Discussion of “Nondestructive measurement of the capillary water absorption coefficient and water transport behaviors of porous building materials by using single-sided NMR”

Abstract

In February 2024, Construction and Building Materials published the paper “Nondestructive measurement of the capillary water absorption coefficient and water transport behaviors of porous building materials by using single-sided NMR”, which claims to measure the capillary absorption of moisture in brick, sandstone, mortar and concrete by means of moisture content profiling with the ‘NMR mouse’, a low-field, single-sided, open-magnet NMR instrument. This critique formulates several serious concerns on the study’s outcomes and conclusions. The excessively large similarity of the capillary absorption behaviour of the four materials is peculiar, since it disregards the differences in their open porosities and pore sizes. The overly large capillary moisture contents are equally abnormal, as they exceed the moisture storage limit of the material’s pore structure. There appears to be an inconsistency between the moisture content profiles and the overall moisture masses. Finally, it is shown that the lengthy time interval necessary for a single NMR pass limits the applicability of the NMR mouse for capillary absorption coefficients of porous building materials.