Denied Leadership: Patriarchal Barriers and Contextual Inequities in Women's School Leadership

Abstract

Translate Article

Take Notes

abstract This paper examined the experiences of three women school principals who have been denied the act of leadership while at the helm of leadership in their schools. Owing to patriarchal barriers and contextual inequities, women in school leadership continue to experience bias, discrimination, and prejudice in their respective institutions. Underpinned by the qualitative interpretive paradigm and using a phenomenological multiple case study as a research design, we used semi-structured interviews to generate data from three women school principals who were purposively selected. The participants were purposively selected based on gender and position, and their schools were located in one education district in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. We used thematic analysis to analyse data, and the findings revealed that entrenched patriarchal norms, institutional gatekeeping, and conflicting gender expectations undermined the leadership authority of women principals, often reducing their roles to symbolic positions. Participants faced a leadership paradox, expected to be both nurturing and assertive, yet penalised for either. Despite these challenges, the women actively resisted structural barriers through solidarity, mentorship, and professional networks, which served as strategic tools of resilience. The study recommends structured mentorship programmes, gender-sensitive leadership training, participatory community dialogues, and institutional accountability mechanisms such as gender inclusive recruitment practices to create more equitable leadership environments for women.