Solar wind origin of 36Ar on Venus

Abstract

A hypothesis is considered in which the 36Ar found on Venus is of solar origin. This possibility is quantitatively discussed within the framework of present theories of planetary accumulation by sweep up of planetesimals under gas-free conditions. Solar wind implantation of 36Ar would take place by irradiation of accumulating material during the first ≈10 5 years of planetary growth, provided that the flux of solar wind was enhanced by a factor of ≈100 at that time. Enrichment of Venus in implanted gas would be a consequence of the irradiated material being initially confined to the innermost edge of the radially opaque circusolar planetesimal disk predicted by these theories. The observed atmospheric data require a Ne/Ar fractionation by a factor of ≈100 during the planetesimal stage. It is also necessary that there be very little mixing of irradiated planetesimals from the inner edge of disk to the distance (≈1 AU) at which the Earth formed. The hypothesis can be tested by measurement of the abundance of Kr and Xe in the Venus atmosphere. Venera data indicate a terrestrial 36Ar/Kr ratio, in disagreement with the solar wind hypothesis. In contrast, the Pioneer experiments find a lower limit to this ratio, well above the terrestrial value, that is compatible with the hypothesis. These experiments also show that Venus' 36Ar/Xe ratio does not correspond to the so-called “planetary” trapped inert gas composition. The inert of Venus could be related to result of admixture of gas with solar composition. The inert gas on Venus could be related to that found in enstatite chondrites.