Discussion on ‘Paleozoic sedimentation and Caledonian terrane architecture in NW Svalbard: indications from U–Pb geochronology and structural analysis’ by Koglin et al . 2022 ( JGS , 179, jgs2021-053)

Abstract

Koglin et al. (2022) present valuable new isotopic and field data regarding northwest Spitsbergen's tectonic history, and propose the existence of the Germaniahalvøya terrane with Scandian (Late Caledonian) igneous activity and deformation. Within this terrane, the Lerner Deformation zone (LDZ), is cast as an east-directed thrust, with the Liefdefjorden Migmatite Complex in the footwall and Lenerøyane Group meta-sediments above. The LDZ occurs on the west limb of the major, shallowly north plunging, Bockfjorden anticline. We suggest their data supports the unmentioned and discussed idea (Dallmann & Piepjohn 2018, Braathen et al. 2018) that a Scandian metamorphic core complex exists here and that the LDZ is part of the Keisarhjelmen extensional detachment (Braathen et al. 2017, Maher et. al. 2022). The detachment consists of ductile to brittle, retrogressive, fault rocks up to several hundred meters thick along the contact between metamorphic basement and overlying Devonian basin strata. In addition, we note that Koglin et al's (2022) evidence for Scandian activity is consistent with core complex dynamics.