Developing consumer-led maternity services: a survey of women's views in a local healthcare setting.

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: This paper describes a prospective study of women's views and experiences of maternity services. The aim was to examine the way women make choices and decisions about maternity care and the factors which influence decision making, with a view to developing services which best meet the needs of the population. Patient choice issues reviewed included: choice of place of birth, choice of lead professional and choices in labour management. DESIGN, SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: A cohort of women attending maternity booking clinics, within the catchment area of Peterhead Maternity Unit (PMU) in north-east Scotland, were surveyed by means of postal questionnaires at three stages during their contact with maternity services. A subset of women also took part in in-depth interviews. RESULTS: Not all women were given information about all the available options for place of birth and many women were unclear of the differences between them. Factors influencing choice of place of birth can change, with the medical aspects of maternity care becoming more important as the pregnancy progresses. Women rated the importance of seeing the same staff at antenatal visits highly, but were less concerned with their ability to choose which professional to see. More importance was attached to being able to choose a particular midwife rather than a particular obstetrician. Women's choices with regard to labour management were largely met. Insufficient information, however, was provided about choices in pain relief. CONCLUSIONS: The survey revealed the importance of locally based research, involving all stakeholders, in developing services which best meet the needs of a population.