Oval window atresia: A novel surgical approach and pathognomonic radiological finding

Objective: To summarize the clinical features and postoperative efficacy of patients with oval window atresia accompanied by facial nerve aberration. Methods: The clinical data of patients with congenital middle ear malformation with facial nerve aberration admitted to our hospital from January 2015 to March 2023 were retrospectively analyzed. There were 97 cases (133 ears) in total. Among them, 39 patients (44 ears) had complete follow-up data, including 27 male patients and 12 females, aged 7-48 years old, with an average age of 17.8 years old. Of these, 14 cases (16 ears) were patients combined with facial nerve aberration, and 25 cases (28 ears) were without facial nerve aberration. The results of imaging examination, pure-tone audiometry, selection of surgical strategy, intraoperative findings and postoperative hearing improvement were summarized and analyzed. The malformations of malleus, incus, stapes, oval window and facial nerve were recorded. Prism 9 software was used to statistically analyze the mean bone conductance and air-bone gap of patients before and after surgery. Results: All the 14 patients (16 ears) with middle ear malformation accompanied by facial nerve aberration and oval window atresia showed poor hearing and no facial palsy since childhood. High resolution CT (HRCT) examination of temporal bone, pure tone audiometry and Gelle test were performed before surgery. The malformations of malleus, incus, stapes, oval window and facial nerve were recorded. Preoperative high-resolution CT (HRCT) examination of temporal bone found 12 ears with 4 or more deformities, accounting for 75.00%, in the group of patients with facial nerve malformation. The preoperative average bone conductive threshold was (15.3±10.4) dB and the average air-bone gap was (46.3±10.6) dB in pure-tone audiometry (0.5, 1, 2, 4kHz). According to the different degrees of facial nerve and ossicle malformation, we performed three different hearing reconstruction strategies for the 14 patients (16 ears) with facial nerve aberration and oval window atresia, including 7 ears of incus bypass artificial stape implantation, 7 ears of Malleostapedotomy (MS) and 2 ears of Malleus-cochlear-prothesis (MCP). After 3 months to 18 months of follow-up, all patients showed no facial paralysis. The postoperative mean bone conductive threshold was (15.7±7.9) dB and air-bone gap was (19.8±8.5) dB. There were significant differences in mean air-bone gap before and after operation (t=7.766, P<0.05), and there was no significant difference between the mean bone conductive threshold before and after surgery (t=0.225, P=0.824). There was no significant difference of mean reduction of air-bone gap between patients with and without facial nerve aberration (t=1.412, P=0.165). There was no significant difference between the three hearing reconstruction strategies. There was no significant displacement of the Piston examined by U-HRCT. Conclusion: For patients of middle ear malformation whose facial nerve cover the oval window partially, incus bypass artificial stape implantation or Malleostapedotomy (MS) can be selected according to the specific condition of auditory ossis malformation, and for patients whose facial nerve completely covers the oval window area, Malleus-cochlear-prothesis (MCP) can be selected. Three types of stapes surgery are safe and reliable for patients with oval window atresia accompanied by facial nerve aberration. There was no significant difference in efficacy between them. Preoperative HRCT assessment of middle ear malformation is effective. There is no significant difference of surgical effect with or without facial nerve aberration. The U-HRCT can be used to evaluate the middle ear malformation before surgery and the Piston implantation status after surgery. Due to the risks of surgery, those who do not want to undergo surgery can choose artificial hearing AIDS, such as hearing aid, vibrating soundbridge, bone bridge or bone-anchored hearing aid.

The purpose of this study is to categorize anomalous tympanic facial nerve (FN) on high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) and to determinate the significance of associated temporal bone anomalies and congenital syndromes without microtia in patients with hearing loss. A retrospective analysis of HRCT findings in 30 temporal bones in 18 patients with anomalous FN was performed. Abnormalities of the tympanic FN were categorized as follows: category 1: FN medially positioned, but above the oval window; category 2: FN in the oval window niche; and category 3: FN below the oval window. Potential associated findings that were assessed included stapes abnormalities, oval window atresia, and inner ear anomalies, as well as the presence of a known congenital syndrome with hearing loss. The most common type of anomalous tympanic FN was category 1 (67%, n = 20), following by group 2 (20%, n = 6) and group 3 (13%, n = 4). Stapes anomalies were detected in 77% of temporal bones (n = 23), oval window atresia was detected in 43% of temporal bones (n = 13), and inner ear anomalies were detected in 70% of temporal bones (n = 21). Anomalous tympanic facial nerves in temporal bone with conductive hearing loss were often (60%) not associated with oval window atresia. The combination of aberrant tympanic FN and inner ear anomalies was significantly (P = .038) associated with a known congenital syndrome (6 patients), including CHARGE syndrome, oculo-auriculo-vertebral spectrum, Pierre-Robin sequences, and Down syndrome. Therefore, an anomalous tympanic FN in conjunction with inner ear anomalies appears to be a biomarker for certain congenital syndromes with hearing loss in the absence of microtia.

Isolated oval window atresia (OWA) is a rare cause of congenital conductive middle ear deafness and may be overlooked owing to the normal appearance of the external ear. This anomaly has been previously described, although the published numbers with both imaging and surgical findings are few. Our aim is to correlate the imaging features of OWA with intraoperative findings. This is a single-centre retrospective evaluation of patients who were diagnosed with OWA and who received surgery from January 1999 to July 2006. No new case was diagnosed after 2006 to the time of preparation of this manuscript. High resolution computed tomography (HRCT) imaging of the temporal bones of the patients were retrospectively evaluated by 2 head and neck radiologists. Images were evaluated for the absence of the oval window, ossicular chain abnormalities, position of the facial nerve canal, and other malformations. Imaging findings were then correlated with surgical findings. A total of 9 ears in 7 patients (two of whom with bilateral lesions) had surgery for OWA. All patients had concomitant findings of absent stapes footplate with normal, deformed or absent stapes superstructure and an inferiorly displaced facial nerve canal. HRCT was sensitive in identifying OWA and associated ossicular chain and facial nerve abnormalities, which were documented surgically. OWA is a rare entity that can be diagnosed with certainty on HRCT, best visualised on coronal plane. Imaging findings of associated middle ear abnormalities, position of the facial nerve canal, which is invariably mal-positioned, and associated deformity of the incus are important for presurgical planning and consent.

Oval window atresia (OWA) is a rare otologic condition often associated with a maximal conductive hearing loss, and variable ossicular and facial nerve canal (FNC) anomalies, which have contributed to suboptimal middle ear surgical outcomes. No grading scheme exists to detail the spectrum of associated temporal bone anomalies in OWA; therefore, our objectives were to complete an audiometric and radiographic review to characterize audiometric patterns of hearing loss, and refine the classification system for OWA to determine suitability for middle ear surgery. A retrospective audiometric and radiographic review was conducted at a pediatric tertiary care institution. Patients with OWA identified on temporal bone computerized tomography (CT) scans obtained from 01/2010 to 06/2024 were included. Audiological, radiological, and patient factors were analyzed. Thirty-one patients (48 ears) with OWA were identified. Across frequencies, the air-bone gap decreased significantly as frequency increased (ANOVA with pairwise comparisons, p < 0.001) due to a worsening of bone conduction thresholds and improvement in air conduction thresholds. The FNC was abnormal in 43/48 ears and was determined to overlay the oval window in 6 ears. Additional anomalies included inferiorly displaced, dehiscent, and duplicated canals. Ossicular anomalies were reported in 46/48 ears, and stapedial anomalies were most common. Our findings indicate OWA may manifest audiometrically with consistent and specific hearing loss characterized by a 60-80 dB ABG at lower frequencies that decreases above 2 kHz. CT findings of OWA show considerable variability. We propose a new classification system for OWA based on facial nerve position as this directly influences middle ear surgical feasibility.

Oval window atresia is often accompanied by malpositioned facial nerve, when inferiorly located facial nerve occupies the expected site of oval window, the ossicular chain reconstruction will always be abandoned. We report the case of a 12-year-old boy with one-side middle ear deformity and hearing loss. Under surgical exploration, the tympanic segment of facial nerve occupied the entire atresia plate, we created a hole on the bony basal turn of the cochlear immediately above the round window, a hand modeled titanium stapes prosthesis was used between the handle of malleus and cochleostomy opening. The audiogram showed an average hearing improvement of 36 dBHL three months later postoperatively. For the case with oval window atresia and inferiorly located facial nerve, cochleostomy could be an effective alternative fenestration site for ossicular chain reconstruction. The prosthesis shaping is always needed for better sound conduction.

Scala tympani drill-out technique for oval window atresia with malformed facial nerve: A report of three cases

The purpose of this study is to offer new data about facial nerve malformations in the tympanic cavity. Prospective anatomic study of newborns to demonstrate the submacroscopic anatomy of the intratympanic facial nerve and its surrounding structures by malformations. Step-by-step microdissection of 12 newborn temporal bones and histologic evaluation of 4 middle ears showing multiple malformations. Four of 12 temporal bones presented malformation in the middle ear. All 4 temporal bones showed developmental failures of the stapes, and 3 of them had malposition of the tympanic portion of the facial nerve. In 3 cases, there was an oval window atresia, and in 1 case, the rim of the oval window was not ossified and was positioned medial to the stapes. Malformation or displacement of the stapes can be an indirect sign for facial nerve malformation. The most common site for facial nerve malformation is the tympanic portion. The tympanic segment of the nerve is devoid of bony covering in association with these anomalies of the stapes.

Perioperative Hearing Impairment

Branchio-oto-renal syndrome (BOR) is an autosomal dominant mutation of the EYA1 and the more recently discovered the SIX1 gene.1 The phenotype and syndrome were comprehensively described by Melnick in 1975 to include hearing loss, auricular malformations, branchial arch remnants, and renal anomalies.2 The diagnosis of BOR is made using major and minor criteria as defined by Chang et al 2004.3 However, 60% of patients who meet phenotypic criteria do not have an identifiable mutation in the EYA1 gene, leading to recent interest in the EYA-SIX regulatory system.1 The most common manifestations include hearing loss (98.5%), preauricular pits (83.6%), branchial anomalies (68.5%), renal anomalies (38.2%), and external ear abnormalities (31.5%). In terms of the imaging characteristics, the most sensitive modality remains CT of the temporal bones. The most commonly reported anomalies on temporal bone imaging include but are not limited to 1)hypoplastic apical turn of the cochlea, 2) facial nerve deviated to the medial side of the cochlea, 3) funnel-shaped internal auditory canal, and 4) patulous eustachian tube. 4 The spectrum of hearing loss in BOR is variable but most commonly presents with mixed hearing loss (50%), pure sensorineural hearing loss (25%) and pure conductive hearing loss (25%) 5. The conductive component of the hearing loss is most often the result of ossicular chain abnormalities. A 42 year old male previously diagnosed with BOR using clinical criteria presented with a conductive hearing loss. His physical exam demonstrated small external auditory canals with a normal tympanic membrane. His audiogram demonstrated a mild left sensorineural hearing loss and a maximal conductive hearing loss in the right ear. Imaging with CT revealed several findings consisted with BOR: Bilateral enlarged air-filled eustachian tubes extending from the middle ear to the nasopharynx, a widened and flared internal acoustic meatus with the nervus intermedius extending into a funnel shaped labyrinthine segment of the temporal bone and hypo-plastic horizontal canal, hypo-plastic vestibular system/epitympanum, and lateral position of the facial nerve. The incus and malleus were malformed and fixed in the attic (Fig. 1). Figure 1 Computed tomography (CT) images. Panel A: Axial view of the head demonstrating enlarged eustachian tubes (arrow). Panel B: Axial view of right internal auditory (IAC) canal demonstrating hypoplastic horizontal semicircular canal(H), and funnel shaped ... Despite the findings on CT, the patient elected to pursue a middle ear exploration prior to pursuing other rehabilitative options. At surgery, middle ear exploration revealed a very small oval window niche with no clear oval window, or stapes footplate as shown on this view with a 30° endoscope (Fig. 2). The round window niche was visible. A dehiscent facial nerve was visible at the horizontal segment. Because no mobile footplate was found there was no attempt at ossiculoplasty. The patient recovered from surgery with no change in his hearing and later went on to a Baha which he found beneficial. Figure 2 Right middle ear as viewed through a 30° endoscope during surgery. There was no clear stapes footplate, but a narrow oval window (OW) niche. The round window (RW) niche was visible. The OW and RW are labeled to the right above the structures. ... The extreme ossicular abnormalities in this patient with BOR made his maximal conductive hearing loss not amenable to ossiculoplasty. We ultimately failed in our attempt to restore his conductive hearing loss due to agenesis of the oval window and lack of a mobile footplate. The intraoperative endoscopy revelaed the lack of suitable anatomy for an ossicular replacement prosthesis. The findings in our patient highlight the diagnostic findings in BOR on CT scan of the temporal bone and correlate well with his clinical findings. Although BOR patients may not be a homogeneous in terms of their middle ear anatomy, this patient suggests ossiculoplasty may not be a viable option in this population.

Facial nerve anomalies in association with congenital hearing loss

The patient’s imaging features, especially the honeycomb pattern of ossific changes in the geniculate fossa, were virtually pathognomonic for ossifying hemangioma of the facial nerve.

Introduction: Although operating microscope is used worldwide for stapes surgery, the use of endoscopes would provide much benefit such as good panoramic view of middle ear and easy accessibility of the oval window area, stapes, and facial nerve. Objective: We aimed to analyze our experiences of endoscopic transcanal stapedotomy performed at a tertiary care teaching hospital of Eastern India. Materials and Methods: This prospective study was done at the Department of Otorhinolaryngology between March 2017 and April 2019. The patients were diagnosed as having otosclerosis with fulfilling the selection criteria. All underwent endoscopic transcanal stapedotomy. Results: Out of 52 patients those underwent endoscopic transcanal stapedotomy, there were 28 females and 24 males. The mean age was 32.40 years. The mean operation time was 35.43 min. The mean preoperative air–bone gap (ABG) was 34.84 dB, whereas the mean postoperative ABG was 9.81 dB. Tympanomeatal flap tear was seen in one case. One case showed chorda tympani injury and two patients presented with vertigo after surgery. No other complications were seen after endoscopic stapedotomy. Conclusion: The important advantages of endoscopic stapedotomy are good-quality visualization with identification of vital parts of the middle ear cleft, minimal handling to the chorda tympani nerve with almost no curettage of the scutum. The development of endoscopic ear surgery techniques promises the change the way we approach for stapes surgery. The wide field view of endoscope helps the surgeon to visualize better the middle ear recess, especially oval window niche and stapes.

Objective: To analyze the clinical characteristics and appropriate surgical procedures, and discuss the classification of congenital middle ear malformation. Methods: All cases were from the Center of Otorhinolaryngology, the Sixth Medical Center of Department of PLA General Hospital. All of these cases, including 26 male patients (ears) , 10 female patients (11 ears) , aged from 7 to 57 years old, had normal external auditory canal, tympanic membrane, conductive hearing loss, type A tympanogram and negative Gelle's test. Tympanoplasty was performed in all cases. The deformity was classified to three types,i.e., Type I (stapes foot plate mobility): Ⅰa, ossicular chain deformity with normal stapes suprastructure; Ⅰb, ossicular chain deformity with abnormal stapes suprastructure; Type Ⅱ (stapes foot plate fixation): Ⅱ a,normal ossicular chain, Ⅱ b, ossicular chain malformation; and Type Ⅲ: vestibular window osseous atresia or undeveloped, or with round window atresia. The malformation of type Ⅱ and Ⅲ may be accompanied with abnormal facial nerve. In addition, the papers on middle ear malformation published from 1982 to 2017 were analyzed retrospectively. The clinical data of 451 ears malformation were summarized. Results: According to the revisional classification criteria in 37 ear samples from our hospital, 20 ears were type I. 6 type Ⅰa cases were used PORP (partial ossicular replacement prosthesis) to reconstruct the ossicular chain; 14 type Ⅰb cases were used TORP (total ossicular replacement prosthesis) to reconstruct the ossicular chain. For the 5 ears of type Ⅱ, 2 of which were type Ⅱ a and 3 were type Ⅱ b. 4 ear samples of type Ⅱ were implanted with Piston ossicular prosthesis, 1 was implanted with TORP in which the ossificated foot plate was removed with periosteum preserved. 12 ear samples were type Ⅲ, with vestibular window osseous atresia, facial nerve malformation, and stapes suprastructure malformation. The pistons ossicular prosthesis were implanted in vestibular window in 3 ears with facial nerve covering vestibular window partially. The surgery had to be given up in 5 ears, and TORP was implanted in 4 ears at the opening with preserved periosteum at the beginning of the tympanic scala because of facial nerve covering vestibular window totally. 30 ears with complete follow-up data had no sensorineural hearing loss and the average air-bone conduction decreased 23.3±10.7 dB (P<0.05).There were 234 ears of type Ⅰ in 451 ears of congenital middle ear malformation reported in the literature. 113 of which were type Ⅰa, the basic surgery was ossicular chain shaking and artificial or autogenous PORP implantation. Type Ⅰb was 121 ears, with autogenous or artificial TORP and PORP. Type Ⅱ was125 ears, including type Ⅱa 22 ears, Ⅱb 60 ears, and no subclassification for 43 ears. The surgery of type Ⅱ was the same as otosclerosis. The vestibular window atresia of type Ⅲ was 92 ears, the surgery of 17 ears had to be abandoned, the other ears underwent vestibular window, promontory or semicircular canal opening to reconstruct hearing with Piston, autogenous or artificial TORP. Conclusion: Referring to the classification of congenital middle ear malformation combining with appropriate surgical materials and methods, otologists can better understand and choose appropriate surgical method to the middle ear malformation.

Background: Simple or non-syndromic types of oval window (OW) or round window (RW) atresia are relatively rare in clinical. Few studies have assessed bone conduction (BC) hearing in OW or RW atresia patients, with some reporting that BC hearing lies within the normal range, whereas others observing impaired BC hearing.Aims/Objectives: This study explored the effect of blocking the OW and RW during BC in cat models.Material and Methods: Twenty-four cats were randomly divided into three immobilization groups (OW blockage, RW blockage, and OW + RW blockage) and control group. Each immobilization group also had the initial control state before blockage. Medical adhesive and ear mould glue were used to immobilise the stapes footplate and RW, respectively. Comparisons were made of the auditory brainstem response (ABR) thresholds before and after immobilization for the three immobilization groups during three different stimuli [air conduction (AC) click, BC click, and BC pure tones].Results: The AC click thresholds increased after immobilisation in three experimental groups compared to the control group (p < .05). The AC click thresholds increased compared to their initial control state after all three immobilization groups (p < .05). With an increase in frequency from 2 to 8 kHz, there was a general decrease in the difference between pre- and post-immobilization BC hearing thresholds in all three immobilization groups. The BC click threshold and BC tone thresholds at 2–4 kHz in both OW blockage and OW + RW blockage groups exceeded those in RW blockage group (p < .05).Conclusions and Significance: The use of medical adhesive and ear mould glue for the blockages of OW and RW, respectively in cats was feasible. The effect of blocking the OW and RW in BC hearing was larger at low frequencies than high frequencies between 2 and 8 kHz. OW blockage had a greater effect than RW blockage on BC hearing at 2–4 kHz range.

Objective: To present the results of our experience with labyrinthotomy or vestibulotomy in cases where the oval window is blocked by the facial nerve and in the presence of bilateral congenital agenesis of the oval window, respectively. Study design: Retrospective analysis of the records of the patients operated in two different centers. Methods: Between 2007 and 2012, 5 ears of 4 patients who were operated on in two different clinics with a presumptive diagnosis of otosclerosis were included in the study. There were 3 female patients and 1 male. The ages ranged from 10 to 26 (mean 19 years). All patients had unilateral conductive hearing loss except 1 (10-year-old girl or patient 1). Pure tone averages were calculated at the frequencies 0.5, 1, 2 and 4 kHz both pre- and postoperatively according to the Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium 1995 Guidelines for the Evaluation of Results of Treatment of Conductive Hearing Loss. All patients underwent a middle ear exploration and postoperatively the initial audiological examination was performed after 6 months. Results: Retrospective analysis revealed that vestibulotomy or labyrinthotomy was performed in 5 ears of 4 patients. Postoperative dizziness was encountered in 2 patients who had vestibulotomy due to oval window agenesis, which ceased spontaneously at 1 month postoperatively. The perioperative period was otherwise uneventful. None of the patients had sensorineural hearing loss or deterioration of hearing. There was a significant improvement in hearing after the operation. A 28-dB improvement in the mean air conduction pure tone thresholds was achieved. Conclusion: Vestibulotomy and labyrinthotomy are safe and effective procedures in terms of hearing restoration, which can be applied in cases of congenital agenesis of the oval window or obstruction of the oval window by the facial nerve.