Abstract

In the area of computer vision, deep learning techniques have recently been used to predict whether urban scenes are likely to be considered beautiful: it turns out that these techniques are able to make accurate predictions. Yet they fall short when it comes to generating actionable insights for urban design. To support urban interventions, one needs to go beyond predicting beauty, and tackle the challenge of recreating beauty. Unfortunately, deep learning techniques have not been designed with that challenge in mind. Given their ‘black-box nature’, these models cannot be directly used to explain why a particular urban scene is deemed to be beautiful. To partly fix that, we propose a deep learning framework (which we name FaceLift1) that is able to both beautify existing urban scenes (Google Street Views) and explain which urban elements make those transformed scenes beautiful. To quantitatively evaluate our framework, we cannot resort to any existing metric (as the research problem at hand has never been tackled before) and need to formulate new ones. These new metrics should ideally capture the presence (or absence) of elements that make urban spaces great. Upon a review of the urban planning literature, we identify five main metrics: walkability, green spaces, openness, landmarks and visual complexity. We find that, across all the five metrics, the beautified scenes meet the expectations set by the literature on what great spaces tend to be made of. This result is further confirmed by a 20-participant expert survey in which FaceLift has been found to be effective in promoting citizen participation. All this suggests that, in the future, as our framework’s components are further researched and become better and more sophisticated, it is not hard to imagine technologies that will be able to accurately and efficiently support architects and planners in the design of the spaces we intuitively love.

Highlights

  • Whether a street is considered beautiful is subjective, yet research has shown that there are specific urban elements that are universally considered beautiful: from greenery, to small streets, to memorable spaces [1,2,3]

  • — We propose a deep learning framework that is able to learn whether a particular set of Google Street Views are beautiful or not, and based on that training, the framework is able to both beautify existing views and explain which urban elements make them beautiful (§3)

  • To ascertain whether FaceLift meets that composite goal, we answer the following questions : Q1 Do individuals perceive ‘FaceLifted’ scenes to be beautiful? Q2 Does our framework produce scenes that possess urban elements typical of great spaces? Q3 Which urban elements are mostly associated with beautiful scenes? Q4 Do architects and urban planners find FaceLift useful?

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Whether a street is considered beautiful is subjective, yet research has shown that there are specific urban elements that are universally considered beautiful: from greenery, to small streets, to memorable spaces [1,2,3]. These elements are those that contribute to the creation of what the urban sociologist Jane Jacobs called ‘urban vitality’ [4]. We do so by proposing a family of five urban design metrics that we have formulated based on a thorough review of the literature in urban planning For all these five metrics, the framework passes with flying colours: with minimal interventions, beautified scenes are twice as walkable as the original ones, for example. After building an interactive tool with ‘FaceLifted’ scenes in Boston and presenting it to 20 experts in architecture, we found that the majority of them agreed on three main areas of our work’s impact: decision making, participatory urbanism and the promotion of restorative spaces

Perception of physical spaces
Ground truth of urban perceptions
Deep learning and the city
Generative models
FaceLift framework
Step 1
Step 2
Step 3
Step 4
Step 5
Evaluation
Q1 People’s perceptions of beautified scenes
Q2 Are beautified scenes great urban spaces?
H2 Beautified scenes tend to offer green spaces
H3 Beautified scenes tend to feel private and ‘cosy’
H4 Beautified scenes tend to be visually rich
Q3 Urban elements characterizing beautified scenes
Q4 Do architects and urban planners find it useful?
Discussion
Limitations
Conclusion
Full Text
Paper version not known

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.