Green Alternatives for the Control of Fungal Diseases in Strawberry: In-Field Optimization of the Use of Elicitors, Botanical Extracts and Essential Oils

Abstract

Finding safe and reliable alternatives to fungicides is currently one of the biggest challenges in agriculture. In this regard, this experiment investigated the effectiveness of different elicitors, botanical extracts and essential oils to control grey mold (Botrytis cinerea) and powdery mildew (Podosphaera aphanis) on strawberry plants. This trial was conducted in field conditions under a plastic tunnel with strawberry plants ‘Elsanta’. A first group of strawberry plants was treated before flowering with elicitors [acibenzolar-S-Methyl–(BTH), chitosan], botanical extracts (seaweed extract, alfalfa hydrolysate) and essential oils (thyme and juniper), and grey mold incidence on flowers was evaluated (Experiment 1). Furthermore, a second group of plants was treated before (Experiment 2) and after (Experiment 3) controlled inoculation with P. aphanis. The results indicated that the incidence of flower infected by B. cinerea was reduced by approximately 50% with thyme and juniper essential oils’ applications compared to the untreated control, with no significant difference observed compared to the commercial fungicide penconazole (positive control). As a consequence, the final yield of essential-oil-treated plants was +27% higher than that of non-treated plants. No significant differences emerged for other tested products against grey mold. However, gene expression analysis showed an up-regulation (>2 ÷ 5 folds as compared to control 4 days after application) of FaEDS1, FaLOX and PR gene expression (FaPR1, FaPR5, FaPR10) in leaves treated with BTH. The other natural substances tested also induced defense-related genes, albeit at a lower level than BTH. In Experiment 2, all treatments applied prior to inoculation significantly reduced the incidence and severity of powdery mildew as compared to control. At 28 days after inoculation, chitosan and thyme essential oil applications performed similarly to their positive controls (BTH and penconazole, respectively), showing a significant reduction in disease incidence (by −84 and −92%) as compared to control. Post-inoculum application of essential oils (Experiment 3) showed an efficacy similar to that of penconazole against powdery mildew. These results indicated that the tested substances could be used as alternatives to fungicides for the control of grey mold and powdery mildew in strawberry, therefore representing a valuable tool for the control of these fungal diseases under the framework of sustainable agriculture.