Nailing versus plating in thoracic trauma: an experimental study in sheep.

Abstract

In this study, femoral intramedullary pressure, fat embolization, and pulmonary response were measured during reamed and unreamed nailing and plating of femoral fractures after blunt thoracic trauma. Intramedullary peak pressures of 425 mm Hg (mean 205 mm Hg) occurred in the reamed nail group (group I) during reaming with the 9-mm reamer, while in the unreamed nail group (group II) peak values were seen during nail insertion (330 mm Hg) with a mean of 203 mm Hg. Plating never led to a pressure rise over 67 mm Hg (mean 37 mm Hg). In reamed nailing, the most intense embolism was identified under ultrasound imaging with the large awl and with the 9.0-mm reamer (mean 2.2) and in the unreamed nail group during nail insertion (mean 2.8). Minimal echoes appeared during plating. The pulmonary arterial pressure did not vary significantly postoperatively between the three groups (p < 0.08). Our findings indicate that intramedullary fracture fixation causes a higher increase of intramedullary pressure and more fat and bone marrow embolization than extramedullary ones. Nevertheless, only minimal differences in the pulmonary hemodynamic response (pulmonary arterial pressure) were noted even in the presence of thoracic trauma.