Long-term results after aortic valve replacement with four different prostheses

Abstract

The long-term results after implantation of isolated aortic ball and disc prostheses were studied. The Starr-Edwards ball valve type 1200 was first used in 80 patients, thereafter type 2300 was used in 173, later the Björk-Shiley and the Lillehei-Kaster disc valves were implanted in 99 and 97 patients according to randomization. The surviving patients with the oldest ball valve were examined after 4.7 and 6.7 years on an average, the others after approximately 2.5 and 4.5 years. The early mortality rate was 15%, and did not differ between the four groups. Even the late mortality rate was quite similar in the patient groups, the five-year survival rate being 65% in patients with ball valves and 68% in those with disc valves, as estimated with the actuarial method. The average reduction of heart size was moderate and quite similar in the four groups, most pronounced in patients with isolated aortic valve involvement. The reduction was greater in patients who received larger rather than smaller valves of all types. Aortic valve replacement resulted in a considerable clinical improvement in patients with all valve types; it corresponded largely to one functional group according to the NYHA classification. The heart size reduction and functional improvement was most moderate in patients with smaller ball valves, which could be anticipated from higher peak systolic gradients than across the other valves used. No significant differences appeared between patients with the larger valves of the four types. The initial improvement, as recorded either by reduction of heart size or increase in functional capacity, had reached its maximum at the first follow-up examination in most patients. The preoperative myocardial function appeared to be the limiting factor which determined what late results could be obtained regardless of the type of valve implanted. The results therefore indicate that more can be achieved by earlier valve replacement than by improving the prostheses.