Identification of cloud-to-ground lightning and intra-cloud lightning based on their radiated electric field signatures using different types of neural networks and machine learning classifiers

Abstract

The scope of this paper is to test the efficiency of three different neural networks in the area of cloud-to-ground/intra-cloud lightning classification using a not very large data set of electric field data. Effective neural network learning verified for a small lightning event dataset but with whole 2-seconds particular record length is an important feature of fast and efficient procedures implemented into lightning location systems among which discrimination between cloud-to-ground and intra-cloud lightning is one of the most important task. Measurement data obtained at the Lightning Observatory in Rzeszow were used for the analysis. About 100 extremely low/medium frequency bandwidth electric field of cloud-to ground lightning registrations and the same number of intra-cloud lightning events were taken into account. During the study 81% of those registrations were dedicated for learning of neural networks while the remaining 19% were put into the testing set. All data were preselected manually with consideration of the electric field variation and information from the lightning location system database. Lightning events were selected uniformly with the well-pronounced presence of their basic components and reported distance to the registration station which ensured a wide variation of expected lightning electric field signatures. The multilayer perceptron neural network, the radial basis function neural network and the convolutional neural network were tested and compared in different configurations while distinguishing lightning. The results were compared with other conventional classification approaches, such as traditional machine learning methods as well as one a little more contemporary architecture, the long short-term memory neural network. The multilayer perceptron neural network achieved the best detection accuracy overall. Presented research is an extension of lightning identification studies available so far mainly based on the convolutional neural network by the results achieved using the multilayer perceptron neural network, the radial basis function neural network, the long short-term memory neural network and several machine learning-based classification methods.