Impact of Spatial Management on Nontarget Species in an Oceanic Penaeid Trawl Fishery

Abstract

AbstractTrawling is generally an unselective fishing method that is employed to harvest a number of species. Capture of nontarget species that are subsequently discarded is an important issue for trawl fisheries, especially penaeid trawl fisheries. While gear modifications are a common approach to manage this issue, maintaining areas that are closed to trawling may also have a positive impact on these nontarget species. This study systematically examined the diversity and abundance of nontarget species across a network of areas closed to trawling (trawl closure areas) relative to adjacent areas that were open to trawling. Analysis of nontarget species from 209 trawls and 72,787 animals (across 216 taxa) revealed some impact on both abundance and diversity within trawl closure areas. Latitude was a key variable that was driving differences in the taxonomic assemblage among locations. Within locations, there were inconsistent impacts for different nontarget species in trawl closure areas. Length distributions showed size truncation of abundant nontarget species in fished areas relative to adjacent trawl closure areas. While the impact of trawl closure areas varied among species, it was clear that the spatial management in the fishery provided some refuge for a diversity of nontarget species, observed in patterns of species richness, abundance, and population size structure. Latitudinal breadth appears to be an essential component of the trawl closure network, but localized effects may be important for maintaining reproductive capacity for nontarget species. These data highlight the broader utility of trawl closure networks as a management tool for trawl fisheries.