Herbivore-induced expansion of generalist species as a driver of homogenization in post-disturbance plant communities

Abstract

We used a controlled experiment to investigate how disturbance scale (canopy gap area) and herbivory influence post-disturbance plant community dynamics. Twenty canopy gaps were installed in a temperate hemlock-hardwood forest during the winter of 2002–2003: seven small gaps (50–150 m2), seven medium gaps (151–250 m2), and six large gaps (251–450 m2). Within each gap, we established 4–12 sample plots (depending on gap size); 1–3 of which were enclosed with wire mesh white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) exclosures in 2005. Gaps were revisited and intensively sampled in 2007. After five growing seasons, ground-layer plant communities in non-exclosed plots were more similar compositionally than exclosure plots. Non-exclosed plots in small and medium gaps were more similar to non-exclosed plots in large gaps than they were to exclosed plots in their respective gap size class. Shade-tolerant forbs and trees were less common outside exclosures, while generalist species associated with higher understory light levels and exotics were more prevalent outside exclosures. Our results suggest that even in forests with relatively low deer densities (6.5–9.3 deer km−2), white-tailed deer herbivory may influence the developmental trajectory of post-disturbance plant communities and be a mechanism for decreasing β-diversity along environmental gradients.