Review of the hydrocarbon potential of the Steele Shale and Niobrara Formation in Wyoming, USA: A major unconventional resource play?

Abstract

The study area, located in the northern rim of the Greater Green River Basin, Wyoming, is a large anticlinal feature with a complex structural history and extensive fracturing. The targets are the Late Cretaceous Steele Shale and the Niobrara Formation, having a combined thickness of 3700–4900ft. The productive intervals have a depth ranging from 8500 to 13,000ft. Total Organic Carbon content in one of the wells drilled, the Bare Ring Butte 4–36, ranges from 0.5wt.% to 4.0wt.% and averages 2.0wt.%. Hydrogen Index ranges from 50 to 220mg HC/g TOC. Gas content averages 30scf/t (as-received) and porosity for the inferred pay zone is estimated at 3–6%. Matrix permeability is low, estimated to be 130nD (nano-Darcy). Mineralogy in the above well consists of 40wt.% quartz, with illite, fracture-filling calcite and chlorite also present. The shales are overpressured, have a gradient of 0.7psi/ft., and they lie within the oil and condensate liquids windows. At Bare Ring Butte 4–36, vitrinite reflectance (%Ro, maximum) ranges from 0.85% at 8000ft. to 1.20% at 10,200ft. A distinct change in the maturation and vitrinite reflectance gradients with depth is evident in this well, which coincides with the top of the overpressure zone. The overpressure zone has a thin wet (oil) zone (34–46° API) at the top, followed by a thick gas-saturated zone underneath. A similar trend was also seen in at least four more wells in the Antelope Arch area. Using an imaging tool, three highly-fractured zones with a combined thickness of 600ft. have been identified in the Steele/Niobrara interval in the Bare Ring Butte 4–36 well. The recoverable gas resource is estimated to be 5Bcf/160acres (1/4 section) using a recovery factor of only 5%. In the early 1980s, vertical wells tested 1.4 to 3.7Mmcf/d following natural completion in the Steele Shale and Niobrara Formation. The closest analogue to the Steele Shale and Niobrara Formation is the stratigraphically-equivalent Baxter Shale in Wyoming. Questar E&P has drilled a number of vertical and horizontal wells in the Baxter Shale. Vertical wells that targeted fractured zones had IP (initial production) rates ranging from 1.8 to 9Mmcf/d. Questar estimated a EUR (estimated ultimate recovery) of 8–16Bcf for vertical wells drilled on 160-acres with recovery factors of 7–15%. A horizontal well (3000ft. long) that encountered a natural fracture swarm had an IP rate of 9.1Mmcf/d in the first 4–5days before it stabilized at 2.7Mmcf/d. With today's improved drilling and stimulation techniques, horizontal wells targeting the highly-fractured zones could improve productivity considerably. Because of the great thickness, highly-fractured character, and overpressured nature, the Steele Shale and Niobrara Formation could have greater resource potential than the normally-pressured Barnett Shale in the core area of the Fort Worth Basin.