‘Our story with the state’: Birth certificates, data structures and gay and lesbian families

Abstract

Birth certificate data has been identified for its centrality in providing complete and accurate information on demographics, particularly as it relates to families. Often, however, these forms of data collection, are very much hetero-centric, re-embedding normative conceptualizations of identity, particularly as it relates to sex, gender and sexuality. Modes of demographic data collection, such as that of the birth certificate, do not allow for the fluidity and multiplicity of gender and sexual identities that characterize the lived experience of many LGBTQ families. This article will explore the significance of the birth certificate for LGBTQ Irish families, particularly in light of the varying inequalities that emerge from the data gaps they create for both parent and child. In exploring these facets, this article draws upon qualitative semi-structured interviews with LGBTQ parents, exploring how they see the data gaps that emerge on birth certificates and the effects these gaps have on them as an LGBTQ family. Through exploring the ways in which the data gaps and omissions on the Irish birth certificate creates inequalities, this article uses the findings to build on the work of Ruberg and Ruellos (2020) who call for shifting how we see and understand queer identity through data. Through these findings, we argue that systems of data collection, data structures and certification must be changed to build data for queer parenthood and that it is necessary to recalibrate how we design birth certificates to more accurately represent LGBTQ-parent families.