Enabling effective urban green space stewardship through planning: A qualitative comparative analysis in Southwest England
Abstract Amid increasing urbanisation and biodiversity decline, ‘effective stewardship’ of urban green space (UGS) is a complex but critical nature‐based solution for long‐term environmental, social and economic gain. Combining stewardship and sense‐of‐place frameworks with European nature‐based solutions guidance, we investigate which social and ecological conditions are present in ‘effectively stewarded’ UGS sites, aiming to assist Local Governments (LGs) in future‐proof UGS planning. Through 138 on‐site interviews, project meetings, online research, biodiversity assessments and landscape appraisals, we score the likelihood of ongoing effective stewardship at 25 UGS sites across Cornwall (England) following an LG‐led enhancement project. Combining measures of biodiversity change, local people's perception, LG maintenance budget and volunteer activity across diverse perspectives, we found 16 sites had a high likelihood of ongoing effective stewardship under varied governance systems, and 9 had a lower likelihood. Through Qualitative Comparative Analysis, we found five social/ecological conditions influenced this likelihood: neighbourhood capacity (deprivation level and presence of volunteer gardening groups nearby); landscape quality (e.g. mature trees, far‐reaching views, heritage features); relations between residents and LG bodies (historic collaborations/tensions); change in sense‐of‐place (impact of works on emotional person‐place bonds); and financial input (cost of enhancement works). We characterise four pathways (combinations of these conditions) that enable effective ongoing stewardship, and three that make it difficult. Effective stewardship can be enabled at lower cost in higher capacity neighbourhoods with high landscape quality, but LG financial input becomes key in disadvantaged neighbourhoods. Understanding local sense‐of‐place is fundamental. Notably, historic LG‐resident tensions feature in all three ‘less effective’ pathways, regardless of neighbourhood capacity, landscape quality or cost of works. Current narratives around devolving stewardship to local communities are critically discussed with reference to study outcomes. Historic narratives defining aesthetic appeal can influence residents ‘relational values’ with nature (from pride/care associated with well‐tended flowerbeds, to reverence for tangled urban wildness). However, our results indicate perspectives around ‘tidiness’ and ‘mess’ are changing, and not mutually exclusive. Colourful, low‐maintenance, pollinator‐friendly plants (native or non‐native) were well‐received and biodiverse ‘messiness’ tolerated (sometimes welcomed) so long as ‘cues to care’ (especially regular, targeted mowing) were apparent. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
- Conference Article
2
- 10.2991/nceece-15.2016.215
- Jan 1, 2016
This paper use the advanced experience of Japan in the area of disaster prevention green space planning and construction and, look at the status, gaps and challenges of China's construction and planning of Green Infrastructure, present the new thinking direction about the construction of disaster prevention green space combine with Green Infrastructure.Taking the construction of the disaster prevention green infrastructure network planning of Majiagou River in Harbin as an example and put forward related strategies.
- Research Article
70
- 10.1016/j.ufug.2021.127133
- Apr 8, 2021
- Urban Forestry & Urban Greening
Quantifying emotional differences in urban green spaces extracted from photos on social networking sites: A study of 34 parks in three cities in northern China
- Book Chapter
2
- 10.4324/9781003133827-12
- Nov 29, 2021
In light of changing urban conditions, urban green space (UGS) planning has been concerned with how to introduce and institutionalise new governing policies that encourage particular UGS qualities and forms. Employing environmental justice as an analytical concept, we investigated how urban transformations have shaped Vienna’s UGS policies, it’s institutional setting as well as outcomes in terms of just provision. Vienna has maintained a high share of UGS – mostly large scale – including longstanding, uneven patterns. Recently, the City increased its efforts to implement more diverse UGS – small to micro scale – addressing multiple needs in light of the climate crisis.
- Research Article
16
- 10.1007/s12132-018-9349-0
- Nov 7, 2018
- Urban Forum
Global development agenda such as the Sustainable Development Goals call for natural-based strategies to make urban areas sustainable. One approach is urban greenspace planning. In Ghana, however, planning response to urban problems has often been inadequate and/or unresponsive. As such, the effective role of planning authorities in urban greenspace planning becomes a critical issue. This paper asks three questions: (i) What attention has been given to urban greenspaces in urban development plans for the Kumasi Metropolis? (ii) What challenges do urban planners encounter in urban greenspace planning in the Kumasi Metropolis? (iii) What factors should urban authorities consider in urban greenspace planning in the Kumasi Metropolis? This paper used content analysis on five urban development plans and interviews with urban development professionals in the Kumasi Metropolis, Ghana. The findings show that urban greenspaces receive low attention in urban development plans. Institutional barriers to urban greenspace planning included a lack of innovation in visions for urban greenspaces, political interference, inadequate funding, disharmony in land management, misconception about land use, and a low appreciation of urban greenspaces among residents and landowners. This study concludes that these factors undermine urban greenspace planning capacity of urban authorities in the Metropolis. Therefore, urban greenspace planning must take cognizance of these factors and act to mitigate their effects on urban greenspace planning in the Kumasi Metropolis.
- Research Article
2
- 10.1080/13549839.2024.2353046
- May 15, 2024
- Local Environment
Everyone has the right to feel welcome, safe and be able to access public green spaces without fear, anxiety or stress. However, the term “accessibility” is primarily used in relation to physical accessibility, while social and cultural dimensions of accessibility to urban public green spaces remains underexplored. Methods and tools for universal design and management that also meets the needs of marginalised groups, are needed. This requires involvement of both users and potential users through participatory methods, building on individual needs and perspectives. In Sweden, traditionally marginalised groups and non-users are rarely engaged in the development of public urban green spaces. Local governments may have the will, but lack resources and appropriate methods in order to do so. Research has recently described a further engagement of users as an unleashed potential in relation to planning and management of urban green spaces. Based on the study of three test beds and the use of public green space governance and management theory, we developed a process model for user participation in green space maintenance with focus on involving marginalised groups and non-users. The model balances what is theoretical optimal with what is practically feasible within the daily work of a municipal organisation. We present an empirically tested process model that can form the basis for future maintenance of urban green spaces, with the use of limited resources.
- Research Article
229
- 10.1016/j.cities.2012.06.017
- Jul 14, 2012
- Cities
Socioeconomic effect on perception of urban green spaces in Guangzhou, China
- Research Article
4
- 10.1002/lim2.96
- Nov 23, 2023
- Lifestyle Medicine
IntroductionWith the rapid growth of urbanization globally and in the UK, increasing attention is now being directed towards urban green spaces (UGS). The appeal of UGS to policymakers lies in their capacity to address multiple policy objectives, including improving physical and mental wellbeing, mitigating noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), combating climate change through carbon sequestration, providing climate adaptation measures, and enhancing biodiversity.MethodThis narrative review gives an overview of the current literature and UK policy relating to urban green and blue spaces, with a particular focus on the use of UGS to increase physical activity levels.ResultsUGS have a profound impact on public health, with evidence indicating their positive effect on both physical and psychological health. Thirty‐eight percent of adults in the UK do not live within 15 minutes of UGS, so policy makers at national and international level are aiming to address this gap. One reason for the health benefits of UGS is associated increased physical activity, a vital component needed to address the burden of non‐communicable disease. To effectively harness UGS to promote physical activity various factors must be considered; proximity and diversity of urban green spaces, and the presence of suitable infrastructure features. Tailoring UGS to meet the needs and preferences of different population demographics is essential, as is ensuring safety, and addressing barriers to access particularly for lower socio‐economic groups. The careful planning of UGS must avoid potential gentrification effects and displacement of vulnerable communities, whilst utilising the equigenic nature of UGS.ConclusionsTo create a brighter future and capitalize on the potential of UGS, a collaborative approach is needed, involving communities, local governments, and national authorities. Primary‐care professionals, represented by organizations like the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP), can play a crucial role in advocating for UGS and physical activity, promoting their use, and providing guidance and support.
- Research Article
- 10.3390/urbansci9100434
- Oct 21, 2025
- Urban Science
Urban green space (UGS) is a fundamental element of urban systems for enhancing the quality of urban life. UGS plays a pivotal role in promoting urban ecological sustainability if important criteria are integrated into urban planning programs. This paper explores the impacts of the ecological criteria on urban sustainability through UGS planning and examines these criteria within the context of the Adelaide Metropolitan Area as a case study. To address the study’s goals, a content analysis was conducted to identify the most critical criteria affecting urban ecological sustainability through UGS planning. Subsequently, based on the identified criteria, a household survey was conducted to evaluate the status of the case study concerning the ecological sustainability factors. In this stage, 100 responses were collected through a questionnaire survey. Then, based on the household survey results, a solution was provided to the challenging criteria by a local experts’ interview. For promoting urban ecological sustainability, ten criteria were identified as the most important and effective criteria based on the previous studies. Household survey data was analysed using one-sample T-test, multiple linear regression, and geographically weighted regression (GWR) model. The results indicated that the criteria of reviving ecological networks, water resources, and the protection of UGS with the score below standard average (which is 3), require practical guidelines and policies to enhance the sustainability of Adelaide Metropolitan Area. The regression analysis demonstrated that ecological landscape and design had the strongest positive effect on sustainability (adjusted R2 = 0.685), while the geographically weighted regression highlighted biodiversity and vegetation as particularly influential in Plympton (local R2 = 0.866) and Unley (local R2 = 0.488). Expert interviews recommended strategies such as wastewater recycling, long-term conservation planning, and restoring ecological connectivity. This study provides a practical framework to guide urban planners and policymakers in enhancing ecological sustainability through UGS planning.
- Research Article
- 10.25236/ajhss.2022.050302
- Jan 1, 2022
- Academic Journal of Humanities & Social Sciences
At present, people pay more and more attention to the benefits of urban ecological environment, including the demands of human living environment. Based on this, through the research on urban green space planning strategy considering ecological effects, and on the basis of fully clarifying the supporting conditions for integrating ecological effects into urban green space planning and the contradiction between supply and demand existing in the current planning, from improving the planning and control of urban green space system, establishing the performance evaluation and monitoring system of urban green space ecosystem Several planning strategies are proposed to realize the compound ecological effect and service function of urban green space. It is expected to provide an important basis for solving the contradiction between supply and demand in urban green space planning and realizing the reasonable maintenance of urban green space.
- Research Article
58
- 10.3390/su10010214
- Jan 17, 2018
- Sustainability
Urban green space is closely related to the quality of life of residents. However, the traditional approach to its planning often fails to address its actual service capacity and users’ demand. In this study, facilitated by mobile phone location data, more specific features of the spatial distribution of urban residents are identified. Further, population distribution in relation to traffic analysis zones is mapped. On this basis, the two-step floating catchment area method (2SFCA) is adopted in combination with urban green space planning to evaluate the per capita area of green space and its accessibility in practice. Subsequently, classification of per capita area and spatial distribution of green spaces within the study area are obtained; thus, urban districts currently with low accessibility to green areas are identified and can be deemed as key areas for the planning of green areas in the future. The study concludes that mobile phone data can be used to more accurately map the spatial distribution of residents; while, the 2SFCA offers a more comprehensive quantitative measuring of the supply and demand of green spaces. The two combined can be used as an important basis for decision-making in the planning of urban green spaces. Since urban green space can be regarded as a kind of public facility, the methodology of the present study is also believed to be applicable in studies of other types of urban facilities.
- Research Article
35
- 10.1016/j.ufug.2019.126424
- Aug 1, 2019
- Urban Forestry & Urban Greening
Benchmark assessment of recreational public Urban Green space provisions: A case of typical urbanizing Indian City, Nagpur
- Research Article
23
- 10.1016/j.ufug.2022.127677
- Jul 15, 2022
- Urban Forestry & Urban Greening
Having access to and visiting urban green space (UGS) improves liveability and provides considerable benefits to residents. However, traditional methods of investigating UGS visitation, such as questionnaires and social surveys, are usually time- and resource-intensive, and frequently provide less transferable, site-specific outcomes. This study uses social media data (Twitter) to examine spatio-temporal changes in UGS use in London associated with COVID-19 related lockdowns. It compares georeferenced Tweets posted in a 3 month period from 23 March to 23 June for 3 years covering the first lockdown in the UK in 2020, with Tweets for the same period in 2019 and 2021. The results show that (1) the land-use type of Public Park and Garden was the most frequently visited type of UGS, which may be correlated with these UGS areas remaining opening during the lockdown period; (2) the usage of UGS decreased in central London and increased in other areas during lockdown, which may correlated with working from home restrictions; (3) activities were positively associated with Physical activities maybe as a result of allowing people to take a single daily exercise, and (4) people spent more time in UGS areas on weekdays than weekends compared to pre-lockdown. This is the first study to examine social media data over consistent time period before, during and after the lockdown in relation to UGS. The results show that the findings and method can inform policy makers in their management and planning of UGS, especially in a period of social crisis like the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Research Article
22
- 10.3390/su132011344
- Oct 14, 2021
- Sustainability
Urban forestry and green spaces have less priority in urban planning. This research intends to assess the policy and planning of urban green spaces with their potential implementation status and challenges in planning and implementation. The general objective is to assess urban green space planning, policy, and implementation strategies and challenges encountered in Addis Ababa. The primary data was collected through key informant interviews, focus group discussions, and field observation; secondary data from a literature review along with examining policy and masterplans of Addis Ababa has been used. The mapping of stakeholder and institutional arrangements is analyzed using stakeholders’ consultation. Triangulation is used for data validation and analysis. Existing policy and proclamations must be supported by legislative regulations and implementation frameworks that provide the basis for concrete action plans. The incentives stipulated by the forest policy are not implemented to the required level. The 10th masterplan of the city (2017–2027) shows that the city will increase its green area development and public recreation coverage to 30% by 2020. Principles, such as multi-functionality, connectivity, green-grey interaction, and social inclusiveness, are considered in the planning of the green space development in the 10th masterplan. The research concludes that regulations and directives are not clearly drafted by responsible bodies, and low enforcement is hardly applied with respect to the green space development of Addis Ababa.
- Research Article
85
- 10.1016/j.landusepol.2017.11.006
- Nov 7, 2017
- Land Use Policy
Is urban agriculture urban green space? A comparison of policy arrangements for urban green space and urban agriculture in Santiago de Chile
- Research Article
3
- 10.7882/az.2019.009
- Jan 1, 2020
- Australian Zoologist
Urbanisation is altering local flora and fauna, but urban greenspaces can provide refugia for a variety of taxa. However, we often lack basic biodiversity information (e.g., species richness) for these urban greenspaces. Citizen science projects are continuously improving our understanding of ecology at broad temporal and spatial scales. But, many conservation-relevant decisions are idiosyncratic and made at small management scales (e.g., local government). Given a general bias of citizen science data towards areas with large human populations, citizen scientists are best placed to contribute to improving our understanding of the biodiversity within cities and urban greenspaces. We introduce the Greenspace Bird Calculator: a web-app aimed at enhancing our collective knowledge of bird diversity in urban greenspaces. Users of the web-app could be land managers seeking to understand the bird diversity in the greenspaces they manage. It is built in a reproducible workflow, allowing anyone to delineate a greenspace and submit it to the web-app administrator, receiving an output comprising the greenspace’s total bird diversity. The Greenspace Bird Calculator web-app provides an automated tool to utilise existing eBird citizen science data to calculate species richness for urban greenspaces globally. Critically, the GBC web-app statistically assesses available data that otherwise would be unlikely to be considered by decision-makers. This web-app is an example of the evolution of citizen science, whereby the data collected has been analysed to allow accessible interpretation and inclusion into urban greenspace management and planning.
- Ask R Discovery
- Chat PDF
AI summaries and top papers from 250M+ research sources.