Comparison of Heterologous Adult Brugia malayi and Homologous Onchocerca volvulus Antigen in the Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA) for Guatemalan Onchocerciasis

Abstract

To determine the susceptibility of a heterologous filarial antigen for measuring Onchocerca volvulus antibodies, worms were compared using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) test. Control serum samples from helminth-free U.S. residents and from helminth-infected but filariae-free Salvadoran residents were tested and compared with serum obtained from microfilariae-positive and -negative Guatemalan residents living in an area of endemic onchocerciasis. The results showed that none of the sera from U.S. residents had positive O. volvulus ELISA titers (greater than or equal to 1:160); however, 8.51% (4/47) had positive B. malayi ELISA titers (greater than or equal to 1:640). The geometric mean titers with the B. malayi ELISA test were higher than with the O. volvulus ELISA test--in sera from 47 U.S. residents (1:219 vs. 1:49), from 108 Salvadoran residents (1:92 vs. 1:71), and from 145 microfilariae-negative (1:539 vs. 1:167) and 303 microfilariae-positive (1:1,270 vs. 1:561) Guatemalan residents. The B. malayi ELISA test exhibited slightly less sensitivity than the homologous O. volvulus ELISA test; nevertheless, a good correlation (r = 0.74) was found between the 2 test antigens, indicating that the B. malayi antigen could be used to measure O. volvulus antibodies.