HOLMIUM: YAG LITHOTRIPSY YIELDS SMALLER FRAGMENTS THAN LITHOCLAST, PULSED DYE LASER OR ELECTROHYDRAULIC LITHOTRIPSY

Abstract

Purpose The mechanism of lithotripsy differs among electrohydraulic lithotripsy, mechanical lithotripsy, pulsed dye lasers and holmium:YAG lithotripsy. It is postulated that fragment size from each of these lithotrites might also differ. This study tests the hypothesis that holmium:YAG lithotripsy yields the smallest among the lithotrites. Materials and Methods We tested 3F electrohydraulic lithotripsy, 2 mm. mechanical lithotripsy, 320 micro m. pulsed dye lasers and 365 micro m. holmium:YAG fiber on stones composed of calcium hydrogen phosphate dihydrate, calcium oxalate monohydrate, cystine, magnesium ammonium phosphate and uric acid. Fragments were dessicated and sorted by size. Fragment size distribution was compared among lithotrites for each composition. Results Holmium:YAG fragments were significantly smaller on average than fragments from the other lithotrites for all compositions. There were no holmium:YAG fragments greater than 4 mm., whereas there were for the other lithotrites. Holmium:YAG had significantly greater weight of fragments less than 1 mm. compared to the other lithotrites. Conclusions Holmium:YAG yields smaller fragments compared to electrohydraulic lithotripsy, mechanical lithotripsy or pulsed dye lasers. These findings imply that fragments from holmium:YAG lithotripsy are more likely to pass without problem compared to the other lithotrites. Furthermore, the significant difference in fragment size adds evidence that holmium:YAG lithotripsy involves vaporization.