Lung cancer risks among lead smelter workers also exposed to arsenic

Abstract

Recent publications indicate an increased incidence of lung cancer in non-ferrous smelter workers exposed to lead. The present study provides further data on selected subgroups in one such cohort. The cohort was based on 3979 smelter workers employed for at least 1 year between 1928 and 1979, and also exposed to lead and included in the Blood Lead Register that was started at the smelter in 1950. Two subcohorts were formed from the original cohort. One consists of 710 workers employed at the lead departments (Lead subcohort 1), and the other of 383 workers employed at the lead departments (Lead subcohort 2), but never at other works where an excess lung cancer risk was previously identified. Standardized Cancer Incidence Rates (SIR) 1958–1987 were calculated relative to county rates. In the subcohorts, arsenic exposure in lung cancer cases was assessed in detail based on occupational hygiene information from the company. Lung cancer incidence was raised in both subcohorts (Lead subcohort1: SIR 2.4; 95% CI 1.2–4.5; Lead subcohort2: SIR 3.6; 95% CI 1.2–8.3). Total cancer incidence in the cohorts was not increased. A detailed study of arsenic exposure in the 10 lung cancer cases in these two subcohorts revealed that all but one of these cases had a significant exposure also to arsenic. An elevated incidence of lung cancer was observed in smelter workers exposed to lead. However, considerable arsenic exposure also occurred in a majority of the lung cancer cases in the investigated subcohorts. In this multifactorial exposure situation it has not been possible to separate the carcinogenic effects of lead and arsenic, but a possible interaction between these metals may be involved in explaining the carcinogenic risks.