Integrated analytical methodologies for the study of the corrosion products naturally grown on Roman Ag-based artefacts

Abstract

Ancient silver-based alloys objects are of a great interest because they were world-wide used to produce high value works of art and precious items as jewels and ornaments with a relevant artistic, religious or historical value. Silver-based alloys were also largely used everyday as monetary currency and form of saving playing a relevant role for the development and growth of the economy. By means of the combined use of complementary surface analytical techniques such as scanning electron microscopy coupled with energy dispersive spectrometry (SEM+EDS), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), X-ray diffraction (XRD) and optical microscopy (OM) we have investigated the micro- and nano-chemical nature of the products of corrosion naturally formed on archaeological silver-based Roman objects characterised by different burial conditions. The results allow the identification of different corrosion products formed during the long interaction between the elements constituting the alloy, i.e. Ag and Cu, and degradation agents present in the surrounding environment. The results of the integrated analytical methodologies highlight the role of chlorine, that is always present in the patina as chloroargyrite (AgCl, also known as cerargyrite or horn silver) and also in some cases of bromine which forms bromargyrite (AgBr) or bromian-chloroargyrite [Ag(Br,Cl)] as dominant corrosion products. The unusual presence of Br in the silver patina reflects the peculiar environmental chemistry suffered by the buried object likely due to the presence of degrading organic matter under aerobic conditions. Furthermore, the results reveal that chlorine often preferentially corrodes the numerous local copper enrichments randomly dispersed in the silver host matrix inducing the formation of harmful copper-chlorine compounds including Cu2Cl(OH)3 (atacamite and its polymorphs) and likely CuCl (nantokite) generally related to the copper cyclic corrosion called by conservators “bronze disease”. Finally, different corrosion patterns have been observed with the outermost layers often enriched by soil elements as S, Ca, Al, Si and Fe thus confirming the strong interaction of the alloys elements with the burial soil components.