Defining fear of cancer recurrence using Rodgers’ evolutionary concept analysis

To investigate the trajectory, influencing factors and dynamic relationships between fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) and quality of life (QOL) in lung cancer patients. Prospective longitudinal study. Longitudinal data from 310 lung cancer patients across three hospitals in China were assessed at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months postoperatively (T1 -T4 ). Descriptive statistics characterised patient demographics, clinical characteristics, levels of FCR and QOL. A linear mixed-effects model was employed to analyse FCR trajectories, identify influencing factors on these trajectories, and predict the impact of FCR on QOL. FCR changed significantly over time, with a slight decrease during T1 -T2 , an increase at T3 and gradual decline at T4 . Higher fear levels were associated with female sex, suburban or rural residency, being a family breadwinner, presence of comorbidities and negative coping behaviours, and low family resilience. QOL negatively correlated with FCR, and FCR predicted lower QOL. At 3 and 6 months postoperatively, lung cancer patients, especially women, suburban or rural residents, family breadwinners, those with comorbidities, negative coping behaviours and low family resilience, reported high levels of FCR. Healthcare providers should pay special attention to lung cancer patients especially during the period of 3-6 months post-surgery and offer tailored interventions to improve their QOL. Understanding the FCR trajectories, its influencing factors and its negative impacts on QOL can guide the development of targeted interventions to reduce fear and enhance well-being in patients with cancer. Identifying the trajectories and influencing factors of fear of lung cancer recurrence in patients at different time points informs future research on targeted interventions to improve QOL. The study adhered to the guidelines outlined in the Statement on Reporting Observational Longitudinal Research.

SummaryPrevious studies on fear of cancer recurrence after endoscopic treatment for early Barrett’s neoplasia focused on fear during a relatively short period after the intervention. The aim of this study was to explore whether fear of cancer (recurrence) persists during long-term follow-up in patients treated endoscopically for Barrett’s neoplasia compared to patients treated surgically for a more advanced stage of esophageal adenocarcinoma. Participants previously participated in a prospective longitudinal study investigating quality of life and fear of cancer recurrence and were treated endoscopically for early Barrett’s neoplasia (high-grade dysplasia—T1sm1N0M0) or surgically for a more advanced esophageal adenocarcinoma (T1N0M0–T3N1M0). For the present study, participants were again invited to complete a set of questionnaires including the fear of cancer recurrence scale (FORS), worry for cancer scale (WOCS), and the anxiety subscale of the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS Anxiety). Thirty-nine patients were eligible in the endoscopy group and 28 in the surgical group. The median time between the baseline measurement (original study) and the long-term follow-up assessment was 4 years (interquartile range 3–5 years). Fear and worry for cancer recurrence and general anxiety diminished over time in both treatment groups. However, at long-term follow-up, endoscopically treated patients had significantly higher levels of worry for cancer and general anxiety than surgically treated patients. Fear of cancer recurrence did not significantly differ between endoscopically and surgically treated patients. We found that worry and fear of cancer recurrence and general anxiety in endoscopically treated patients declined over time, but not as much as in surgically treated patients.

Fear of cancer recurrence is one of the psychological distresses that seriously affects the quality of life of breast cancer patients. However, the evidence for cognitive behavioral therapy on fear of cancer recurrence in breast cancer is limited. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy in reducing breast cancer patients' fear of cancer recurrence. Seven databases were searched for randomized controlled studies on cognitive behavioral therapy for fear of cancer recurrence in cancer patients from the inception of the database to April 30, 2023, with no language restrictions. Meta-analysis was performed using Stata MP 17. The Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool version 2 was used to assess the quality of the included studies. The quality of evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation method. This review includes a total of 13 randomized controlled trials with 1447 breast cancer patients and survivors. When compared with controls, meta-analysis revealed that cognitive behavioral therapy significantly reduced the fear of cancer recurrence ( g = -0.44; 95% confidence interval, -0.75 to -0.13; P < .001), whereas subgroup analysis revealed that only mindfulness-based cognitive therapy was significant. The overall risk of bias was high. The Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation assessment showed a low overall quality of evidence. Cognitive behavioral therapy may be effective in reducing fear of cancer recurrence in breast cancer patients, and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy is particularly worthy of implementation. Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy may be used as an additional strategy to help manage breast cancer patients' fears of cancer recurrence.

Fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) is a significant psychological problem for cancer survivors. Some survivors experience FCR, which is both persistent and highly distressing. The aim of this systematic review was to identify the key factors associated with fear of recurrence among cancer patients. A comprehensive literature search using keywords was performed with three databases, followed by an organic search to identify additional relevant articles. Included studies had a quantitative methodology presenting empirical findings focussed on adult cancer patients. A methodological quality assessment was performed for each study, and the strength of evidence was defined by the consistency of results. Forty-three studies met the inclusion criteria and are presented in this review. The most consistent predictor of elevated FCR was younger age. There was strong evidence for an association between physical symptoms and fear of cancer recurrence. Additional factors moderately associated with increased FCR included treatment type, low optimism, family stressors and fewer significant others. Inconsistent evidence was found for socio-demographic factors. Fear of cancer recurrence is a complex issue influenced by a multitude of factors, including demographic, clinical and psychological factors. However, some studies have reported contradictory evidence, and FCR has been measured using a range of scales, which can hamper comparison across studies. Further research is needed to clarify inconsistencies in the current published research.

The present study investigated the interrelationships among fatigue, depressive symptoms, resilience, and fear of cancer recurrence in patients with colorectal cancer. Patients were recruited from the colorectal cancer surgical outpatient departments of two medical centers in northern Taiwan. A total of 416 patients with colorectal cancer at Stages 0-III were recruited. The Fatigue Symptom Inventory, Resilience Scale, Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale, and Fear of Cancer Recurrence Inventory-Short Form were adopted. The generated serial multiple mediation model was examined using the Hayes PROCESS macro V4.3 in SPSS. The patients had mild overall scores in fatigue, depressive symptoms, and fear of cancer recurrence but moderate scores in resilience. Notably, 46.6% of the patients had clinical-level scores in fear of cancer recurrence. Fear of cancer recurrence was negatively correlated with resilience and positively correlated with fatigue and depressive symptoms. Furthermore, resilience and depressive symptoms fully mediated the relationship between fatigue and fear of cancer recurrence. The findings of this study underscore the pivotal roles of resilience and depressive symptoms in the relationship between fatigue and fear of cancer recurrence. Therefore, health care providers are encouraged to prioritize early assessment and the management of depressive symptoms in patients with colorectal cancer and incorporate resilience-focused interventions into their care plans. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).

To test the hypothesis that patient-initiated follow up reduces the fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) and healthcare use when compared with traditional hospital-based follow up. Pragmatic, multicentre randomised trial. Four Danish departments of gynaecology between May 2013 and May 2016. One hundred and fifty-six women diagnosed with International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) stage I low-intermediate risk endometrial carcinoma. Women allocated to the control group attended hospital-based follow up consisting of regular outpatient visits for 3years after primary treatment. Women in the intervention group were instructed in patient-initiated follow up, which included careful instruction in alarm symptoms and options for self-referral rather than a schedule of examinations. The primary end point was FCR as measured by the Fear of Cancer Recurrence Inventory (FCRI) after 10months of follow up. Secondary end points included cancer-related use of primary and secondary health care during the first 10months after treatment. In the primary analysis, FCR decreased significantly more in the control group from baseline to 10months of follow up (difference -5.9, 95% CI -10.9 to -0.9). The majority of this improvement happened after only 3months of follow up. Women receiving the intervention had fewer examinations at the department compared with the control group (0 versus 2 median visits, P<0.01) and 58% of these examinations were scheduled because of vaginal bleeding. Hospital-based follow up alleviates FCR significantly more than patient-initiated follow up, though the estimated difference was small. Patient-initiated follow up is a feasible, potentially cost-reducing follow-up approach in a population of endometrial cancer survivors with low risk of recurrence. The decision to use patient-initiated follow up should balance these benefits and harms. Patient-initiated follow up reduces healthcareuse but maintains fear of recurrence in endometrial cancer. Why and how was the study carried out? Follow up of women with endometrial cancer is resource consuming and previous research suggests that it is not effective. Even though the women benefit from reassurance at follow up, routine examinations may also remind the women of the disease and induce fear of cancer recurrence. Furthermore, routine follow up may delay recurrence diagnosis, because the women do not report their symptoms until the next scheduled visit. In the research explained in this article, patient-initiated follow up was evaluated as an alternative to traditional follow up. The women were randomly assigned to one of two follow-up programmes: regular gynaecological examinations at the department of gynaecology or self-referral with careful instruction in alarm symptoms, that is, patient-initiated follow up. The level of fear of cancer recurrence in the two groups was obtained by questionnaires. Information on healthcare use was obtained by questionnaires and a chart review. What were the main findings? Regular examinations at the department of gynaecology reduced the fear of cancer recurrence significantly more than patient-initiated follow up, though the difference was small. Women who were instructed in alarm symptoms, under self-referral, were able to monitor their symptoms, and this approach significantly reduced the number of examinations at the department of gynaecology. What are the limitations of the work? Participants in the self-referral group knew that they were examined less than other women, and this may have induced fear of cancer recurrence. Similarly, the regular completion of questionnaires regarding fear of cancer recurrence may have reminded the women of the disease and diminished the difference between the two groups. What are the implications for patients Patient-initiated follow up reduced healthcare use but maintained fear of cancer recurrence in women who had survived early-stage endometrial cancer. Future analyses on quality of life and cost-effectiveness are needed to balance the benefits and harms of patient-initiated follow up.

Objective To investigate the effect of resilience on fear of cancer recurrence in breast cancer patients and to find the specific role of perceived social support between them. Methods From April 2018 to January 2019, we invited 456 breast cancer patients hospitalized in the Department of Breast surgery in Qilu Hospital of Shandong University in Jinan to participate in the study and to finish a questionnaire survey which including the general information questionnaire, Chinese version of the Fear of Progression Questionnaire-Short Form, The Connor-Davidson Resilience Scale and Perceived Social Support Scale. Results The average score of fear of cancer recurrence in breast cancer patients was (41.5±7.7), and 85.99% (313/364) of the patients′ score was clinically significant (total score ≥ 34). Resilience could negatively predict the fear of cancer recurrence (β=-0.240 P < 0.01). Perceived social support is the moderation between resilience and fear of cancer recurrence (β=-0.179, P<0.01). Conclusions The level of resilience could affect the level of fear of cancer recurrence in breast cancer patients, and the increase in the level of perceived social support could enhance the effect of resilience on the fear of cancer recurrence, thus further reducing the level of patient′s fear of recurrence. Key words: Breast neoplasm; Resilience; Fear of cancer recurrence; Perceived social support; Moderation

There is increasing recognition of the unique physical and psychosocial concerns of the growing population of cancer survivors. An emerging literature demonstrates that fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) is a problematic long-term and late effect for cancer survivors. In fact, FCR is a top concern, and this article provides a necessary synthesis of the extant research evidence and theory. Literature searches were conducted using databases including MEDLINE and PsychINFO using specified search terms including 'fear of recurrence' and 'worry about recurrence'. A comprehensive narrative review summarizes early empirical findings on FCR including current definitions, assessment tools, clinical presentations, quality of life impact, prevalence, trajectory and risk factors. This paper also critically reviews the relevant theoretical frameworks to best understand these findings and considers multiple psychosocial treatment models that may have relevance for addressing FCR in the clinical setting. There is evidence of substantial prevalence and quality of life impact of FCR. Several theories (e.g. self-regulation model of illness, a family-based model, uncertainty in illness theory, social-cognitive processing theory, terror management theory) directly or indirectly help conceptualize FCR and inform potential treatment options for those with clinically significant distress or impairment resulting from FCR. Further investigation into FCR is warranted to promote evidence-based care for this significant cancer survivorship concern.

ABSTRACTWe examined whether (1) fear of cancer recurrence was related to lower health-related quality of life and (2) perceived growth moderated the link between fear of recurrence and health-related quality of life. About 292 adolescent and young adult cancer survivors (diagnosed with cancer at ages 15–34) completed a cross-sectional survey. Fear of recurrence was related to poorer physical and mental health-related quality of life. The negative association between fear of recurrence and mental health-related quality of life was moderated by perceived growth. Fostering perceived growth may mitigate the adverse associations of fear of recurrence and health-related quality of life.

The aims of the study were to (1) describe the prevalence of fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) in partners of prostate cancer (PCa) survivors; (2) to compare the proportions of high FCR in partners with high FCR in PCa survivors; (3) to explore partners' demographic and survivors' clinical characteristics associated with high FCR in partners; and (4) to identify the relationship between high FCR and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in partners. Questionnaires were sent to partners of disease-free PCa survivors. Outcomes included FCR severity (Cancer Worry Scale [CWS]) and HRQoL (RAND-36). The t and chi-square tests were used to compare partner FCR with survivor FCR. Regression analyses were performed to determine if demographic and clinical characteristics were significantly associated with partner FCR. The multivariate analysis of variance identified differences in HRQoL between partners with high and low FCR. Questionnaires were completed by 168 partners. Mean levels of FCR were comparable between partners and survivors (P=.144). Thirty-five percent of partners reported high FCR (CWS≥14) compared to 38% of PCa survivors (CWS≥13) (P=.542). Higher survivor FCR and younger partner age were significantly associated with higher partner FCR. Partners with high FCR scored significantly lower on social functioning, emotional role functioning, mental health, general health, and vitality than those with low FCR (all P<.05). Findings from this study illustrate that FCR is a significant concern for partners of PCa survivors. Clinicians should be aware of partner FCR when delivering care to men with PCa.

Background: Fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) is prevalent among breast cancer survivors and more intense in younger women. Given that FCR is a powerful determinant of quality of life and is associated with healthcare utilization, identifying who may be at risk for experiencing elevated FCR without resolution can inform the timing and targeting of interventions. Methods: Participants included women diagnosed (dx’d) at age ≤40 enrolled in the Young Women’s Breast Cancer Study, a multi-site prospective cohort surveyed at baseline and regularly in follow-up. Surveys include the 3-item Lasry Fear of Recurrence Index which measures the degree of concern about recurrence and current health using 4-point Likert response options that provide a score ranging from 3-12; higher scores indicate greater concern. Group-based trajectory modeling was used to classify distinct FCR patterns from baseline (median of 5 months from dx) through 3 years post-dx. Multinomial logistic regression was used to identify the associated patient (socio-demographics and BRCA status), disease (stage, ER/PR/HER2) and treatment (surgery, chemotherapy) characteristics associated with each trajectory. Variables significant at p&amp;lt;0.05 in univariable models were entered into the final multivariable model. Results: 965 women with Stages 0-III breast cancer were included in the analysis, with a median age at dx of 37. Participants were predominantly non-Hispanic White (85%), partnered (76%) and had completed college (84%). There was a significant decrease in median FCR scores from baseline to year 3 (9 vs. 8, Wilcoxon signed-rank test P&amp;lt;0.01). Five FCR trajectories (Table) were identified: 1) 10.5% of participants reported low/stable FCR from baseline over follow-up; 2) 33.1% had moderate FCR that improved over time; 3) 5.5% had moderate FCR scores at baseline that worsened over time; 4) 30% had high FCR scores at baseline that improved over time; 5) 20.8% had high FCR at baseline that remained high at all time points. In the fully adjusted multinomial model, younger age at dx and Stage 3 and 2 (vs. 1) disease were associated with higher odds of being in the high/stable trajectory. Having a lumpectomy (vs. mastectomy) was associated with higher odds of being in a high/stable as well as moderate/improving trajectory while White (vs. non-White) women had higher odds of being in a trajectory of improving FCR. Receipt of chemotherapy and financial discomfort were significantly associated with assignment to specific FCR trajectories in univariate analyses, however did not remain significant in the adjusted model. Being partnered, BRCA mutation status, and ER/PR/HER2 status were not significantly associated with any FCR trajectory classification in univariate or multivariate analyses. Conclusion: While FCR improves over time for many young women with breast cancer, a substantial minority (26%) had FCR that was severe and did not improve or worsened over time. Younger women with higher stage disease who are at risk for high levels of unresolved FCR may benefit from intervention including early referral to mental health professionals. Ongoing monitoring of women at risk for developing FCR following active treatment is warranted. Table Mean FCR score for each trajectoryBaselineYear 1Year 2Year 3TrajectoriesLow/Stable (N=103)5.725.605.545.45Moderate/Improving (N=331)7.907.487.287.09Moderate/Worsening (N=34)6.748.329.6410.54High/Improving (N=294)9.889.419.088.67High/Stable (N=203)11.0211.0811.0310.88 Citation Format: Lidia Schapira, Yue Zheng, Shari Gelber, Philip Poorvu, Kathryn J Ruddy, Rulla Tamini, Jeffrey Peppercorn, Steve Come, Virginia Borges, Ann Partridge, Shoshana Rosenberg. Trajectories of fear of cancer recurrence in young breast cancer survivors [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 2019 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium; 2019 Dec 10-14; San Antonio, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2020;80(4 Suppl):Abstract nr P2-13-09.

Fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) significantly impacts the treatment and prognosis of lung cancer survivors. However, the mechanisms and factors contributing to FCR and its related consequences in lung cancer remain poorly understood. To evaluate the validity of the Lee-Jones Theoretical Model of FCR in lung cancer survivors. A cross-sectional survey was conducted among 257 lung cancer survivors who had undergone surgical treatment 1 year prior. The participants completed a comprehensive set of questionnaires, and the data were analyzed using structural equation modeling to test the proposed model. The analysis confirmed direct relationships between family resilience, coping behaviors, illness perceptions, FCR triggers, and FCR. Fear of cancer recurrence was also found to have a direct negative impact on quality of life (QOL). Furthermore, levels of family resilience, coping behaviors, illness perceptions, and FCR triggers indirectly influenced QOL through their association with FCR. This study provides partial support for the validity of the Lee-Jones Theoretical Model of FCR in lung cancer survivors. The findings contribute to a better understanding of FCR in this population and lay the groundwork for targeted interventions. Effective strategies to reduce FCR in lung cancer survivors should focus on enhancing family resilience, improving disease cognition, minimizing FCR triggers, and guiding patients toward adopting positive coping styles, ultimately improving their QOL. Fear of cancer recurrence plays a vital role in relationships between internal and external cues and QOL. We can construct interventions to enhance the QOL of survivors based on the FCR influencing factors.

Fear of cancer recurrence in Korean women after breast cancer treatment: A mixed methods study.

Fear of cancer recurrence (FCR) and psychological distress are common psychological problems in breast cancer (BC) patients and ultimately affecting their health-related quality of life (HRQoL). Heart rate variability (HRV) can reflect the activity of the parasympathetic nervous system. However, the pathways through which HRV influences between FCR and HRQoL are unclear. This study preliminarily explored the intermediary role of HRV in FCR and HRQoL in BC patients. A total of 101 BC patients participated in this study. HRV parameters were measured by a 5-min dynamic electrocardiogram. FCR, psychological distress and HRQoL were evaluated by the Fear of disease progression simplified scale (FOP-Q-SF), Distress thermometer and SF-36 concise health survey. The intermediary effect model was established to test the intermediary effect of high frequency-HRV (HF-HRV) on FCR and HRQoL. FCR and psychological distress were negatively correlated with HRV in the time domain, negatively correlated with HF-HRV in the frequency domain, and positively correlated with low frequency/high frequency (LF/HF). HF-HRV had a partial mediating effect on the FCR and physical health and mental health, with effects of 30.23% and 9.53%, respectively. FCR and psychological distress are correlated with HRV parameters in the time domain and the frequency domain, and we preliminarily believe that parasympathetic nerves play an important intermediary role between FCR and subjective physical and mental health. This may provide intervention information for improving the HRQoL of BC patients.

Fear of cancer recurrence is highly prevalent among adult survivors of cancer. The role of fear of recurrence in the emotional distress of survivors of cancer, as well as health behaviors that may directly affect their health, remains unclear. To advance oncology practice, this study sought to examine the extent to which fear of recurrence stemming from physical symptoms accounts for emotional distress in a large sample of adult survivors of cancer and to extend the model to explain postdiagnosis self-reported health behavior change. In 2016, 258 survivors of cancer at an academic hospital completed a survey of psychosocial needs. Items assessed physical symptoms (checklist), fear of cancer recurrence (Assessment of Survivor Concerns), emotional distress (anxiety and depressed mood), and health behaviors (current alcohol use, physical activity, diet, and sunscreen use, as well as changes after cancer diagnosis) informed by National Comprehensive Cancer Network survivorship guidelines. Indirect effects regression models accounting for relevant covariates (age and treatment history) used 5,000-iteration bootstrapping. Higher fear of cancer recurrence was associated with greater number of physical symptoms (P < .001), greater emotional distress (P < .05), lower moderate or vigorous physical activity (P < .05), higher sunscreen use (P < .05), and postdiagnosis increases in alcohol use (P < .01) and reductions in physical activity (P < .01). Fear of cancer recurrence models accounted for almost half of the variance in distress of survivors of cancer (R2 = 0.44, P < .001) and, to a lesser yet significant extent, changes in alcohol consumption (R2 = 0.09, P < .001) and physical activity (R2 = 0.06, P = .003). Fear of cancer recurrence plays a central role in the emotional distress and key health behaviors of survivors of cancer. These findings support fear of cancer recurrence as a potential target for emotional health and health behavior change interventions.