Palaeoecology of transported brachiopod assemblages embedded in black shale, Cape Phillips Formation (Silurian), Arctic Canada

Abstract

Brachiopod communities have been widely used for palaeoecological studies and reconstruction of sea-level changes in Earth history. Previous studies of brachiopod communities emphasised sampling benthic shelly fossils preserved in situ to avoid preservation bias. Silurian (Wenlock) brachiopod assemblages are well preserved as debris-turbidity flows, including calcareous concretions, embedded in thick sequences of black shale of the Cape Phillips Formation, with a mixture of deep-water brachiopods and transported shallow-water forms. In this study, the first attempt is made to use the transported assemblages to reconstruct Silurian brachiopod communities that once lived along a palaeogradient from the shallow-water Arctic Platform to the deep-water Franklinian Basin. Seven transported brachiopod assemblages were recognised using multivariate analyses (cluster analysis and principal components analysis), with varying ratios of shallow- versus deep-water shells, segregated according to their known palaeobathymetric ranges in other regions. The Wenlock–early Ludlow sea-level fluctuations in the study area, reconstructed using the percentage values of shallow- and deep-water brachiopod specimens as a proxy, have a high degree of agreement with the Arctic Silurian sea-level curve and moderate agreements with global sea-level histories of other regions such as the British Isles and Gotland interpreted from graptolite abundance and diversity changes, and sequence and event stratigraphical methods, respectively.