Multiple geographic breakdown events of the Rpv1-Rpv3.1 pyramided resistance in grapevine by Plasmopara viticola.

Grapevine downy mildew, caused by the oomycete Plasmopara viticola (P. viticola, Berk. & M. A. Curtis; Berl. & De Toni), is a global threat to Eurasian wine grapes Vitis vinifera. Although resistant grapevine varieties are becoming more accessible, P. viticola populations are rapidly evolving to overcome these resistances. We aimed to uncover avirulence genes related to Rpv3.1-mediated grapevine resistance. We sequenced the genomes and characterized the development of 136 P. viticola strains on resistant and sensitive grapevine cultivars. A genome-wide association study was conducted to identify genomic variations associated with resistant-breaking phenotypes. We identified a genomic region associated with the breakdown of Rpv3.1 grapevine resistance (avrRpv3.1 locus). A diploid-aware reassembly of the P. viticola INRA-Pv221 genome revealed structural variations in this locus, including a 30 kbp deletion. Virulent P. viticola strains displayed multiple deletions on both haplotypes at the avrRpv3.1 locus. These deletions involve two paralog genes coding for proteins with 800-900 amino acids and signal peptides. These proteins exhibited a structure featuring LWY-fold structural modules, common among oomycete effectors. When transiently expressed, these proteins induced cell death in grapevines carrying Rpv3.1 resistance, confirming their avirulence nature. This discovery sheds light on the genetic mechanisms enabling P. viticola to adapt to grapevine resistance, laying a foundation for developing strategies to manage this destructive crop pathogen.

Vitis vinifera (grapevine) is the most economically important deciduous fruit crop, but cultivated grapevine varieties lack adequate innate immunity to a range of devastating diseases. To identify genetic resources for grapevine innate immunity and understand pathogen defense pathways in a woody perennial plant, we focus in this study on orthologs of the central Arabidopsis thaliana defense regulator ENHANCED DISEASE SUSCEPTIBILITY1 (EDS1). The family of EDS1-like genes is expanded in grapevine, and members of this family were previously found to be constitutively upregulated in the resistant variety 'Norton' of the North American grapevine species Vitis aestivalis, while they were induced by Erysiphe necator, the causal agent of grapevine powdery mildew (PM), in the susceptible V. vinifera variety 'Cabernet Sauvignon'. Here, we determine the responsiveness of individual EDS1-like genes in grapevine to PM and salicylic acid, and find that EDS1-like paralogs are differentially regulated in 'Cabernet Sauvignon', while two are constitutively upregulated in 'Norton'. Sequencing of VvEDS1 and VaEDS1 cDNA and genomic clones revealed high conservation in the protein-encoding sequence and some divergence of the promoter sequence in the two grapevine varieties. Complementation of the Arabidopsis eds1-1 mutant showed that the EDS1-like gene with highest predicted amino acid sequence similarity to AtEDS1 from either grapevine varieties is a functional ortholog of AtEDS1. Together, our analyses show that differential susceptibility to PM is correlated with differences in EDS1 expression, not differences in EDS1 function, between resistant 'Norton' and susceptible 'Cabernet Sauvignon'.

Grapevine varieties showing partial resistance to downy mildew, caused by Plasmopara viticola, are a promising alternative to fungicides for disease control. Resistant varieties are obtained through breeding programs aimed at incorporating Rpv loci controlling the quantitative resistance into genotypes characterized by valuable agronomic and wine quality traits by mean of crossing. Traditional phenotyping methods used in these breeding programs are mostly based on the assessment of the resistance level after artificial inoculation of leaf discs in bioassays, by using the visual score proposed in the 2nd Edition of the International Organization of Vine and Wine (OIV) Descriptor List for Grape Varieties and Vitis species (2009). In this work, the OIV score was compared with an alternative approach, not used for the grapevine-downy mildew pathosystem so far, based on the measurement of components of resistance (RCs); 15 grapevine resistant varieties were used in comparison with the susceptible variety ‘Merlot’. OIV scores were significantly correlated with P. viticola infection frequency (IFR), the latent period for the downy mildew (DM) lesions to appear (LP50), and the number of sporangia produced per lesion (SPOR), so that when the OIV score increased (i.e., the resistance level increases), IFR and SPOR decreased, while LP50 increased. The relationship was linear for LP50, monomolecular for IFR and hyperbolic for SPOR. No significant correlation was found between OIV score and DM lesion size, sporangia produced per unit area of lesion, length of infectious period, and infection efficiency of the sporangia produced on DM lesions. The correlation between OIV score and area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) calculated by using the RCs and a simulation model was significant and fit an inverse exponential function. Based on the results of this study, the measurement of the RCs to P. viticola in grapevine varieties by means of monocyclic, leaf disc bioassays, as well as their incorporation into a model able to simulate their effect on the polycyclic development of DM epidemics in vineyards, represents an improved method for phenotyping resistance level.

Protease inhibitors decrease the resistance of Vitaceae to Plasmopara viticola

BackgroundPapain-like cysteine proteases (PLCPs), a large group of cysteine proteases, are structurally related to papain. The members belonging to PLCPs family contribute to plant immunity, senescence, and defense responses in plants. The PLCP gene family has been identified in Arabidopsis, rice, soybean, and cotton. However, no systematic analysis of PLCP genes has been undertaken in grapevine. Since Plasmopara viticola as a destructive pathogen could affect immunity of grapes in the field, we considered that the members belonged to PLCPs family could play a crucial role in defensive mechanisms or programmed cell death. We aimed to evaluate the role of PLCPs in 2 different varieties of grapevines and compared the changes of their expressions with the transcriptional data in response to P. viticola.ResultsIn this study, 23 grapevine PLCP (VvPLCP) genes were identified by comprehensive bioinformatics analysis. Subsequently, the chromosomal localizations, gene structure, conserved domains, phylogenetic relationship, gene duplication, and cis-acting elements were analyzed. Numerous cis-acting elements related to plant development, hormone, and stress responses were identified in the promoter of the VvPLCP genes. Phylogenetic analysis grouped the VvPLCP genes into nine subgroups. The transcription of VvPLCP in different inoculation time points and varieties indicated that VvPLCP may have vital functions in grapevine defense against Plasmopara viticola. According to transcriptome data and qPCR analysis, we observed the increasing expression levels of VvRD21–1 at 72 h after inoculation in resistant variety, inferring that it was related to grape downy mildew resistance. Meanwhile, 3 genes including VvXBCP1, VvSAG12–1, and VvALP1 showed higher expression at 24 h after pathogen inoculation in the susceptible variety and might be related to the downy mildew phenotype. We nominated these four genes to function during hypersensitive response (HR) process, inferring that these genes could be associated with downy mildew resistance in grapes.ConclusionsOur results provide the reference for functional studies of PLCP gene family, and highlight its functions in grapevine defense against P. viticola. The results help us to better understand the complexity of the PLCP gene family in plant immunity and provide valuable information for future functional characterization of specific genes in grapevine.

Biomarkers for the prediction of the resistance and susceptibility of grapevine leaves to downy mildew

The biotrophic oomycete Plasmopara viticola is the causal agent of downy mildew, one of the major grapevine diseases. We report here a successful strategy to cross compatible strains of this pathogen and obtain a large viable progeny. We used this method to study the offspring between two P. viticola strains able to overcome two major grapevine resistance factors (Rpv3, Rpv10). Thanks to the genomic resources now available, we will genotype this progeny to build an unprecedented linkage map and uncover the genomic bases of grapevine resistance breakdown displayed by P. viticola virulent strains.

We describe a standard method for characterizing the virulence profile of Plasmopara viticola, the causal agent of grapevine downy mildew. We used 33 European strains to inoculate six grapevine varieties carrying the principal factors for resistance to downy mildew (Rpv1, Rpv3.1, Rpv3.2, Rpv5, Rpv6, Rpv10, and Rpv12) and the susceptible Vitis vinifera 'Chardonnay'. For each interaction, we characterized the level of sporulation by image analysis and the intensity of the grapevine hypersensitive response by visual score. We propose a definition for the breakdown of grapevine quantitative resistances combining these two traits. Among the 33 strains analyzed, 28 are virulent on at least one resistance factor. We identified five different pathotypes across the 33 strains analyzed: two pathotypes overcoming a single resistance factor (vir3.1 and vir3.2) and three complex pathotypes overcoming multiple resistance factors (vir3.1,3.2; vir3.2,12; vir3.1,3.2,10). Our findings confirm the widespread occurrence of P. viticola strains overcoming the Rpv3 haplotypes (28 strains). We also detected the first breakdown of resistance to the Rpv10 by a strain from Germany and the breakdown of Rpv12 factors by a strain from Hungary. The pathotyping method proposed here and the associated differential host range lay the groundwork for the early detection of resistance breakdown in grapevines. This approach will also facilitate the monitoring of the evolution of P. viticola populations at large spatial scales. This is an essential step forward to promoting durable management of the resistant grapevine varieties currently available.

Specific adjustments in grapevine leaf proteome discriminating resistant and susceptible grapevine genotypes to Plasmopara viticola

The current strategy to control grapevine downy and powdery mildew relies on chemical treatments. An alternative solution to the use of chemicals is the development of varieties resistant to pathogens. Therefore a program to create new grapevine varieties with a durable resistance to downy and powdery mildew and with a berry quality suitable for high quality wine production was launched in 2000. The situation seemed very favourable to start up such a program: plenty of resistance sources were available, and several resistance QTLs with various effects had already been discovered. Nevertheless a first case of downy mildew resistance breakdown was described in the cultivar ?Bianca?. Even if resistance durability is a retrospective judgment, some principles can be considered to monitor the risk of resistance break-down: pyramiding resistance genes, taking into account the evolutionary potential of the pathogen or assessing the cost of virulence, from a practical point of view, a durable management of resistance meaning to reduce the selection pressure applied by the resistance genes on the pathogen population. Therefore we chose to use multiple sources of resistance as genitors. The genetic determinism of most of them was analysed and the molecular markers derived from these studies were quickly integrated to assist with selection. Concerning the shortening of the breeding process, we developed a greenhouse growing method allowing to go from seed to seed in one year and a resistance phenotyping platform to get the precise plant phenotype as early as possible in the process. Moreover all the field trials have been performed through an experimental network, which allows us to save time and to take into account the differences in environment conditions. The overall process of selection is organized into three steps and takes 16 years. We expect to propose our first varieties for registration in 2016.

The cultivation of grape varieties with partial resistance to disease may become an important component for disease management in the future. The impact of partial resistance on downy mildew epidemics according to its components have not been explored so far. This work aims to model, understand, and quantitatively analyse the effect of partial resistance against dual disease epidemics (foliage and clusters) caused by Plasmopara viticola, and rank the efficiency of different resistance components in disease suppression. We use an epidemiological simulation model to integrate the effect of four components of partial resistance, expressed as relative resistance parameters, i.e. infection efficiency (RRIE), latency period (RRLP), sporulation (RRSP), and infectious period (RRIP). Both the individual and combined effect of these components of resistance on downy mildew epidemics are evaluated through a sensitivity analysis. A comparison of simulation runs in different scenarios of disease conduciveness using experimental measurements of components of partial resistance for 16 different grapevine varieties is also performed. Increasing values of RR parameters led to a suppression of disease progress on foliage. The strongest reduction of epidemics on foliage is generated by increases in RRIE, followed by RRSP, RRIP, and last by RRLP. The effect of partial resistance on epidemics is more conspicuous in a scenario of limited disease conduciveness. The strongest suppressive effect of simulated epidemics on clusters is associated with RRIE, and the lowest effect with RRLP, with similar effects of increasing values of RRIP and RRSP. The use of experimentally measured relative resistance parameters to run simulated epidemics shows a reduction of the area under the disease progress curve from 4 × 105 (on a susceptible reference grapevine variety) to 4 × 102 (on cv. Bronner), i.e. a reduction of disease by 1000. The simulation of the varietal effect in intermediate and less favourable scenarios of disease conduciveness strongly suppresses the epidemic on foliage and limits disease on clusters to very low levels. Deploying partial host plant resistance in environments that are not strongly conducive to downy mildew epidemics could represent an effective use of partial resistance.

Simulating crop-disease interactions in agricultural landscapes to analyse the effectiveness of host resistance in disease control: The case of potato late blight

Transcriptome analysis reveals different response of resistant and susceptible rice varieties to rice stripe virus infection

Downy mildew is a major disease of grapevine. Conventional methods for assessing crop diseases are time-consuming and require trained personnel. This work aimed to develop and validate a new method to automatically estimate the severity of downy mildew in grapevine leaves using fuzzy logic and computer vision techniques. Leaf discs of two grapevine varieties were inoculated with Plasmopara viticola and subsequently, RGB images were acquired under indoor conditions. Computer vision techniques were applied for leaf disc location in Petri dishes, image pre-processing and segmentation of pre-processed disc images to separate the pixels representing downy mildew sporulation from the rest of the leaf. Fuzzy logic was applied to improve the segmentation of disc images, rating pixels with a degree of infection according to the intensity of sporulation. To validate the new method, the downy mildew severity was visually evaluated by eleven experts and averaged score was used as the reference value. A coefficient of determination (R2) of 0.87 and a root mean squared error (RMSE) of 7.61 % was observed between the downy mildew severity obtained by the new method and the visual assessment values. Classification of the severity of the infection into three levels was also attempted, achieving an accuracy of 86 % and an F1 score of 0.78. These results indicate that computer vision and fuzzy logic can be used to automatically estimate the severity of downy mildew in grapevine leaves. A new method has been developed and validated to assess the severity of downy mildew in grapevine. The new method can be adapted to assess the severity of other diseases and crops in agriculture.

BABA, a non-protein amino acid, was used to induce resistance in grapevine against downy mildew. BABA-induced resistance was observed in the susceptible cv. Chasselas as well as in the resistant cv. Solaris. Following BABA treatment, sporulation of Plasmopara viticola was strongly reduced and the accumulation of stilbenes increased with time following infection. Induction of trans-piceide, trans-resveratrol and, more importantly, of trans-ɛ- and trans-δ-viniferin and trans-pterostilbene was observed in BABA-primed Chasselas. On the other hand, induction of trans-resveratrol, trans δ-viniferin and trans-pterostilbene was observed in BABA-primed Solaris. The accumulation of stilbenes in BABA-primed Solaris was much higher than that found in BABA-primed Chasselas. Furthermore, BABA-treatment of Solaris led to a rapid increase in transcript levels of three genes involved in the phenylpropanoid pathway: phenylalanine ammonia lyase, cinnamate-4-hydroxylase and stilbene synthase. BABA-primed Chasselas showed increased transcript levels for cinnamate-4-hydroxylase and stilbene synthase. Here we show that pre-treatment of a susceptible grapevine cultivar with BABA prior to infection with P. viticola primed the accumulation of specific phytoalexins that are undetectable in non-BABA-primed plants. As a result, the susceptible cultivar became more resistant to downy mildew.KeywordsPhytoalexin Plasmopara viticola PrimingStilbenes Vitis vinifera