Does new magnetic resonance imaging technology provide better geometrical accuracy during stereotactic imaging?

Abstract

The authors sought to compare the accuracy of stereotactic target imaging using the Siemens 1T EXPERT and 1.5T SYMPHONY magnetic resonance (MR) units. A water-filled cylindrical Perspex phantom with axial and coronal inserts containing grids of glass rods was fixed in the Leksell stereotactic frame and subjected to MR imaging in Siemens 1T EXPERT and Siemens 1.5T SYMPHONY units. Identical sequences were used for each unit. The images were transferred to the GammaPlan treatment planning system. Deviations between stereotactic coordinates based on MR images and estimated real geometrical positions given by the construction of the phantom insert were evaluated for each study. The deviations were further investigated as a function of the MR unit used, MR sequence, the image orientation, and the spatial position of measured points in the investigated volume. Larger distortions were observed when using the SYMPHONY 1.5T unit than those with the EXPERT 1T unit. Typical average distortion in EXPERT 1T was not more than 0.6 mm and 0.9 mm for axial and coronal images, respectively. Typical mean distortion for SYMPHONY 1.5T was not more than 1 mm and 1.3 mm for axial and coronal images, respectively. The image sequence affected the distortions in both units. Coronal T2-weighted spin-echo images performed in subthalamic imaging produced the largest distortions of 2.6 mm and 3 mm in the EXPERT 1T and SYMPHONY 1.5T, respectively. Larger distortions were observed in coronal slices than in axial slices in both units, and this effect was more pronounced in SYMPHONY 1.5T. Noncentrally located slice positions in the investigated volume of the phantom were associated with larger distortions.