Estimating cation exchange capacity from hygroscopic water content change

Abstract

Listen

Translate article

AbstractThe existing models for estimating cation exchange capacity (CEC) from easy‐to‐measure hygroscopic water content (θh) were based on a single water activity (aw) value rather than on the processes that govern soil water vapor adsorption for a distinct aw range. Here, we present a new CEC estimation model based on θh data of 119 soils with different clay mineralogy (i.e., illitic [IL], montmorillonitic [ML], and kaolinitic [KA] samples) and organic carbon (OC) contents for the aw range from 0.23 to 0.57 (Δθ0.23–0.57) and validate its performance. Based on the hypothesis that multilayer adsorption exhibits a higher correlation with CEC than monolayer adsorption and capillary condensation, the aw range from 0.23 to 0.57 was chosen with CEC calculated as CEC = k × Δθ0.23–0.57. The performance of the new model is compared to the Arthur (2017) model and the Torrent (2015) model, which considers a single θh value. The average proportionality coefficient (k) varied with the dominant clay mineralogy of the investigated soils. For soils dominated by 2:1 clay minerals (i.e., IL and ML), the new model showed a good estimation accuracy (Nash‐Sutcliffe model efficiency [E] ≥ 0.85; root mean squared error [RMSE] ≤ 4.18 cmol(+) kg−1). The new model performed better for IL and ML samples than for KA samples, and yielded more accurate CEC estimations than the Arthur model and Torrent model for soils with 2:1 clay minerals. For soil with high OC content (>23.2 g kg−1), the new model slightly underestimated CEC (E = 0.66; RMSE = 5.87).