Is it necessary to increase the maize planting density in China?

Abstract

Increasing the maize planting density is considered a potential approach for increasing the grain yield in China, but there is no consensus regarding its yield-increasing effect and the influence of specific factors. Thus, we established a database (2721 pairs of data from 187 publications) to quantify the effects of increasing the maize planting density on the phenotypic traits and yield, to determine an appropriate maize planting density for each planting area, and to quantify the effects of environmental factors and agricultural imputs on the outcomes of increasing the planting density. We found that increasing the planting density increased the individual competition among maize plants, with negative effects on their growth, but the grain yield increased by 11.18–13.43 % due to the increased population biomass. Using the database, we found large differences in the optimal density and peak grain yield among maize planting areas, and the factors that caused these differences were analyzed based on subgroup analysis. Field management practices significantly influenced the outcomes of increasing the planting density. In particular, higher agricultural inputs (irrigation amount, and nitrogen and phosphorus application rates) enhanced the positive effect of increasing plant density on the optimal plant density and peak grain yield. In addition, the effects of increasing the planting density were significantly influenced by environmental (climate and soil) factors. When the mean annual temperature was 7–14°C and the mean annual precipitation was 400–800 mm, the yield and maximum peak yield were highest in relatively fertile (high total nitrogen, available nitrogen, and soil organic matter contents) and neutral (pH 6–8) soils. Our results highlight the need to increase the current maize planting density and provide a scientific basis for determining reasonable planting densities for different maize growing areas in China.