enhanced the abundance of Lactobacillus at the acidification stage as well as lactate dehydrogenase, which also all favoured lactic acid production. However, the addition of valine evidently reduced lactic acid yield by 18%, and the results implied that valine seemingly inhibited the conversion of carbohydrate. In addition, the low abundance of Lactobacillus was observed in the tests with valine, which appeared to be detrimental to lactic acid production. Overall, this study provides a novel insight into the regulation of lactic acid production from anaerobic fermentation of food waste by adding amino acids under acidic fermentation conditions.

Lactic acid fermentation has recently been shown to be a robust storage strategy for food waste prior to conversion to biohydrogen through dark fermentation. However, the importance of initial microbial communities and, more particularly, exogenous microorganisms on the conversion of lactic acid-rich stored substrate is not yet fully elucidated. This study investigates the impact of introducing exogenous inoculum to lactic acid-rich stored food waste prior to biohydrogen production in dark fermentation. Results showed exogenous inoculation produced a statistically significant increase in biohydrogen production rate (Rm) by 199%, 250%, 137%, 130%, 19%, and 10% compared to non-inoculated stored food waste after food waste storage at 4 °C, 10 °C, 23 °C, 35 °C, 45 °C, and 55 °C, respectively. Interestingly, no impact on the maximum production yield (Pm) was observed, but exogenous inoculation increased the accumulation of acetate, up to 160% more compared to endogenous inoculum. The main hydrogen-producing bacteria (HPB) were affiliated with Clostridium sp., while Prevotella_9 sp., another known HPB, was found after the fermentation of the food waste stored at 23 °C. In this study, the interest of exogenous inoculation to convert food waste stored by lactic acid fermentation was demonstrated through an increase in production rate along with higher accumulation of co-products, e.g., acetate. Such findings are promising for further development of process coupling, combining storage and conversion by fermentation of complex food waste.

BackgroundWaste is currently a major problem in the world, both in the developing and the developed countries. Efficient utilization of food waste for fuel and chemical production can positively influence both the energy and environmental sustainability. This study investigated using food waste to produce acetone, butanol, and ethanol (ABE) by Clostridium beijerinckii P260.ResultsIn control fermentation, 40.5 g/L of glucose (initial glucose 56.7 g/L) was used to produce 14.2 g/L of ABE with a fermentation productivity and a yield of 0.22 g/L/h and 0.35 g/g, respectively. In a similar fermentation 81 g/L of food waste (containing equivalent glucose of 60.1 g/L) was used as substrate, and the culture produced 18.9 g/L ABE with a high ABE productivity of 0.46 g/L/h and a yield of 0.38 g/g. Fermentation of food waste at higher concentrations (129, 181 and 228 g/L) did not remarkably increase ABE production but resulted in high residual glucose due to the culture butanol inhibition. An integrated vacuum stripping system was designed and applied to recover butanol from the fermentation broth simultaneously to relieve the culture butanol inhibition, thereby allowing the fermentation of food waste at high concentrations. ABE fermentation integrated with vacuum stripping successfully recovered the ABE from the fermentation broth and controlled the ABE concentrations below 10 g/L during fermentation when 129 g/L food waste was used. The ABE productivity with vacuum fermentation was 0.49 g/L/h, which was 109 % higher than the control fermentation (glucose based). More importantly, ABE vacuum recovery and fermentation allowed near-complete utilization of the sugars (~98 %) in the broth.ConclusionsIn these studies it was demonstrated that food waste is a superior feedstock for producing butanol using Clostridium beijerinckii. Compared to costly glucose, ABE fermentation of food waste has several advantages including lower feedstock cost, higher productivity, and less residual sugars.

This study was performed to investigate the influence of operational pH on dark H(2) fermentation of food waste by employing anaerobic batch reactors. The highest maximum H(2) yield was 1.63 mol H(2)/mol hexoseadded at operational pH 5.3, whereas the lowest maximum H(2) yield was 0.88 mol H(2)/mol hexoseadded at operational pH 7.0. With decreasing operational pH values, the n-butyrate concentration tended to increase and the acetate concentration tended to decrease. The highest hydrogen conversion efficiency of 11.3% was obtained at operational pH 5.3, which was higher than that (8.3%) reported by a previous study (Kim et al. (2011) 'Effect of initial pH independent of operational pH on hydrogen fermentation of food waste', Bioresource Technology 102 (18), 8646-8652). The new result indicates that the dark fermentation of food waste was stable and efficient in this study. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis showed that Clostridium species Cluster I accounted for 84.7 and 13.3% of total bacteria at operational pH 5.3 and pH 7.0, respectively, after 48 h operation.

This study was performed to improve acidogenic fermentation of food waste in a continuous-flow reactor. The fermentation of food waste is affected by the fermentation constraints such as the biodegradability of substrate, the degrading capability of microorganisms and the environmental conditions. The key factors were, therefore, examined to control the fermentation constraints, such as the effect of seed inoculation and the effect of adjusting dilution rate. Acidogenic fermentation of food waste employing rumen microorganisms resulted in the enhanced efficiency (71.2%) as compared with that (59.8%) employing mesophilic acidogens. In addition, the fermentation efficiency increased from 71.2 to 82.0% by adjusting dilution rate from 3.0 to 1.0 d(-1) depending on the state of the fermentation. The main component of the acidified product was shifted from butyric to acetic acid. This meant that the increase of the fermentation efficiency was mainly caused by the enhanced degradation of vegetables and meats. The control of the fermentation constraints was, therefore, very effective in improving the fermentation efficiency of food waste.

Nitrogen removal performance of high ammonium and high salt wastewater by adding carbon source from food waste fermentation with different acidogenic metabolic pathways

Biohydrogen production by anaerobic fermentation of food waste

Food waste can be a valuable carbon source in biological nutrient removal (BNR) systems because of the high C/N and C/P ratio. However, pretreatment is necessary to promote hydrolysis of food waste because of the high concentration of volatile solids associated with organic matter. The influence of the enzymatic pretreatment on acid fermentation of food waste was investigated in this study. Solubilization of particulate matter in food waste was carried out using commercial enzymes. The acidification efficiency and the volatile fatty acid (VFA) production potential of enzymatically pretreated food waste were examined. The highest volatile suspended solid (VSS) reduction was obtained with an enzyme mixture ratio of 1:2:1 for carbohydrase: protease: lipase. An optimum enzyme dosage for solubilization of food waste was 0.1% (V/V) with the enzyme mixture ratio of 1:2:1. In the acid fermentation of enzymatically pretreated food waste, the maximum VFA production and the highest VFA fraction in soluble COD (SCOD) were also achieved at 0.1% (V/N) of total enzyme dosage. Increase in VFA production at this level of enzyme dosage was over 300% compared with the control fermenter. The major form of VFA produced by fermentation was n-butyrate followed by acetate.

Commercial enzyme is usually needed for the bioconversion of organic waste or biomass. The overall cost could be reduced very significantly if enzyme production could be integrated with its application, avoiding unnecessary steps in enzyme production (such as concentration, recovery and transportation). This investigation attempted to integrate crude glucoamylase production with lactic acid fermentation of food waste. A maximum glucoamylase activity of 1850 U g−1 was obtained with Aspergillus nigerduring solid‐state fermentation (SSF) of food waste, 14.8 times more than that obtained during submerged fermentation (SmF). The optimum pH for producing glucoamylase was 4.6, and glucoamylase retained 83.5% of peak activity at pH 3.0. Without any recovery treatment, the glucoamylase produced by SSF could be used directly for lactic acid fermentation of food waste. Lactic acid concentration reached 45.5 g L−1 with the addition of the crude enzyme, 72% higher than the control. No side‐effects were caused by the viable A. niger in the crude enzyme. This work successfully integrated glucoamylase production with lactic acid fermentation. The enzyme produced by SSF of food waste had sufficient activity to be used directly without any treatment. The integrated process proposed in this study was very economical and may be helpful to other bioconversions. Copyright © 2008 Society of Chemical Industry

Acidogenic fermentation is an emerging biotechnology that allows for the utilization of food waste as a feedstock to produce high-value products such as short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs), effectively offering a tangible solution for food waste management as well as resource recovery. The objectives of the current study were to identify the ideal inoculum, waste-activated sludge (WAS) or anaerobic digester sludge (AD), for the acidogenic fermentation of food waste at room temperature, as well as to evaluate the impact of heat pretreatment of these inoculums on fermentation performance. The maximum hydrolysis yield of 399 g sCOD/kg VS added was obtained when untreated AD was used as the inoculum, whereas the pretreated AD inoculum provided the highest SCFA yield and conversion efficiency of 238 g sCODSCFA/kg VS added and 71%, respectively. Heat pretreatment had a detrimental impact on the WAS inoculum, leading to lower hydrolysis and SCFA yields, but exerted a positive influence on the AD inoculum. The microbial community showed that heat pretreatment negatively impacted the abundance of non-spore-forming hydrolytic and acidogenic microorganisms. Overall, this study demonstrates the critical role of inoculum type and heat pretreatment in optimizing the acidogenic fermentation process, laying the groundwork for future refinements in SCFA production from food waste through inoculum design.

High-rate carboxylate production in dry fermentation of food waste at room temperature

Food waste has a great potential for resource recovery due to its huge yield and high organic content. Oriented fermentation is a promising method with strong application prospects due to high efficiency, strong robustness, and high-value products. Different fermentation types lead to different products, which can be shifted by adjusting fermentation conditions such as inoculum, pH, oxidation-reduction potential (ORP), organic loading rate (OLR), and nutrients. Compared with other types, lactic acid fermentation has the lowest reliance on artificial intervention. Lactic acid and volatile fatty acids are the common products, and high yield and high purity are the main targets of food waste fermentation. In addition to operational parameters, reactors and processes should be paid more attention to for industrial application. Currently, continuously stirred tank reactors and one-stage processes are used principally for scale-up continuous fermentation of food waste. Electro-fermentation and iron-based or carbon-based additives can improve food waste fermentation, but their mechanisms and application need further investigation. After fermentation, the recovery of target products is a key problem due to the lack of green and economic methods. Precipitation, distillation, extraction, adsorption, and membrane separation can be considered, but the recovery step is still the most expensive in the entire treatment chain. It is expected to develop more efficient fermentation processes and recovery strategies based on food waste composition and market demand.

Analysis of microbial community adaptation in mesophilic hydrogen fermentation from food waste by tagged 16S rRNA gene pyrosequencing

Continuous lactate-driven dark fermentation of restaurant food waste: Process characterization and new insights on transient feast/famine perturbations