Question banks: credit? Or debit? A qualitative exploration of their use among medical students

Abstract

BackgroundOnline question banks are the most widely used education resource amongst medical students. Despite this there is an absence of literature outlining how and why they are used by students. Drawing on Deci and Ryan’s self-determination theory, our study aimed to explore why and how early-stage medical students use question banks in their learning and revision strategies.MethodsThe study was conducted at Newcastle University Medical School (United Kingdom and Malaysia). Purposive, convenience and snowball sampling of year two students were employed. Ten interviews were conducted. Thematic analysis was undertaken iteratively, enabling exploration of nascent themes. Data collection ceased when no new perspectives were identified.ResultsStudents’ motivation to use question banks was predominantly driven by extrinsic motivators, with high-stakes exams and fear of failure being central. Their convenience and perceived efficiency promoted autonomy and thus motivation. Rapid feedback cycles and design features consistent with gamification were deterrents to intrinsic motivation. Potentially detrimental patterns of question bank use were evident: cueing, avoidance and memorising. Scepticism regarding veracity of question bank content was absent.ConclusionsWe call on educators to provide students with guidance about potential pitfalls associated with question banks and to reflect on potential inequity of access to these resources.