Inhibition of calcium carbonate scale under severe conditions

Abstract

Despite extensive works have been devoted to study the scale inhibition behavior, the performance of inhibitors is still not fully understood. In this paper, we present a laboratory study to elucidate the impact of water composition on the performance of some commonly used phosphonate and polymeric calcium carbonate scale inhibitors, in highly supersaturated brines at high temperature. Calcium tolerance inhibitor chemicals with various molecular structures are studied using dynamic scale loop test method at 150 °C. Brine composition is varied by changing the non-stoichiometry of scaling lattice ions, e.g., ( Ca 2 + ) / ( CO 3 2 − ) ratio, over a wide range. Test results indicate that the effectiveness of inhibitors can be significantly changed by the scaling ion ratio. In general, the efficacy of inhibitors decreases significantly with calcium concentration in the test brine even at constant supersaturation state and temperature, and also the performance ranking of the different inhibitor chemistries can be changed with brine composition. This could be caused by the alternations of interactions between inhibitor molecules and the surface of calcium carbonate scale crystals. Findings from this study suggest that the effect of scaling ion ratio must be considered in scaling risk assessment and for the optimization of inhibitor treatment programs.