Mixed-stock analysis of Atlantic coast striped bass (Morone saxatilis) using nuclear DNA and mitochondrial DNA markers

Abstract

Striped bass (Morone saxatilis) stocks comingle along the northeastern United States and Canadian coasts and support mixed-stock fisheries in which stock compositions fluctuate widely. Many approaches to stock analysis of these populations have been tried. The recent use of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) haplotype frequency data showed promising results, despite low levels of mtDNA variation; to improve resolution, we used a single-copy nuclear DNA (nDNA) probe with two mtDNA markers (major length variants and Taq I variants), alone or in combination. Striped bass reference collections were from the Hudson River and Chesapeake Bay, and mixed-stock collections (1989 and 1991) were from eastern Long Island, New York. The combination of the nDNA and mtDNA major length variant data provided lower but still quite high resolution potential (Dst = 0.417) in mixed-stock analysis (1991 collection) than the combination of all three markers (Dst = 0.552). However, unlike the Hudson River stock, the Chesapeake Bay stock is composed of multiple substocks that vary significantly in the frequencies of Taq I variants; this among-substock variation destabilizes the Chesapeake Bay reference data set and the resultant mixed-stock estimates. Thus, we recommend an approach based on composite nDNA and mtDNA major length variant markers.