Models and Methods for Two-Level Facility Location Problems

Heuristic Methods for Location-Allocation Problems

Primal–dual approximation algorithm for the two-level facility location problem via a dual quasi-greedy approach

A comparison of separation routines for benders optimality cuts for two-level facility location problems

The facility location problem is a classical combinatorial optimization problem with extensive applications spanning communication technology, economic management, traffic governance, and public services. The facility location problem is to assign a set of clients to a set of facilities such that each client connects to a facility and the total cost (open cost and connection cost) is as low as possible. Among its various models, the uncapacitated facility location (UFL) problem is the most fundamental and widely studied. However, in real-world scenarios, resource constraints often make the UFL problem insufficient, necessitating more generalized models. This investigation primarily focuses on the universal facility location (Uni-FL) problem, a generalized framework encompassing both capacitated facility location problems (with hard and soft capacity constraints) and the UFL problem. Through a systematic analysis, we examine the Uni-FL problem alongside its specialized variants: the hard capacitated facility location (HCFL) problem and soft capacitated facility location (SCFL) problem. A comprehensive survey is conducted of existing approximation algorithms and theoretical results. The relevant results of their important variants are also discussed. In addition, we propose some open questions and future research directions for this problem based on existing research.

In this paper, we present improved inapproximability results for the k-level uncapacitated facility location problem. In particular, we show that there is no polynomial time approximation algorithm with performance guarantee better than 1.539 unless NP is contained in DTIME(nO(log log n)) for the case when k = 2. For the case of general k (tendining to infinity) we obtain a better hardness factor of 1.61.Interestingly, our results show that the two-level problem is computationally harder than the well known uncapacitated facility location problem (k = 1) since the best known approximation guarantee for the latter problem is 1.488 due to Li [22], and our inapproximability is a factor of 1.539 for the two-level problem. The only inapproximability result known before for this class of metric facility location problems is the bound of 1.463 due to Guha and Khuller [17], which holds even for the case of k = 1.

Integrating simplified swarm optimization with AHP for solving capacitated military logistic depot location problem

Multi-objective two-level medical facility location problem and tabu search algorithm

A two-level facility location problem (FLP) has been studied in the transportation network of emergence maize crop in Tanzania. The facility location problem is defined as the optimal location of facilities or resources so as to minimize costs in terms of money, time, distance and risks with the relation to supply and demand points. Distribution network design problems consist of determining the best way to transfer goods from the supply to the demand points by choosing the structure of the network such that the overall cost is minimized. The three layers, namely production centres (PCs), distribution centres (DCs) and customer points (CPs) are considered in the two-level FLP. The flow of maize from PCs to CPs through DCs is designed at a minimum cost under deterministic mathematical programming model. The four decisions to be made simultaneously are: to determine the locations of DCs (including number of DCs), allocation of CPs to the selected DCs, allocation of selected DCs to PCs, and to determine the amount of maize crop transported from PCs to DCs and then from DCs to CPs. The modelled problem generated results through optimization with respect to optimal location-allocation strategies. The results of the optimized network shows the improvement in costs saving compared to the manually operated existing network. The results show the costs saving of up to 18% which is equivalent to $2,910 thousand (TZS 2.9 billion). Keywords: Optimization; Maize crop; Transportation network; Deterministic model; Facility location

Previous chapter Next chapter Full AccessProceedings Proceedings of the 2012 Annual ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms (SODA)Inapproximability of the Multi-level Uncapacitated Facility Location ProblemRavishankar Krishnaswamy and Maxim SviridenkoRavishankar Krishnaswamy and Maxim Sviridenkopp.718 - 734Chapter DOI:https://doi.org/10.1137/1.9781611973099.59PDFBibTexSections ToolsAdd to favoritesExport CitationTrack CitationsEmail SectionsAboutAbstract In this paper, we present improved inapproximability results for the k-level uncapacitated facility location problem. In particular, we show that there is no polynomial time approximation algorithm with performance guarantee better than 1.539 unless NP is contained in DTIME(nO(log log n)) for the case when k = 2. For the case of general k (tendining to infinity) we obtain a better hardness factor of 1.61. Interestingly, our results show that the two-level problem is computationally harder than the well known uncapacitated facility location problem (k = 1) since the best known approximation guarantee for the latter problem is 1.488 due to Li [22], and our inapproximability is a factor of 1.539 for the two-level problem. The only inapproximability result known before for this class of metric facility location problems is the bound of 1.463 due to Guha and Khuller [17], which holds even for the case of k = 1. Previous chapter Next chapter RelatedDetails Published:2012ISBN:978-1-61197-210-8eISBN:978-1-61197-309-9 https://doi.org/10.1137/1.9781611973099Book Series Name:ProceedingsBook Code:PR141Book Pages:xiii + 1757

We propose a quasi-greedy algorithm for approximating the classical uncapacitated 2-level facility location problem (2-LFLP). Our algorithm, unlike the standard greedy algorithm, selects a sub-optimal candidate at each step. It also relates the minimization 2-LFLP problem, in an interesting way, to the maximization version of the single level facility location problem. Another feature of our algorithm is that it combines the technique of randomized rounding with that of dual fitting.This new approach enables us to approximate the metric 2-LFLP in polynomial time with a ratio of 1:77, a significant improvement on the previously known approximation ratios. Moreover, our approach results in a local improvement procedure for the 2-LFLP, which is useful in improving the approximation guarantees for several other multi-level facility location problems.

We propose a quasi-greedy algorithm for approximating the classical uncapacitated 2-level facility location problem (2-LFLP). Our algorithm, unlike the standard greedy algorithm, selects a sub-optimal candidate at each step. It also relates the minimization 2-LFLP problem, in an interesting way, to the maximization version of the single level facility location problem. Another feature of our algorithm is that it combines the technique of randomized rounding with that of dual fitting.This new approach enables us to approximate the metric 2-LFLP in polynomial time with a ratio of 1:77, a significant improvement on the previously known approximation ratios. Moreover, our approach results in a local improvement procedure for the 2-LFLP, which is useful in improving the approximation guarantees for several other multi-level facility location problems.

Clustering is a ubiquitous problem that arises in many applications in different fields such as data mining, image processing, machine learning, and bioinformatics. Clustering problems have been extensively studied as optimization problems with various objective functions in the Operations Research and Computer Science literature. We focus on a class of objective functions more commonly referred to as facility location problems. These problems arise in a wide range of applications such as, plant or warehouse location problems, cache placement problems, and network design problems where the costs obey economies of scale. In the simplest of these problems, the uncapacitated facility location (UFL) problem, we want to open facilities at some subset of a given set of locations and assign each client in a given set D to an open facility so as to minimize the sum of the facility opening costs and client assignment costs. This a very well-studied problem; however it fails to address many of the requirements of real applications. In this thesis we consider various problems that build upon UFL and capture additional issues that arise in applications such as, uncertainties in the data, clients with different service needs, and facilities with interconnectivity requirements. By focusing initially on facility location problems in these new models, we develop new algorithmic techniques that will find application in a wide range of settings. We consider a widely used paradigm in stochastic programming to model settings where the underlying data, for example, the locations or demands of the clients, may be uncertain: the 2-stage with recourse model that involves making some initial decisions, observing additional information, and then augmenting the initial decisions, if necessary, by taking recourse actions. We present a randomized polynomial time algorithm that solves a large class of 2-stage stochastic linear programs (LPs) to near-optimality with high probability. We exploit this tool to devise the first approximation algorithms for various 2-stage discrete stochastic problems such as the stochastic versions of the set cover, vertex cover, and facility location problems, when the underlying random data is only given as a “black box” and no restrictions are placed on the cost structure. We introduce the facility location with service installation costs problem to model applications involving clients with different service requirements. if the service requested by it has been installed at the facility (incurring a service installation cost). The connected facility location problem captures settings where the open facilities want to communicate with each other or with a central authority; we model this by requiring that the open facilities be interconnected by a Steiner tree. We give intuitive and efficient algorithms for both these problems. We use these algorithms to obtain approximation algorithms for the κ-median variants of these problems, where in addition to all of the constraints of the problem, a bound of κ is imposed on the number of facilities that may be opened.

We consider the competitive facility location problem in which two competing sides (the Leader and the Follower) open in succession their facilities, and each consumer chooses one of the open facilities basing on its own preferences. The problem amounts to choosing the Leader’s facility locations so that to obtain maximal profit taking into account the subsequent facility location by the Follower who also aims to obtain maximal profit. We state the problem as a two-level integer programming problem. A method is proposed for calculating an upper bound for the maximal profit of the Leader. The corresponding algorithm amounts to constructing the classical maximum facility location problem and finding an optimal solution to it. Simultaneously with calculating an upper bound we construct an initial approximate solution to the competitive facility location problem. We propose some local search algorithms for improving the initial approximate solutions. We include the results of some simulations with the proposed algorithms, which enable us to estimate the precision of the resulting approximate solutions and give a comparative estimate for the quality of the algorithms under consideration for constructing the approximate solutions to the problem.

In this article, we present improved inapproximability results for the k -level uncapacitated facility location problem. In particular, we show that there is no polynomial time approximation algorithm with performance guarantee better than 1.539 unless P = NP for the case when k = 2. For the case of general k (tending to infinity), we obtain a better hardness factor of 1.61. Interestingly, our results show that the two-level problem is computationally harder than the well-known uncapacitated facility location problem ( k = 1) since the best-known approximation guarantee for the latter problem is 1.488 due to Li [2013], and our inapproximability is a factor of 1.539 for the two-level problem. The only inapproximability result known before for this class of metric facility location problems is the bound of 1.463 due to Guha and Khuller [1999], which holds even for the case of k = 1.

Fractional location problems