Estimating the performance of international regulatory regimes

Abstract

This paper is now published as:Siegfried, Tobias, Bernauer, Thomas. 2007. Estimating the Performance of International Regulatory Regimes: Methodology and Empirical Application to International Water Management in the Naryn / Syr Darya Basin. Water Resources Research 43, W11406, doi:10.1029/2006WR005738, 2007. Please read and cite the published version.We develop a methodology for estimating the performance of international regulatory regimes, building on work by Underdal, Sprinz, Helm, and Hovi. Our performance metric (PER) relies on assessments, over time, of actual performance, counterfactual performance, and optimal performance. To demonstrate the empirical relevance of this methodology we examine international water management in the Naryn/Syr Darya basin, a major international river system in Central Asia. The emphasis is on the Toktogul reservoir, the main reservoir in the Naryn/Syr Darya basin, and its downstream effects. The biggest policy challenge in this case has been to design and implement international trade-offs among water releases for upstream hydropower-production in winter and water releases for downstream irrigation in summer. We find that the international regime in place since 1998 is characterized by low average performance and high variability. We compare these results with results from a compliance-oriented assessment approach to highlight the analytical problems inherent in the latter.