Financial conflicts of interest among the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) Clinical Practice Guideline (CPG) Panelists in 2019.

Abstract

15 Background: CPG are evidence-based guidelines, which serve as a standard of care in practice, quality improvement, and reimbursement. The extent of financial conflicts of Interest (FCOI) in NCCN guidelines has not been recently evaluated. Our study evaluated the extent of FCOI in the NCCN CPG among the 10 most common malignancies in the US. Methods: We examined the latest 2019 version of the NCCN CPG for the 10 most common cancers by incidence in the US. Using disclosure lists, we catalogued the FCOIs for the panelists under various categories outlined in the CPG. We also tabulated the companies/institutions involved in each disclosure. An “episode” describes 1 instance of participation of a panelist in 1 company in 1 category of each guideline. “Affiliation” describes a commercial, industry, or institute affiliation reported by a panelist in each episode. Results: Of the 491 panelists on the CPG, 483 (98.3%) completed FCOI disclosures. 224 (46.38%) reported at least 1 FCOI. A total of 1,103 episodes were disclosed with an average of 4.9 episodes per panelist with FCOI. Being a part of scientific advisory boards, consultant, or expert witness was the most common FCOI category (19.9%). A total of 191 companies were associated with 1,103 episodes of FCOI. The top companies were Bristol Myers Squibb, Merck, Genentech and AstraZeneca. Among the top 10 cancers, the prevalence of FCOI were lung (56%), bladder (52%), pancreatic (52%), non-Hodgkin lymphoma (50%), kidney (49%), colorectal (43%), breast (42%), melanoma (40%), prostate (38%), and uterine (32%). Among the panelists with FCOI, 26%, 17%, and 57% reported 1, 2, and > 3 episodes, respectively. There were 127 episodes among the CPG chairs/vice chairs who reported FCOI (mean 6.4). The chairs/vice chairs of uterine, pancreatic, melanoma, and prostate cancer CPG did not have any FCOI. Conclusions: FCOI are very prevalent among the top 10 NCCN CPG panelists. In almost half of the CPG, the majority of the panelists had at least 1 FCOI. Over half of the CPG chairs/vice chairs reported multiple FCOI. Further studies are necessary to determine the impact of these FCOI.