Evaluation of resilient abutment components on measured strain using dynamic loading conditions

Abstract

Statement of problem. Factors that affect transmission of strain from prostheses to bone may affect the long-term success of loaded implants. Current in vitro models are theoretically predictive (finite element modeling) or facsimile (photoelastic) in nature. A more clinically relevant in vitro model for strain evaluation should be investigated. Purpose. This study attempted: (1) to validate a human cadaver bone model for in vitro measurement of cortical bone strain, and (2) to evaluate the effect on cortical strain measurements of a resilient plastic component incorporated within a titanium implant in response to variable dynamic loading. Material and methods. Two IMZ (Interpore International) abutment alternatives were used: the titanium Abutment Complete and the polyoxymethylene Intra-mobile Element. The model system consisted of two implants placed in unfixed human cadaver ulna bone to simulate an implant bound edentulous region. Four biaxial rosette strain gauges simultaneously recorded cortical bone strain immediately mesial and distal to each implant. During experimentation a simulated prosthetic framework supported by either titanium or polyoxymethylene abutments was dynamically loaded 6 mm from the terminal abutment along a cantilever extension. Cyclic nominal peak loads were applied with a materials testing machine at 20N intervals from 20 to 200 N at a crosshead speed of 5 mm/minute. The protocol allowed frequency of load application to vary. A Newtonian linear correlation ( r 2 ≥ 0.98) between load application and strain output was determined for each gauge position except for the terminal gauge located opposite the cantilever. Results. Cortical strains recorded were within reported physiologic ranges involved in bone modeling and remodeling. Further, the polyoxymethylene abutment components did not result in reduction of peak microstrain at any gauge position. The Intra-mobile Element abutments, however, did increase the time required to complete 10 loading cycles when compared with the titanium Abutment Complete abutments for the crosshead speed and ultimate loads evaluated. Conclusions. Results indicate the cadaver bone behaved in an elastic manner within the load range evaluated, and as such represents a viable in vitro experimental model. Under these conditions, polyoxymethylene abutment components do not affect measurable bone strain in response to variable loading when compared with titanium. (J Prosthet Dent 1998;80:46-51.)