Mitigation of Ship Motion Using Passive and Active Anti-Roll Tanks
Because excessive roll motions of ships in rough seas badly affect their performance, there is a continuous interest in efficient ways to mitigate these undesirable motions. There are different devices to mitigate the roll of ships with different levels of performance and operating limits. Anti-roll tanks are more effective than other roll stabilization devices when the ship is not underway or moves slowly. Here, we investigate the application of passive and active anti-roll tank systems. The tank system consists of three tanks: each one consists of two columns connected at the bottom via a horizontal pipe equipped with a pump. The tanks are arranged along the length of the ship, symmetrically located about its center of gravity. The motion of the liquid in the tank is 1-D, but it exerts loads on all degrees of freedom of the ship. The equation governing the tank-liquid motion is coupled with the equations governing the 6-DOF motion of the ship in waves; the coupled system is solved simultaneously in time. First, we derive expressions for the forces and moments exerted on the ship by the tanks. Then, we study the roll response at different sea heading angles in rough sea conditions in the absence of the tanks to identify the critical heading angles where the roll is large. We demonstrate the nonlinear behavior of roll through frequency-response curves for different beam wave amplitudes. These curves exhibit typical nonlinear phenomena (jumps and hysteresis) for high wave amplitudes. Spectral analysis shows a two-to-one frequency relationship between the roll and pitch in rough head and follower seas, which are the most critical sea headings. For passive and active tanks, we study the effect of the frequency of the tank system on its effectiveness. We consider active anti-roll tanks in which the pump power is controlled via a proportional-derivative (PD) control law using the roll angle and its rate. We compare the performances of passive and active tanks in rough sea for the critical heading angles. We found that active anti-roll tanks outperform passive ones in terms of roll reduction and size and weight, but they require power consumption. To achieve a specified roll reduction, the weight of a passive tank might be as large as five times that of an active tank. We also found that the performance of passive tanks depends strongly on their frequencies, in contrast with active tanks, which are insensitive to their frequencies.
- Supplementary Content
34
- 10.1177/1077546303009007006
- Jul 1, 2003
- Journal of Vibration and Control
Roll motion is an undesirable feature of the behavior of a ship in rough seas, and so it is natural to consider ways of reducing it. The most common devices for increasing roll damping are bilge keels. However, the effectiveness of keels is limited, and anti-roll tanks and fins are used when more control is required. Moreover, unlike keels, anti-roll tanks can be used when the ship is not underway. Our objective is to develop design procedures for passive tanks for roll reduction in rough seas. To this end, we develop an improved model of the passive tank-liquid motion in this paper. This tank consists of U-shaped tubes placed side by side along the length of the ship. The equations of six-degrees-of-motion (6DOF) that govern the tank-liquid are coupled with those that govern the 6DOF motion of the ship, and all of the equations are integrated simultaneously in the time domain using the Large Amplitude Motion Program (“LAMP”). LAMP is a three-dimensional time-domain simulation of the motion of ships in waves. The unstabilized and stabilized roll motions of a S60-70 ship with forward speed and beam waves have been analyzed. For high-amplitude waves, the variation of the roll angle with the encounter-wave frequency exhibits typical nonlinear phenomena: a shift in the resonance frequency, multi-valued responses, and jumps. The performance of passive tanks on a S60-70 ship with forward speed is investigated in an irregular sea with different encounter-wave directions. It is found that passive anti-roll tanks tuned in the nonlinear range are very effective in reducing the roll motion. The effect of the tank mass and distribution of tank tubes on the performance of the tank system is studied. Also, it is found that passive anti-roll tanks are very effective in reducing the roll motion in sea state five of a ship whose pitch frequency is nearly twice its roll frequency.
- Research Article
45
- 10.1016/s0029-8018(01)00021-x
- Sep 3, 2001
- Ocean Engineering
Design of passive anti-roll tanks for roll stabilization in the nonlinear range
- Research Article
4
- 10.1016/j.oceaneng.2022.112802
- Oct 28, 2022
- Ocean Engineering
Wave propulsion and sea-keeping enhancement for ships in rough sea condition by flapping foils
- Conference Article
6
- 10.23919/oceans.2011.6107047
- Sep 1, 2011
Performing oceanographic measurements from the sea surface to the sea bottom is technically challenging under rough or icy sea conditions. As a measure to deal with rough seas, a new dynamic simulation program was developed and its validity was verified by comparison with the results of actual sea tests. This program can therefore be used as a design tool. To develop countermeasures against icing, we carried out basic tests in a large-scale snow and ice laboratory. Some of these countermeasures were then implemented in real sea tests and were found to be effective under icy conditions. These results indicate that deployment of moored surface buoys in regions of rough and icy sea conditions will soon be practical.
- Research Article
9
- 10.1016/j.oceaneng.2022.111731
- Aug 22, 2022
- Ocean Engineering
Comparative study of realistic ship motion simulation for optimal ship routing of a bulk carrier in rough seas
- Research Article
- 10.3390/jmse13030534
- Mar 11, 2025
- Journal of Marine Science and Engineering
To ensure the safe navigation of ships in rough seas while reducing steering gear energy consumption and losses, a steering control system with small rudder output angles, low steering frequency, and high control performance was designed. A third-order closed-loop gain-shaping algorithm was employed in the development of the controller, with the ultimate control strategy derived by embedding a nonlinear compound function between the proportional derivative (PD) controller and the second-order oscillation link to enhance control effectiveness. A nonlinear Nomoto model of the “Yupeng” ship was employed for simulation validation. The simulation results illustrated a 14.5% improvement in overall control performance achieved by the proposed controller compared to a nonlinear feedback controller. The controller’s robustness was additionally validated through the application of the Norrbin ship model. The proposed controller enhances the stability of ships in rough seas, effectively limiting the maximum rudder angle during turns and reducing the average rudder angle and steering frequency during navigation. This design aligns with practical requirements for maritime operations in heavy weather, contributing significantly to the economic, safe, and efficient navigation of ships.
- Book Chapter
- 10.1007/978-3-319-11194-0_39
- Jan 1, 2014
This paper analyzes the rough seas weather which may be encountered during the voyage and its influences on ship’s navigation safety. This paper draws lessons from related both domestic and abroad researches about ship’s navigation safety, according to the accident causes, analyzes the factors of ship’s navigation safety affected by rough seas, determines assessment index system of ship’s navigation safety in rough seas, uses Bayesian Network to realize the assessment, and eventually works out which index contributes the most to the marine accidents of ship in rough seas.
- Conference Article
- 10.1115/omae2017-61319
- Jun 25, 2017
Simulation of marine operations for launch and recovery of bluff bodies such as autonomous underwater vehicles (AUV), remotely operated vehicles (ROV) or subsea templates is traditionally performed in calm to moderate sea conditions. The reason for doing so is partly due to the interaction between the complex dynamic response of an installation vessel, a moving bluff body and the wave kinematics of the rough sea condition. This is in addition to the need for accurate hydrodynamic coefficients that would enable proper simulation and modelling of the launch and recovery process. The key objective of the current methodology is to minimize risks of damage to the vessel and total loss of assets during the deployment and recovery process for marine operations in rough sea conditions. The aim of this paper is to present the results of experimental and numerical investigation on the prediction of dynamic response of a bluff body during launch and recovery from a surface vessel in rough sea condition. Experimental measurements of hydrodynamic coefficients and responses of a large scale bluff body using a scaled model were completed. Further studies using a time-domain numerical tool have been undertaken to measure the response characteristic of bluff bodies in rough seas. The study also predicted the contributions of vessel motion in rough seas to the dynamic response of the bluff bodies. The results obtained have shown that simulation of launch and recovery operations in rough seas can be carried out efficiently if their hydrodynamic coefficients through the wave active regions of the rough seas are predicted and then adequately implemented in the simulations.
- Research Article
72
- 10.1016/j.oceaneng.2009.03.005
- Mar 21, 2009
- Ocean Engineering
Control of ship roll using passive and active anti-roll tanks
- Conference Article
1
- 10.1109/tmee.2011.6199477
- Dec 1, 2011
For some ships in special use or the warships as sea platforms, the out range rolling will produce bad effects on the operation of the ships or the equipments on the warships. The current researches show that the synthetic stabilization scheme combined several stabilization sets is the main trends in the future. Considering the relationship between fin stabilizer and passive ling tank and the stabilization effectiveness in all kinds of sea condition, a configuration scheme of fin stabilizer and passive anti-rolling tank is proposed. An index of function-effectiveness is defined according to the economic factors. The simulation shows that the scheme employing low-capacity fin stabilizer to match anti-rolling tank is more rational.
- Research Article
- 10.2534/jjasnaoe1968.1988.435
- Jan 1, 1988
- Journal of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan
It has recently been recognized that structural failures of large ocean-going vessels are essentially related to the dynamic stresses induced by bottom and bow-flare slamming in rough seas. Bottom slamming may cause an excessive vertical bending moment in a hull girder which may lead buckling of the upper deck, while bow-flare slamming may cause an excessive torsional moment in the fore-body of high speed ships in oblique waves. Local dents and cracking failures due to slamming are also observed in the fore body of large ships, they might be accelerated by severe corrosion.In high speed ocean-going ships, cracking failures are sometimes observed in middle and aft parts of the hull girders after passing through a rough sea. Since this type of failure is not necessarily exceptional to newly build ships, it may be caused by low cylce fatigue due to repeated whipping stresses induced by bow-flare slams. In the present paper, fatigue strength is investigated for structural members with high stress concentration factors in the neighbourhood of the front end of the superstructure of a container ship, where the applied stress is composed of a wave induced bending stress including non-linear effects, whipping components of stresses, and possibly coupled vibratory stresses of the superstructure.Having calculated the dynamic stress components among regular waves in head seas, the fatigue strength of highly stressed portions are examined by using appropriate S-N curves, in which effects of ship speeds and wave heights are taken into considerations. When a high speed vessel passes through very rough seas, the fatigue strength may be reduced due to the significant elevation of the repeated stress range caused by the whipping components of stresses superposed on the wave induced bending stress.
- Research Article
1
- 10.1016/j.oceaneng.2023.114970
- Jun 3, 2023
- Ocean Engineering
Z-shaped navigation for surface ships in rough seas based on constraint MPC
- Research Article
- 10.2534/jjasnaoe1952.1960.a91
- Jan 1, 1960
- Journal of Zosen Kiokai
This paper presents a practical method of predicting the longitudinal stresses of ships in rough seas by means of Neumann-Pierson's wave spectrum theory and St. Denis-Pierson's theory. Given the principal dimensions of ships, the wind velocities, the durations and the fetches, we can statistically find the logitudinal stresses. In an experiment the predicted stress was in good agreement with the observation.
- Research Article
9
- 10.2478/v10012-012-0030-6
- Oct 1, 2012
- Polish Maritime Research
This paper presents a computational model which describes motion of an object of six degrees of freedom (DoF), intended for simulation of spatial motion of one- or two- rope-sling lifeboat or rescue boat during its launching from ship in rough sea. This is a complex model which accounts for sea conditions as well as elasticity and damping properties of davit’s elements and mechanisms, rope and boat hull. Also, are presented results of example calculations for an assumed set of technical parameters of davit and boat as well as sea conditions.
- Research Article
2
- 10.2534/jjasnaoe1968.2001.181
- Jan 1, 2001
- Journal of the Society of Naval Architects of Japan
Model experiments were carried out for a container ship in long crested irregular waves to investigate the non-linear effect on ship responses such as ship motions, wave induced pressure and wave load varying with wave height. The wave condition was changed from moderate to rough sea state in head waves. Numerical computations, by means of the strip method, the slender ship theory and the non-linear time domain strip method, were also carried out. The calculation results were compared with the experimental data to confirm the accuracy and to check on the range of the applicability.As a result, non-linear effect on vertical bending moment and wave induced pressure were remarkably observed in large waves : with increase of wave height, the bending moment acting on fore part is accelerated due to the influence of slamming and the induced pressure at the position near water surface is repressed due to the influence of exposure to the air. A time domain strip method can predict well the significant/maximum value of non-linear vertical bending moment in large waves. Toki's correction method is useful for improving the calculation accuracy of the induced pressure in regular and irregular waves.
- Ask R Discovery
- Chat PDF
AI summaries and top papers from 250M+ research sources.