Molecular marker analysis of genes of resistance to scab and fire blight in the apple cultivars bred at the Sverdlovsk Horticultural Breeding Station

The presence of genes for resistance to scab (Venturia inaequalis) and powdery mildew (Podosphaera leucotricha) was studied using molecular markers in a sample of 279 apple cultivars from the Czech collection of apple genetic resources. The sample comprised 37 cultivars supposed to have the Vf gene for scab resistance, 97 reference world cultivars and 145 old and local cultivars. Six PCR molecular markers for the scab resistance genes Vf, Vm, Vbj, Vr and Vh and three PCR molecular markers for the powdery mildew resistance genes Pl-w, Pl-1 and Pl-d were used. The marker for the major scab resistance gene Vf was detected in all cultivars supposed to have Vf, except in Romus 1, and in the three small-fruited cultivars Malus Evereste, Golden Gem and Hilleri. The markers of the Vr and Vh scab resistance genes were detected in 22 cultivars in combination with the marker for Vf, in 56 reference world cultivars and in 82 old and local apple cultivars. PCR molecular markers for one or two of the powdery mildew resistance genes were detected in the small-fruited cultivars Malus Evereste, Golden Gem, prof. Sprengeri and Hilleri; and in the larger fruited cultivars Hagloe Crab, Borovinka and Tita Zetei. We did not find markers for the scab resistance genes Vm and Vbj in any of the studied cultivars. They are absent also in the remaining part of the Czech collection of apple genetic resources. PCR molecular markers are useful tools for the identification of resistance genes within apple germplasm collections and can be used to increase the number of sources for disease resistance in breeding programmes.

Swiss and more generally European apple (Malus × domestica) production is hampered by several diseases, the most destructive being fire blight, caused by Erwinia amylovora. On the other hand, there are apple scab, caused by Venturia inaequalis and powdery mildew, caused by Podosphaera leucotricha, which represent the major phytosanitary problems. Classical breeding has produced many scab and mildew resistant cultivars and efforts to breed also fire blight resistant cultivars are currently undertaken. Marker assisted selection (MAS) increases efficiency by allowing early non-destructive screening of seedlings and identifying genotypes showing pyramids of resistance genes. If the development of markers for MAS was the primary goal of genetic analysis in the 1990s, identification and cloning of resistance genes is now the goal. The first and until now the sole resistance gene which has been isolated and transformed into a susceptible apple cultivar is the gene HcrVf2 (Rvi6), responsible for the Vf scab resistance present in most classically bred scab resistant cultivars. Much effort is currently spent in the identification and positional cloning of other apple genes conferring resistance to apple scab and fire blight. In our labs, we identified the putative scab resistance gene Rvi15 and two fire blight resistance genes namely from ‘Evereste’ and Malus × robusta 5. The functionality of these candidate genes is currently under scrutiny by complementation experiments. However, the final goal is the creation of a product, e.g., an improved apple cultivar that is resistant to scab and fire blight. The ideal product would have advantages to the environment and producer, and should raise as little concern as possible with consumers. To accomplish this ‘ideal product’, we opted for the cisgenic approach by introducing the scab resistance gene HcrVf2 with its own regulatory sequences into the highly susceptible apple cultivar, ‘Gala’, through Agrobacterium transformation. All marker genes were eliminated after transformation. Similarly, we are currently introducing into both the readily developed cisgenic ‘Gala’ and in the untransformed ‘Gala’ the putative Malus own fire blight resistance gene candidates, aiming at both proof of functionality of the identified candidates and possibly at rapid development of a fire blight and scab resistant cisgenic apple.

BackgroundScab, caused by the fungus Venturia inaequalis, is one of the most important diseases of cultivated apple. While a few scab resistance genes (R genes) governing qualitative resistance have been isolated and characterized, the biological roles of genes governing quantitative resistance, supposed to be more durable, are still unknown. This study aims to investigate the molecular mechanisms involved in the partial resistance of the old Belgian apple cultivar ‘Président Roulin’ against V. inaequalis.ResultsA global gene expression analysis was conducted in ‘Président Roulin’ (partially resistant) and in ‘Gala’ (susceptible) challenged by V. inaequalis by using the cDNA-AFLP method (cDNA-Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism). Transcriptome analysis revealed significant modulation (up- or down-regulation) of 281 out of approximately 20,500 transcript derived fragments (TDFs) in ‘Président Roulin’ 48 hours after inoculation. Sequence annotation revealed similarities to several genes encoding for proteins belonging to the NBS-LRR and LRR-RLK classes of plant R genes and to other defense-related proteins. Differentially expressed genes were sorted into functional categories according to their gene ontology annotation and this expression signature was compared to published apple cDNA libraries by Gene Enrichment Analysis. The first comparison was made with two cDNA libraries from Malus x domestica uninfected leaves, and revealed in both libraries a signature of enhanced expression in ‘Président Roulin’ of genes involved in response to stress and photosynthesis. In the second comparison, the pathogen-responsive TDFs from the partially resistant cultivar were compared to the cDNA library from inoculated leaves of Rvi6 (HcrVf2)-transformed ‘Gala’ lines (complete disease resistance) and revealed both common physiological events, and notably differences in the regulation of defense response, the regulation of hydrolase activity, and response to DNA damage. TDFs were in silico mapped on the ‘Golden Delicious’ apple reference genome and significant co-localizations with major scab R genes, but not with quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for scab resistance nor resistance gene analogues (RGAs) were found.ConclusionsThis study highlights possible candidate genes that may play a role in the partial scab resistance mechanisms of ‘Président Roulin’ and increase our understanding of the molecular mechanisms involved in the partial resistance against apple scab.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/1471-2164-15-1043) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

To enhance the breeding of new scab-resistant apple cultivars, a comprehensive understanding of the mechanisms governing major scab resistance genes is essential. Rvi12_Cd5 was previously identified as the best candidate gene for the Rvi12 scab resistance of the crab apple "Hansen's baccata #2" by gene prediction and in silico analysis. In the present study, Rvi12_Cd5 was used to transform the scab-susceptible apple cultivar "Gala Galaxy." Two constructs were prepared: the first carrying Rvi12_Cd5 under the control of a 35S promoter and E9 terminator, and the second carrying Rvi12_Cd5 under the control of its native promoter and terminator. All the transgenic lines were analyzed for T-DNA integration, copy number, and expression of Rvi12_Cd5 and phenotypically evaluated for scab resistance. The "Gala Galaxy" lines carrying the 35S promoter expressed Rvi12_Cd5 at a high level, showing partial to high resistance against a mixed inoculum of Venturia inaequalis, with symptoms ranging from class 0 to 3b on the Chevalier scale. The transgenic lines carrying the native promoter showed a lower expression of Rvi12_Cd5 compared with the 35S lines. Nevertheless, the low expression was sufficient to induce a resistance level comparable to that of the transgenic lines carrying the 35S promoter. These results indicate that Rvi12_Cd5 confers scab resistance to a susceptible apple cultivar and that even a low level of gene transcript can trigger a plant response to V.inaequalis infection. After HcrVf2 and Vr2-C, Rvi12_Cd5 is the third major apple scab resistance gene being functionally proven.

The expression of the apple scab resistance gene Rvi6 in different apple cultivars and lines is not modulated by biotic or abiotic factors. All commercially important apple cultivars are susceptible to Venturia inaequalis, the causal organism of apple scab. A limited number of apple cultivars were bred to express the resistance gene Vf from the wild apple genotype Malus floribunda 821. Positional cloning of the Vf locus allowed the identification of the Rvi6 (formerly HcrVf2) scab resistance gene that was subsequently used to generate cisgenic apple lines. It is important to understand and compare how this resistance gene is transcribed and modulated during infection in conventionally bred cultivars and in cisgenic lines. The aim of this work was to study the transcription pattern of Rvi6 in three classically bred apple cultivars and six lines of 'Gala' genetically modified to express Rvi6. Rvi6 transcription was analyzed at two time points using quantitative real-time PCR (RT-qPCR) following inoculation with V. inaequalis conidia or water. Rvi6 transcription was assessed in relation to five reference genes. β-Actin, RNAPol, and UBC were the most suited to performing RT-qPCR experiments on Malus × domestica. Inoculation with V. inaequalis conidia under conditions conducive to scab infection failed to produce any significant changes to the transcription level of Rvi6. Rvi6 expression levels were inconsistent in response to external treatments in the different apple cultivars, and transgenic, intragenic or cisgenic lines.

This article presents the results of DNA marker-assisted selection of apple tree varieties and breeding material obtained in the North Caucasian Region Research Institute of Horticulture and Viticulture for several genes – Rvi2, Rvi3, Rvi5, and Rvi15 – determining scab resistance (Venturia inaequalis (Cooke) G. Winter). The aim was to estimate the polymorphism of Rvi2, Rvi3, Rvi5, and Rvi15 scab resistance genes in representatives of Malus Mill. of domestic selection with the purpose of identifying the most prospective genotypes for further breeding. The research objects included apple-tree genotypes of different genetic origin. The following genotypes were used as controls for identification of DNA-marker alleles of target genes: Malus pumila R12740-7A (gene Rvi2); Q71 (gene Rvi3); Malus atrosanguinea 840 (gene Rvi5); and GMAL2473 (gene Rvi15). The research was conducted using the facilities of the Collective Use Center “Research and Breeding Collection of Genetic Resources of Horticultural Crops”, Krasnodar, using conventional research methods. DNA extraction was conducted using a modified STAB method previously developed by researchers of the North Caucasian Region Research Institute of Horticulture and Viticulture. Various degrees of the prevalence of resistance genes in the sample were revealed. The most frequent genes were found to be Rvi3 (45.95 % of carriers identified) and Rvi15 (43.24 %). The prevalence of Rvi2 was 27.02 %. The least frequent gene was found to be Rvi5 (2.70 %). Among the studied apple varieties, carriers of 2-3 scab resistance genes were identified, including Vesta (RVI2, RVI3, RVI15) and late winter Margo (RVI2, RVI15). The 12/1-21-63 (Golden Delicious (4×)×2034 (F2 M. floribunda×Golden Delicious))×Modi) hybrid family demonstrated the highest number of carriers of several scab resistance genes. Application of DNA marker-assisted technology made it possible to identify 4-hybrid forms containing three target resistance genes in the genome: Rvi3, Rvi2, Rvi15 – 17/1-6-1 (Karmen×Gemeni), 17/2-6-7(12/1- 21-63×Modi), 17/1-7-17 (12/1-20-56×Fujion); Rvi3, Rvi5, Rvi15 – 17/1-6-73 (12/1-21-63×Modi). The identified carriers of several target genes can be used in further breeding for long-term resistance against Venturia inaequalis (Cooke) G. Winter.

The development of high-quality cultivars, with durable disease resistance, is a major objective of apple breeding. The selection procedures of modern breeding programs no longer rely exclusively on phenotypic criteria but include marker-assisted breeding (MAB). Currently, molecular markers linked to several resistance genes and quantitative trait loci (QTLs) are available. In this study, we focused on markers available for resistance breeding against the major diseases scab (Venturia inaequalis), powdery mildew (Podosphaera leucotricha), and fire blight (Erwinia amylovora). One approach proposed to achieve durable resistance is the pyramiding of functionally different resistance genes against the same pathogen. This approach can be complemented with the incorporation of resistance genes against other pathogens. The resulting resistant apple cultivars would contribute considerably to low-input, sustainable, fruit production. Furthermore, apple cultivars can be developed carrying homozygous allele sets of specific resistance genes, and these genotypes can be used as parents for further crosses. Due to the ensured inheritance of the resistance genes to the progeny, MAB for these genes will become superfluous. In this study, we developed elite apple plants which are homozygous for three different scab resistance genes, Rvi6, Rvi2, and Rvi4. Furthermore, these apple selections tested positive for a resistance gene against powdery mildew (Pl1 or Pl2), and the FBF7 QTL from ‘Fiesta’ for enhanced fire blight resistance. Selected progeny plants were tested for their fire blight resistance after artificial shoot inoculation and evaluated for tree and fruit characteristics.

Scab, caused by the ascomycete fungus Venturia pirina, leads to severe damage on European pear varieties resulting in a loss of commercial value and requiring frequent use of fungicides. Identifying scab resistance genes, developing molecular markers linked to these genes and establishing marker-assisted selection would be an effective way to improve European pear breeding for scab resistance. Most of the European pear cultivars (Pyrus communis) are currently reported to be sensitive. The pear cultivar ‘Navara’ was shown to carry a major scab resistance gene whose phenotypic expression in seedling progenies was a typical stellate necrosis symptom. The resistance gene was called Rvp1, for resistance to V. pirina, and was mapped on linkage group 2 of the pear genome close to microsatellite marker CH02b10. This genomic region is known to carry a cluster of scab resistance genes in apple indicating a first functional synteny for scab resistance between apple and pear.

The use of chemical means of protection against Apple scab is associated with high material costs and causes great harm to the environment. Growing of apple varieties with stable resistance to scab (the pathogen Venturia inaequalis) will significantly limit the use of pesticides. On the territory of the Russian Federation, the Rvi6 gene is considered immune, which determines resistance to five scab races, including the most aggressive fifth. The country has scabimmune apple varieties created by scientists from VNIISPK, NCFSCHWWG, FRC named after I. V. Michurin , VSTISP and other scientific institutions. In recent years, the Rvi6 gene has been overcome by scab in many European countries, and the Rvi5 gene, which is immune to four scab races, has been overcome in Russia and Germany. When creating high-yielding apple varieties of a new generation, with good fruit flavor quality, long-term and stable resistance to scab, in addition to the rvi6 resistance gene, the most promising sources are the Rvi5, Rvi11, Rvi12, Rvi14 and Rvi15 genes. The Rvi2, Rvi4, Rvi6, Rvi7 and Rvi9 genes in the apple breeding process are best used in extended pyramids of genetic resistance to scab. This will allow you to combine several scab resistance genes that control the immune system in one apple genotype. The article describes the characteristics of DNA markers, the nucleotide sequence of primers, the size of target fragments of the PCR product, including the size of the dominant allele product for detecting Rvi genes of the Venturia inaequalis pathogen that are promising for apple breeding in varieties and hybrid material. Amplification programs were selected to identify resistance genes to various races of apple scab.

BackgroundBreeding for resistance to apple scab (caused by Venturia inaequalis), the most devastating fungal disease of apples, relies on genetic resources maintained in germplasm collections.MethodsTo identify new sources of scab resistance, we evaluated 177 Malus accessions, including 27 primary and 13 hybrid Malus species from diverse geographical origins, in an orchard at Geneva, New York. We also screened a differential host set for 2 years to monitor for changes in the effectiveness of ten known scab resistance genes, which allowed us to confirm the presence of virulent pathogen races in the orchard.ResultsWe found that ~ 37% of the wild Malus accessions and domesticated cultivars were resistant to apple scab in the field. Several of these accessions were unrelated to sources of previously known resistance genes and are promising for apple scab genetic research and resistance breeding. Cultivars carrying the Rvi6 (Vf) gene from Malus floribunda clone 821, e.g. ‘Liberty’ or ‘Florina’, remained resistant despite the breakdown of Rvi6. ‘Demir’, a Malus hybrid from Turkey, and ‘Chisel Jersey’, a traditional English hard cider cultivar, showed fewer symptoms than the Rvi6 resistant cultivar ‘Prima’. Races 1 to 7 and 9 of V. inaequalis were present in the orchard, but no scab was observed on the indicator host accessions for races 11 and 12.ConclusionsDetailed and systematic screening of Malus germplasm identified resistant and moderately resistant donor accessions based on resistance reaction types. These accessions are promising for use in future genetic studies to identify novel sources of scab resistance alleles for apple breeding to develop cultivars with durable apple scab resistance.

A major scab resistance gene initially called Vr1 was identified in the apple cultivar “Regia” derived from the Malus scab resistance source R12740-7A (Russian seedling, RS). A codominant, multiallelic sequence characterized amplified region (SCAR) marker was developed from a random amplified polymorphic DNA marker identified by bulked-segregant analysis. Additional alleles of the AD13 marker locus proved to be informative for the analysis of genetic relationships within Malus including putative relatives of RS. Separate linkage maps were created for the two families derived from crosses with “Regia”. Using phenotypic data from the greenhouse scab tests, the recombination frequency between Vr1 and AD13-SCAR was between 6 and 17%. The Vr1 locus appeared to be closely linked to the Vx [Hemmat et al. J Am Soc Hortic Sci, 127:365–370, 2002], Vr2 [Patocchi et al. Theor Appl Genet, 109:1087–1092, 2004], and the Vh4 gene [Bus et al. Mol Breed, 15:103–116, 2005a]. Our linkage analysis of the molecular markers identified by Hemmat et al. [J Am Soc Hortic Sci, 127:365–370, 2002] for two scab resistance factors from RS (Vr and Vx) indicate that both genes are separated by a large distance on apple linkage group 2 [Boudichevskaia et al. Acta Hortic, 663:171–175, 2004]. This is in agreement with the results of Bus et al., [Mol Breed, 15:103–116, 2005a] who concluded that (1) the RS-derived gene Vh2 is identical to Vr, (2) the RS-derived gene Vh4 is identical to Vx and Vr1, (3) Vh2/Vr and Vh4/Vr1/Vx map on opposite sides of LG 2. One of our main goals was the verification of the Vr1-SCAR within a practical apple-breeding program. The utility of the AD13-SCAR was evident after 2 years under natural scab infection conditions in both families investigated. This is the first report about the confirmation of a molecular marker for a RS resistance factor in a 2-year field experiment. A multiplex polymerase chain reaction assay based on two codominant SCARs for Vf and Vr1 was tested in an apple progeny segregating for both genes. The result of the two-marker approach is discussed with respect to scab races, which are able to overcome the Vf resistance gene.

Scab resistance is one of the most important goals of apple breeding, typically achieved by time-consuming and expensive conventional breeding techniques. Cisgenesis, which is the genetic modification of a recipient organism with genes from a crossable—sexually compatible—organism, is a promising tool for plant breeding to develop disease resistance in a rapid way. A cisgenic, scab-resistant line of the apple variety ‘Gala’ expressing the native apple scab resistance gene Rvi6 (formerly HcrVf2) under control of its own regulatory sequences has been recently developed. In this paper, we present the results from a phenotypic, molecular and biochemical evaluation of clonal replicates of this line (C11.1.53). The phenotype (shoot length, shoot diameter, internode length, number of leaves, leaf length and leaf width) of C11.1.53 was compared to that of the Gala parental background over a period of 108 days. Only a few statistically significant differences were detected, which are probably due to small differences in the quality of the budwood used for grafting rather than effects related to the presence of the cisgene. As the expression of a resistance gene can affect the downstream cascade of plant defence responses, a selection of apple defence-related genes was analyzed by quantitative real-time PCR analysis. These genes are also known as major allergen genes in apple. Even if three out of ten apple allergen genes tested in the leaves differed in the cisgenic line compared to both Gala (background) and ‘Florina’ (the variety from which the Rvi6 gene was cloned), using 2D-PAGE, we were unable to find any significant difference in the expressed proteomes of the leaves of C11.1.53 compared to Gala. Results are discussed in the context of a possible use of cisgenic lines for fruit crop improvement.

Scab caused by the fungal pathogen Venturia inaequalis is the most common disease of cultivated apple (Malus x domestica Borkh.). Monogenic resistance against scab is found in some small-fruited wild Malus species and has been used in apple breeding for scab resistance. Vf resistance of Malus floribunda 821 is the most widely used scab resistance source. Because breeding a high-quality cultivar in perennial fruit trees takes dozens of years, cloning disease resistance genes and using them in the transformation of high-quality apple varieties would be advantageous. We report the identification of a cluster of receptor-like genes with homology to the Cladosporium fulvum (Cf) resistance gene family of tomato on bacterial artificial chromosome clones derived from the Vf scab resistance locus. Three members of the cluster were sequenced completely. Similar to the Cf gene family of tomato, the deduced amino acid sequences coded by these genes contain an extracellular leucine-rich repeat domain and a transmembrane domain. The transcription of three members of the cluster was determined by reverse transcriptionpolymerase chain reaction to be constitutive, and the transcription and translation start of one member was verified by 5' rapid amplification of cDNA ends. We discuss the parallels between Cf resistance of tomato and Vf resistance of apple and the possibility that one of the members of the gene cluster is the Vf gene. Cf homologs from other regions of the apple genome also were identified and are likely to present other scab resistance genes.

High quality disease resistant apples are the main breeding objective in the programme at Agroscope Changins-Wadenswil (ACW). Apple scab caused by the fungus Venturia inaequalis is still the most important disease in apple production. To ensure the durability of scab resistance we are combining different resistance genes (pyramiding). Moreover, we are incorporating also resistances against powdery mildew (Podosphaera leucotricha) and fire blight (Erwinia amylovora). Principles and methods of resistance breeding are outlined and pyramiding of resistances is illustrated by analysing crosses between two cultivars carrying different scab resistance genes (Vf and Vh2). Crosses are being analysed applying marker-assisted selection (MAS) to detect plants carrying multiple resistances. Phenotypic screening of seedlings for scab symptoms and MAS results are compared and the observed segregations into resistant and susceptible progenies discussed.

Asian pear scab is a fungal disease caused by Venturia nashicola. The identification of genes conferring scab resistance could facilitate the breeding of disease-resistant cultivars. Therefore, the present study aimed to identify a scab-resistance gene using an interspecific hybrid population ((Pyrus pyrifolia × P. communis) × P. pyrifolia). Artificial inoculation of V. nashicola was carried out for two years. The segregation ratio (1:1) of resistant to susceptible individuals indicated that resistance to V. nashicola was inherited from P. communis and controlled by a single dominant gene. Based on two years phenotypic data with the Kruskal–Wallis test and interval mapping, 12 common markers were significantly associated with scab resistance. A novel scab resistance gene, Rvn3, was mapped in linkage group 6 of the interspecific hybrid pear, and co-linearity between Rvn3 and one of the apple scab resistance genes, Rvi14, was confirmed. Notably, an insertion in pseudo-chromosome 6 of the interspecific hybrid cultivar showed homology with apple scab resistance genes. Hence, the newly discovered Rvn3 was considered an ortholog of the apple scab resistance gene. Since the mapping population used in the present study is a pseudo-BC1 population, pyramiding of multiple resistance genes to pseudo-BC1 could facilitate the breeding of pear cultivars with durable resistance.