Evolution of ontogenetic niches promotes species coexistence in a surprising way.

Abstract

Animals usually change their trophic niche during their ontogeny, which has fundamental consequences for their population dynamics and interactions with other species. Theory predicts that ontogenetic niche differences between species can influence their ability to coexist. However, we lack empirical evidence for this coexistence mechanism and the role of evolution in shaping species' ontogenetic niches. Here, Anaya-Rojas et al. (2023) show that contemporary evolution of ontogenetic niches likely contributes to the coexistence of two competing fish species (killifish and guppies) in streams on the Caribbean Island of Trinidad. As predicted by coexistence theory, they found that the weaker competitor (killifish) exhibited a relatively large ontogenetic niche shift, feeding at higher trophic levels as it grew, in streams where competition with the stronger competitor (guppies) was intense. Intuition suggests that the weaker competitor should experience strong selection on its ontogenetic niche in a different competitive environment, but this was not the case. Instead, they found that the stronger competitor evolved a more compressed ontogenetic niche, where guppies fed at a low trophic level regardless of their body size, when competition was intense. Although the mechanism underlying this surprising result remains to be determined, this work points to the importance of taking a food web perspective-explicitly accounting for consumer-resource interactions-to understand the outcome of eco-evolutionary dynamics. Given that ontogenetic niche shifts are extremely common in animals, understanding the evolutionary ecology of these niche shifts should be a priority for future research on species coexistence.