Accelerate Literature Icon
Want to do a literature review? Try our new Literature Review workflow

Social-Psychological Interventions in Education

  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • Similar Papers
Abstract
Translate article icon Translate Article Star icon

Recent randomized experiments have found that seemingly “small” social-psychological interventions in education—that is, brief exercises that target students’ thoughts, feelings, and beliefs in and about school—can lead to large gains in student achievement and sharply reduce achievement gaps even months and years later. These interventions do not teach students academic content but instead target students’ psychology, such as their beliefs that they have the potential to improve their intelligence or that they belong and are valued in school. When social-psychological interventions have lasting effects, it can seem surprising and even “magical,” leading people either to think of them as quick fixes to complicated problems or to consider them unworthy of serious consideration. The present article discourages both responses. It reviews the theoretical basis of several prominent social-psychological interventions and emphasizes that they have lasting effects because they target students’ subjective experiences in school, because they use persuasive yet stealthy methods for conveying psychological ideas, and because they tap into recursive processes present in educational environments. By understanding psychological interventions as powerful but context-dependent tools, educational researchers will be better equipped to take them to scale. This review concludes by discussing challenges to scaling psychological interventions and how these challenges may be overcome.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 51
  • 10.1021/acs.jchemed.0c01497
Prompts to Promote Success: Evaluating Utility Value and Growth Mindset Interventions on General Chemistry Students’ Attitude and Academic Performance
  • Mar 31, 2021
  • Journal of Chemical Education
  • Ying Wang + 3 more

Some students struggle with chemistry because they do not find the relevance between chemistry content and their lives or they perceive their intelligence as fixed. Social-psychological interventions (SPIs), brief interventions that target students’ subjective experiences, were developed to address these issues. As a result, SPIs have been associated with gains in students’ academic performance, attitude, and persistence in various instructional settings; however, only a limited number of studies have explored SPIs within a chemistry context. This study evaluated the effectiveness of two SPIs, a growth mindset intervention (GMI) and a utility value intervention (UVI), on promoting students’ academic performance and attitude in a general chemistry course with a large class size. This study also explored a theoretical explanation for the relationship among SPIs, attitude, and academic performance. Each SPI was designed to facilitate instructional adoption and was implemented by posting three prompts incorporated into homework assignments. The results show that the UVI led to a consistent improvement in student achievement, and among students who begin the course with lower attitudes toward chemistry, the UVI led to an improvement in students’ emotional satisfaction and utility value. The UVI’s improvement in academic performance was also observed with a group of students who have been underrepresented in the sciences, although a smaller sample size prevented finding statistical significance. The GMI improved academic performance relative to a comparison group but not to the extent observed with the UVI. The cost-to-benefit ratio associated with adopting SPIs within chemistry instruction seems highly favorable and thus warrants strong consideration among chemistry instructors.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 271
  • 10.1002/14651858.cd004054.pub3
Psychological and educational interventions for atopic eczema in children.
  • Jan 7, 2014
  • The Cochrane database of systematic reviews
  • Steven J Ersser + 9 more

Psychological and educational interventions have been used as an adjunct to conventional therapy for children with atopic eczema to enhance the effectiveness of topical therapy. This is an update of the original Cochrane review. To assess the effect of psychological and educational interventions for atopic eczema in children. We updated our searches of the following databases to January 2013: the Cochrane Skin Group Specialised Register, CENTRAL in The Cochrane Library (2012, Issue 12), MEDLINE (from 1946), EMBASE (from 1974), OpenGrey, and PsycINFO (from 1806). We also searched six trials registers and checked the reference lists of included and excluded studies for further references to relevant randomised controlled trials (RCTs). Randomised controlled trials of psychological or educational interventions, or both, used to assist children and their carers in managing atopic eczema. Three authors independently applied eligibility criteria, assessed trial quality, and extracted data. A lack of comparable data prevented data synthesis, and we were unable to conduct meta-analysis because there were insufficient data. We included 10 RCTs, of which 5 were new to this update; all interventions were adjuncts to conventional therapy and were delivered in primary- and secondary-care settings. There were 2003 participants in the 9 educational interventions and 44 participants in the 1 psychological study. Some included studies had methodological weaknesses; for example, we judged four studies to have high risk of detection bias, attrition bias, or other bias. Our primary outcomes were participant-rated global assessment, reduction in disease severity (reported as objective SCORAD (SCORing Atopic Dermatitis)), and improvement in sleep and quality of life. No study reported participant-rated global assessment or improvement of sleep.The largest and most robust study (n = 992) demonstrated significant reduction in disease severity and improvement in quality of life, in both nurse- and dermatologist-led intervention groups. It provided six standardised, age-appropriate group education sessions. Statistically significant improvements in objective severity using the SCORAD clinical tool were recorded for all intervention groups when compared with controls. Improvements in objective severity (intervention minus no intervention) by age group were as follows: age 3 months to 7 years = 4.2, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.7 to 6.8; age 8 to 12 years = 6.7, 95% CI 2.1 to 11.2; and age 13 to 18 years = 9.9, 95% CI 4.3 to 15.5. In three of five studies, which could not be combined because of their heterogeneity, the objective SCORAD measure was statistically significantly better in the intervention group compared with the usual care groups. However, in all of the above studies, the confidence interval limits do not exceed the minimum clinically important difference of 8.2 for objective SCORAD.The largest study measured quality of life using the German 'Quality of life in parents of children with atopic dermatitis' questionnaire, a validated tool with five subscales. Parents of children under seven years had significantly better improvements in the intervention group on all five subscales. Parents of children aged 8 to 12 years experienced significantly better improvements in the intervention group on 3 of the 5 subscales. This update has incorporated five new RCTs using educational interventions as an adjunct to conventional treatment for children with atopic eczema. We did not identify any further studies using psychological interventions. The inclusion of new studies has not substantially altered the conclusions from the original review. The educational studies in both the original review and this update lack detail about intervention design and do not use a complex interventions framework. Few use an explicit theoretical base, and the components of each intervention are not sufficiently well described to allow replication. A relative lack of rigorously designed trials provides limited evidence of the effectiveness of educational and psychological interventions in helping to manage the condition of atopic eczema in children. However, there is some evidence from included paediatric studies using different educational intervention delivery models (multiprofessional eczema interventions and nurse-led clinics) that these may lead to improvements in disease severity and quality of life. Educational and psychological interventions require further development using a complex interventions framework. Comparative evaluation is needed to examine their impact on eczema severity, quality of life, psychological distress, and cost-effectiveness. There is also a need for comparison of educational interventions with stand-alone psychosocial self-help.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 6
  • 10.1097/der.0000000000000868
Psychological Interventions Are More Effective Than Educational Interventions at Improving Atopic Dermatitis Severity: A Systematic Review.
  • Jul 17, 2023
  • Dermatitis®
  • Tammy Hua + 10 more

We determined which educational and/or psychological interventions were most effective in atopic dermatitis (AD). A systematic review of published studies evaluated the effectiveness of educational and/or psychological interventions in MEDLINE, Embase, SCOPUS, LILACS, Cochrane, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Taiwan Electronic Periodical Services, and CiNii. Two reviewers conducted title/abstract, full-text review, and data extraction. Twenty-four prospective studies were included, including 20 randomized controlled trials. Educational (4/7 studies) and combined educational and psychological (5/6 studies) interventions reduced AD severity; psychological (10/11 studies) interventions showed the greatest benefit. The most commonly studied psychological intervention was habit reversal training (8/11 studies), which was most frequently incorporated in studies that reduced AD severity (8/10 studies). The most commonly studied educational interventions were education on AD triggers (7/7 studies) and skin care (7/7 studies); they were incorporated in all studies that reduced AD severity. Different psychological and/or educational interventions successfully reduced AD severity, especially habit reversal training.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 48
  • 10.1111/sipr.12066
Theoretical, Ethical, and Policy Considerations for Conducting Social–Psychological Interventions to Close Educational Achievement Gaps
  • Jan 1, 2020
  • Social Issues and Policy Review
  • Kevin R Binning + 1 more

Social–psychological interventions in education have shown remarkable promise as brief, inexpensive, and powerful methods for improving educational equity and inclusion by helping underperforming students realize their potential. These findings have led to intensive study and replication attempts to understand and close achievement gaps at scale. In the present review, we identify several significant issues this work has raised that bear on the theoretical, ethical, and policy implications of using these interventions to close achievement gaps. Using both classic and contemporary models of threat and performance, we propose a Zone Model of Threat to predict when social–psychological interventions in education may yield positive, null, and negative effects for specific students. From this analysis, we argue from an ethical standpoint that to reduce backfire effects, interventions should be focused on optimizing the salience of psychological threat across students rather than on uniformly reducing it. As a long‐term policy goal, intervention studies should follow a two‐step process, in which students’ individual levels of threat are first diagnosed and then interventions are tailored to the students based on their threat levels. Practical and theoretical implications of the proposed framework are discussed.

  • Research Article
  • 10.3760/cma.j.issn.1674-2907.2017.09.037
Application progress of social support and psychological intervention on preventing multidrug-resistant tuberculosis
  • Mar 26, 2017
  • Chinese Journal of Modern Nursing
  • Xueping Zhang

China has a high burden of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) . The treatment for MDR-TB was affected by complex and long treatment course, high treatment costs and high psychological burden. Previous studies have shown that social support and psychological intervention play an important role in alleviating the economic and psychological burden, and improving the compliance and treatment outcome in MDR-TB patients. The aim of this article is to conclude and analyze the research progress of social support and psychological intervention in China and overseas in recent years. Different intervention methods are collected and classified into different areas. The article also gives some expectations to the studies of social support and psychological intervention refer to follow-up and management in MDR-TB patients. Key words: Review; Multidrug-resistant tuberculosis; Social support; Psychological intervention

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 15
  • 10.4300/jgme-d-14-00443.1
Applying Clinical Research Skills to Conduct Education Research: Important Recommendations for Success.
  • Dec 1, 2014
  • Journal of Graduate Medical Education
  • Rebecca D Blanchard + 2 more

Imagine a physician who wants to research options to help her patients lose weight. As a clinical researcher, she may first explore the efficacy of a medication. Not only is there an instrument that accurately collects patient weight but also the link between the intervention (medication) and the outcome (weight) has been established. Her study manipulates the behavior of the physician (what should be prescribed), and the intervention is administered to the patient, who in this case, is a relatively passive recipient.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 104
  • 10.1002/14651858.cd004054.pub2
Psychological and educational interventions for atopic eczema in children.
  • Jul 18, 2007
  • The Cochrane database of systematic reviews
  • Steven J Ersser + 4 more

Psychological and educational interventions have been used as an adjunct to conventional therapy for children with atopic eczema to enhance the effectiveness of topical therapy. There have been no relevant systematic reviews applicable to children. To assess the effectiveness of psychological and educational interventions in changing outcomes for children with atopic eczema. We searched the Cochrane Skin Group Specialised Register (to September 2004), the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (The Cochrane Library Issue 2, 2005), MEDLINE (from 1966-2005), EMBASE (from 1980 to week 3, 2005 ), PsycINFO (from 1872 to week 1, 2005). On-line: National Research Register, Meta-register of Controlled Trials, ZETOC alerts, SIGLE (August 2005). RCTs of psychological or educational interventions, or both, used to manage children with atopic eczema. Two authors independently applied eligibility criteria, assessed trial quality and extracted data. A lack of comparable data prevented data synthesis. Five RCTs met the inclusion criteria. Some included studies required clearer reporting of trial procedures. Rigorous established outcome measures were not always used. Interventions described in all 5 RCTs were adjuncts to conventional therapy. Four focused on intervention directed towards the parents; data synthesis was not possible. Psychological interventions remain virtually unevaluated by studies of robust design; the only included study examined the effect of relaxation techniques (hypnotherapy and biofeedback) on severity. Three educational studies identified significant improvements in disease severity between intervention groups. A recent German trial evaluated long term outcomes and found significant improvements in both disease severity (3 months to 7 years, p=0.0002, 8 to 12 years, p=0.003, 13 to 18 years, p=0.0001) and parental quality of life (3 months to 7 years, p=0.0001, 8 to 12 years p=0.002), for children with atopic eczema. One study found video-based education more effective in improving severity than direct education and the control (discussion) (p<0.001). The single psychological study found relaxation techniques improved clinical severity as compared to the control at 20 weeks (t=2.13) but this was of borderline significance (p=0.042). A lack of rigorously designed trials (excluding one recent German study) provides only limited evidence of the effectiveness of educational and psychological interventions in helping to manage the condition of children with atopic eczema. Evidence from included studies and also adult studies indicates that different service delivery models (multi-professional eczema school and nurse-led clinics) require further and comparative evaluation to examine their cost-effectiveness and suitability for different health systems.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 84
  • 10.1002/14651858.cd011034.pub2
Psychological and educational interventions for subfertile men and women.
  • Mar 31, 2016
  • The Cochrane database of systematic reviews
  • Jolijn Verkuijlen + 4 more

Approximately one-fifth of all subfertile couples seeking fertility treatment show clinically relevant levels of anxiety, depression, or distress. Psychological and educational interventions are frequently offered to subfertile couples, but their effectiveness, both in improving mental health and pregnancy rates, is unclear. To assess the effectiveness of psychological and educational interventions for subfertile couples on psychological and fertility treatment outcomes. We searched (from inception to 2 April 2015) the Cochrane Gynaecology and Fertility Group Specialised Register of Controlled Trials, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL; Issue 2, 2015), MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, EBSCO CINAHL, DARE, Web of Science, OpenGrey, LILACS, PubMed, and ongoing trials registers. We handsearched reference lists and contacted experts in the field. We included published and unpublished randomised controlled trials (RCTs), cluster randomised trials, and cross-over trials (first phase) evaluating the effectiveness of psychological and educational interventions on psychological and fertility treatment outcomes in subfertile couples. Two review authors independently assessed trial risk of bias and extracted data. We contacted study authors for additional information. Our primary outcomes were psychological measures (anxiety and depression) and fertility rates (live birth or ongoing pregnancy). We assessed the overall quality of the evidence using GRADE criteria.As we did not consider the included studies to be sufficiently similar to permit meaningful pooling, we summarised the results of the individual studies by presenting the median and interquartile range (IQR) of effects as well as the minimum and maximum values. We calculated standardised mean differences (SMDs) for continuous variables and odds ratios (ORs) for dichotomous outcomes. We included 39 studies involving 4925 participants undergoing assisted reproductive technology. Studies were heterogeneous with respect to a number of factors, including nature and duration of interventions, participants, and comparator groups. As a result, we judged that pooling results would not result in a clinically meaningful estimate of a treatment effect. There were substantial methodological weaknesses in the studies, all of which were judged to be at high risk of bias for one or more quality assessment domains. There was concern about attrition bias (24 studies), performance bias for psychological outcomes (27 studies) and fertility outcomes (18 studies), and detection bias for psychological outcomes (26 studies). We therefore considered study-specific estimates of intervention effects to be unreliable. Thirty-three studies reported the outcome mental health. Only two studies reported the outcome live birth, and both of these had substantial attrition. One study reported ongoing pregnancy, again with substantial attrition. We have combined live birth and ongoing pregnancy in one outcome. Psychological outcomesStudies utilised a variety of measures of anxiety and depression. In all cases a low score denoted benefit from the intervention.SMDs for anxiety were as follows: psychological interventions versus attentional control or usual care: median (IQR) = -0.30 (-0.84 to 0.00), minimum value -5.13; maximum value 0.84, 17 RCTs, 2042 participants; educational interventions versus attentional control or usual care: median = 0.03, minimum value -0.38; maximum value 0.23, 4 RCTs, 330 participants.SMDs for depression were as follows: psychological interventions versus attentional control or usual care: median (IQR) = -0.45 (-0.68 to -0.08), minimum value -3.01; maximum value 1.23, 12 RCTs, 1160 participants; educational interventions versus attentional control or usual care: median = -0.33, minimum value -0.46; maximum value 0.17, 3 RCTs, 304 participants. Fertility outcomesWhen psychological interventions were compared with attentional control or usual care, ORs for live birth or ongoing pregnancy ranged from minimum value 1.13 to maximum value 10.05. No studies of educational interventions reported this outcome. The effects of psychological and educational interventions on mental health including distress, and live birth or ongoing pregnancy rates is uncertain due to the very low quality of the evidence. Existing trials of psychological and educational interventions for subfertility were generally poorly designed and executed, resulting in very serious risk of bias and serious inconsistency in study findings. There is a need for studies employing appropriate methodological techniques to investigate the benefits of these treatments for this population. In particular, attentional control groups should be employed, that is groups receiving a treatment that mimics the amount of time and attention received by the treatment group but is not thought to have a specific effect upon the participants, in order to distinguish between therapeutic and non-specific effects of interventions. Where attrition cannot be minimised, appropriate statistical techniques for handling drop-out must be applied. Failure to address these issues in study design has resulted in studies that do not provide a valid basis for answering questions about the effectiveness of these interventions.

  • Research Article
  • 10.1017/s1092852923004200
Rural tourism combined with psychological intervention on functional cognitive disorders
  • Oct 1, 2023
  • CNS Spectrums
  • Meishan Shi

BackgroundFunctional cognitive impairment, also known as cognitive impairment, can lead to severe loss of daily or social communication abilities and diagnosis of dementia. The treatment methods for functional cognitive impairment include medication, psychological training, and so on.Subjects and MethodsThe study conducted an experiment on 88 patients with functional cognitive impairment, dividing them into a control group, a psychological group, and an experimental group. The control group only received prescription medication provided by the doctor, the psychological group received social psychological intervention treatment on the basis of the control group, and the experimental group received comprehensive treatment of rural tourism projects on the basis of the psychological group. The study used the MATRICS Consensus Cognitive Battery (MCCB) and Positive and Negative Symptom Scale (PANSS) to evaluate the condition of three groups of patients after treatment, in order to analyze the therapeutic effects of different treatment plans on the patient’s condition.ResultsAs the treatment duration increases, the patient’s MCCB score gradually increases and the PANSS score gradually decreases, indicating that all three treatment regimens can improve the patient’s cognitive impairment. The MCCB and PANSS scores of the experimental group were better than those of the control group and the psychological group.ConclusionsThe effect of simple drug therapy is unclear and the treatment course is long. Combining medication with social psychology intervention training can improve the treatment effect of patients. Rural tourism projects combined with social psychological intervention present the best treatment effect.AcknowledgementThe Year of 2021 Vocational Education Teaching Reform Research Project of Shandong Province (No.2021120).

  • PDF Download Icon
  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 3
  • 10.5901/mjss.2015.v6n4s2p285
Social Psychological Interventions to Reduce the Number of Violence against Women in Indonesia
  • Jul 1, 2015
  • Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences
  • Tommy Prayoga + 8 more

This article aimed at discussing the interventions that have been made in the fight against gender injustice, and specifically the domestic violence which is widespread in Indonesia. There are three social intervention solutions conducted during October 2014 to January 2015 in Jakarta, the capital of Indonesia, as part of Social Psychology and Psychological Intervention Course Program that will be discussed in detail, namely 1) intervention toward the observer’s (bystander’s) attitude toward the violence to be a preventer of the violence (or, to be an upstander), 2) intervention eliminating women objectification among men, and 3) intervention reducing verbal violent behavior against women. All those three will be discussed in an intervention methods of PATH, a model constructed by Abraham P. Buunk and Mark Van Vugt (2013) consisting of four stages, i.e. Problem formulation (Problem), Analysis and explanation (Analyze), Test stages (Test) and Intervention implementation (Help). The intervention targets are the students, the late teens, and the young adults through 1) Handbook of Violence Prevention to offer support and assistance for the actual and potential victims of domestic violence, 2) the campaign via radio mass media for prevention of women objectification, as well as 3) the delivery of contemplative messages through shirt and pin for verbal abuse prevention. DOI: 10.5901/mjss.2015.v6n4s2p285

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 288
  • 10.1002/14651858.cd003380.pub2
Psychological and/or educational interventions for the prevention of depression in children and adolescents.
  • Apr 19, 2004
  • The Cochrane database of systematic reviews
  • Sally N Merry + 4 more

Although there is insufficient evidence to warrant the introduction of depression prevention programmes currently, results to date indicate that further study would be worthwhile. There is a need to compare interventions with a placebo or some sort of active comparison so that study participants do not know whether they are in the intervention group or not, to investigate the impact of booster sessions to see if effectiveness immediately after intervention can be prolonged, ideally for a year or longer, and to consider practical implementation of prevention programmes when choosing target populations. Until now most studies have focussed on psychological interventions. The potential effectiveness of educational interventions has not been fully investigated. Given the gender differences in prevalence, and the change in these that occurs in adolescence with a disproportionate increase in prevalence rates for girls, it is likely that girls and boys will respond differently to interventions. Although differences have been reported in studies in this review the findings are contradictory and a more definitive delineation of gender specific responses to interventions would be helpful.

  • Research Article
  • 10.1080/00220671.1980.10885221
Comparison of Pupil Achievement and Teacher Reactions in Teacher Center and Non-Teacher Center Schools
  • Jan 1, 1980
  • The Journal of Educational Research
  • Lyn Corno + 2 more

This year-long, quasi-experimental evalu ation assessed the influence of selected teacher center com ponents on student academic achievement. The study also examined differences in teacher self-ratings of effectiveness, teaching style, and use of teacher education resource mate rials across treatment groups. Results suggested that center placed student teachers and school-based teacher education coordinators were an important influence on the reading and mathematics achievement of fifth and sixth graders. Teacher use of skills training materials also positively influ enced student achievement. Center teachers were found to rate themselves higher on teaching effectiveness and flexi bility than noncenter teachers. In recent years teacher have received increas ing national attention as potentially cohesive organi zations, responsive to today's needs for preparing prospec tive teachers and training teachers in-service. There is, however, little solid research evidence to substantiate the relative effectiveness of teacher (5), and center staff have been slow to evaluate their own efforts. West Virginia's Multi-Institutional Teacher Education Center (MITEC), for example, has been in existence since 1966. The center is now operating independently of external funds, and encompasses five state colleges and universities, four out-of-state institutions, four county school districts, and the state department of education. Such a wide-scale operation needs more than process-level, opinionaire sup port. Its efforts should begin to be felt at the product level?in classrooms?as well (1, 12). Thus, the present study was designed to relate selected MITEC activities to student achievement in Kanawha County schools. Student achievement was selected as the criterion for study with full knowledge that it is a variable at least two steps removed from center influence. That is, center activi ties might be expected, first, to influence teacher class room behavior, which, in turn, influences student class room behavior and, finally, student achievement. Resources did not permit examination of all these levels of influence, so a bottom-up strategy was applied. The hope was that any center influences on student achieve ment might provide clues to classroom processes that could eventually be studied in more detail, to help explain and control the effects. To determine the MITEC components for study, two sources were examined. Center objectives and related activities were stated in the MITEC Handbook (6), and in a previously conducted, process-level evaluation (9). Among the stated objectives, the following key activities were considered likely to have a positive influence on stu dent achievement: Establish special schools as for coordi nating preservice and in-service teacher training. Such schools are designated by MITEC as laboratory centers (LLCs). These LLCs provide diverse teacher education experi ences, encourage experimental methods of class room instruction, and maintain special differen tiated staffing patterns. Student teacher placement. Student teacher placement under the tutelage of specially selected and trained supervisory teachers is one element of the differentiated staffing patterns employed in LLCs. Appointment of special school-based coordina tors (SBCs) to handle teacher training needs in schools that have student teachers. Another element of staffing in some LLCs is the appoint ment of an outstanding teacher as SBC. This This content downloaded from 157.55.39.29 on Tue, 12 Apr 2016 10:03:58 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms 124 THE JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH teacher is responsible for organizing interesting and appropriate training experiences in schools that have student teachers. Establishment of teacher education resource in LLCs. These instructional materials (IMCs) are established by SBCs for LLC schools, and contain various sorts of learning packages, books, games, skills training materials, and so on, for use by any teacher in-service and, particularly, student teachers. The influence of each of these components was exam ined at three grade levels?fourth, fifth, and sixth. Middle elementary grades were considered a more appropriate point of influence than early elementary grades, where students are still acquiring achievement-related skills. Also, few student teachers were placed in the high schools in Kanawha County. In addition to the center components, the study determined the extent to which selected teacher characteristics, specifically, teacher ratings of themselves as teachers and teaching style (studentversus teacher centered) related to student achievement. It was expected that these teacher characteristics would mediate the effects of center components on student achievement.

  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 237
  • 10.4300/jgme-d-11-00147.1
Getting Off the “Gold Standard”: Randomized Controlled Trials and Education Research
  • Sep 1, 2011
  • Journal of Graduate Medical Education
  • Gail M Sullivan

While useful in some situations, randomization is not the “gold standard” for medical education research. More important is that decisions regarding methodology precede the intervention, that adequate numbers of subjects and iterations are used, that a comparison group is included, and that limitations are addressed in a thoughtful, thorough manner. In addition, the literature demonstrates quite definitively that medical learners will learn whatever we teach and also may supplement any teaching deficits to meet certification requirements.18 Thus, to increase our understanding of effective educational interventions, a new educational intervention should be compared to another effective intervention. Unlike clinical research, a placebo arm is rarely helpful. Comparing the new educational intervention to “usual” practices is productive as long as students are not “cued” to the novelty of the research arm—which may enhance (or negatively bias) their learning—and the usual practices are well described. Whether randomized or nonrandomized, medical education studies must carefully analyze sources of bias—unforeseen confounding variables—to explain the observed results and ensure that subsequent researchers will find these results reproducible. Rather than an obligatory listing of these potential sources of error in the discussion, researchers will enhance existing knowledge through a careful and detailed analysis of sources of bias that may have affected the results.3 Equally important, research designs must include a control group, concurrent if possible, to ensure equal likelihood of exposure to nonintervention events that could bias the results. If educators begin to work together, more collaborative, multi-institutional projects, perhaps akin to “pragmatic trials,”12 may be produced in the future. This is likely to add substantially to our understanding of effective resident education.

  • PDF Download Icon
  • Research Article
  • Cite Count Icon 9
  • 10.1007/s44322-024-00022-9
Improving reporting standards in quantitative educational intervention research: introducing the CLOSER and CIDER checklists
  • Jan 1, 2025
  • Journal of New Approaches in Educational Research
  • Rebecca Upsher + 6 more

In educational research, the complexity of interventions and the diversity of contexts challenge the adequacy of existing reporting standards, primarily tailored for health interventions and randomised controlled trials. Recognising the critical need for appropriate tools to support education research, we developed two checklists: the CheckList Of Standards of reporting in Education Research (CLOSER) and the Checklist for Intervention Description of Education Research (CIDER). CLOSER was designed to guide the comprehensive reporting of quantitative educational intervention research from the abstract to the discussion for multiple study designs. Concurrently, CIDER details the precise features of educational interventions. The final refinements of CLOSER and CIDER comprise of 34 and 17 items, respectively, developed through a five-stage process, including tool adaptation, expert feedback, a 2-round modified Delphi consensus survey, and final refinements. These checklists aim to enhance the clarity of educational intervention research findings, facilitating their replicability and subsequent meaningful translation into practice and policy. This addresses the gap in educational research reporting standards and sets the stage for a more robust, evidence-informed approach to educational intervention development and evaluation.

  • Research Article
  • 10.1108/jhom-01-2025-0029
Accreditation through the eyes of nurse managers: an infinite staircase or a phenomenon that evaporates like water
  • Jun 30, 2025
  • Journal of Health Organization and Management
  • Hatice Mutlu + 1 more

This study aims to develop a comprehensive understanding of improving quality and safety in healthcare by thoroughly examining the impact of accreditation processes on hospital operations and exploring nurse managers' experiences with these processes. This study was designed as a qualitative research project. Semi-structured online interviews were employed to capture participants' subjective experiences and perspectives on the processes. Participants were purposively selected from nurse managers working in various hospitals, enabling the collection of rich and detailed data from individuals actively involved in accreditation processes. Thematic analysis was adopted for data analysis, systematically coding and categorizing the collected data into themes. This study explores the impact of employee and patient-centered approaches, communication and managerial strategies on healthcare inequalities. It reveals that while efficient workflows emerged in employee-centered approaches, high workloads and varying adaptability persisted. Patient-centered care showed strong links between patient safety, care quality and empathic communication. Team collaboration enhanced service quality and patient-staff interactions had positive effects. Resource management and institutionalization improved operational efficiency and transparency, while accreditation reduced healthcare inequalities. Despite the valuable insights offered by this study, several limitations must be acknowledged. First, the study's focus on a specific context - hospital accreditation processes in private hospitals in Turkey - restricts the generalizability of the findings to other healthcare settings or countries with different healthcare systems. The experiences and perspectives of nurse managers in public hospitals or other healthcare environments, such as primary care or long-term care facilities, were not examined and may differ significantly. Second, the study's qualitative nature indicates that its findings are based on the subjective views and experiences of a relatively small sample of nurse managers. While this approach provides in-depth insights, it does not permit the broad statistical generalizability that quantitative studies may offer. Furthermore, although efforts were made to ensure the reliability and validity of the data through thematic analysis, the interpretation of findings may still be influenced by researcher biases, primarily since the study involved a single-country context with a specific cultural and healthcare setting. Lastly, the study did not investigate the long-term effects of accreditation on healthcare systems or assess how the evolution of accreditation standards might impact future healthcare delivery. Further longitudinal studies could offer a more comprehensive understanding of the lasting effects of accreditation processes. This study offers valuable insights for nurse managers and their teams, enabling more effective resource management implementation, internal team collaboration and patient-centered strategies. Enhancing employee satisfaction and patient experience can improve healthcare quality and foster a more efficient healthcare environment. Additionally, process improvement recommendations for efficient resource utilization can boost operational efficiency in healthcare institutions. By considering these findings in strategic decision-making, managers can elevate employee and patient satisfaction. Furthermore, the insights from this study can be directly translated into practice by incorporating accreditation-focused leadership training into continuous professional development programs for nurse managers and healthcare administrators. These findings offer actionable guidance for designing hospital workflows that prioritize patient safety, communication and organizational resilience. From a policy perspective, the results support the development of flexible accreditation frameworks that align with local healthcare system capacities and workforce realities. In an educational context, integrating accreditation concepts into nursing and healthcare management curricula can better prepare future professionals for leadership roles. Societally, improving transparency, patient trust and equity through accreditation processes can enhance public confidence in healthcare systems and contribute to greater healthcare accessibility and quality of life improvements across communities. These implications are consistent with the findings and conclusions of the study, highlighting the potential for research to bridge theory and practice effectively while promoting tangible advancements in healthcare delivery and public health outcomes. This research underscores the societal impact of workforce management and patient care in the healthcare sector. Balancing healthcare workers' workloads and working conditions improves their quality of life and positively influences patient care. Fostering a strong culture of collaboration among staff enhances healthcare service effectiveness and boosts patient satisfaction, contributing to healthier individuals and increasing trust in health systems. Moreover, institutional transparency and effective communication can elevate public acceptance and trust in healthcare services. Strengthening the right to quality care ensures equitable access to health services, playing a crucial role in meeting the health needs of all societal segments and reinforcing public trust in the health system. This study provides a novel view on hospital accreditation by exploring the experiences of nurse managers, who are often overlooked yet central to healthcare operations. Unlike studies that use mostly quantitative methods or focus on institutional outcomes, it captures the real-life insights of nurse managers, highlighting both human and organizational aspects of accreditation. This qualitative exploration, grounded in thematic analysis, distinctly highlights an often-overlooked stakeholder group. It addresses a gap in previous research where the subjective experiences and operational challenges faced by nurse managers during accreditation processes have remained underexplored.

Save Icon
Up Arrow
Open/Close
Notes

Save Important notes in documents

Highlight text to save as a note, or write notes directly

You can also access these Documents in Paperpal, our AI writing tool

Powered by our AI Writing Assistant