Comparison between percutaneous transthoracic co-axial needle CT-guided biopsy and transbronchial lung biopsy for the diagnosis of persistent pulmonary consolidation

Abstract

BackgroundDiagnosing persistent pulmonary consolidation still faces challenges. The purpose of this study is to compare the diagnostic yield and the complication rate between percutaneous transthoracic CT-guided coaxial needle biopsy (PTCNB) and transbronchial lung biopsy (TBLB) of persistent pulmonary consolidation.MaterialsFrom January 1, 2016, to December 31, 2020, we have retrospectively enrolled a total of 155 consecutive patients (95 males, 60 females) with persistent pulmonary consolidation who underwent both TBLB and PTCNB. According to the standard reference, the diagnostic yield, accuracy, sensitivity and specificity of PTCNB and TBLB were assessed and compared.ResultsAccording to the standard reference, the final biopsy diagnoses of 11 cases were confirmed true malignant based on the surgical resections, the remaining were confirmed by clinical and imaging follow-up for at least 12 months. The overall diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity and specificity of PTCNB for malignant diagnosis were 91.61%, 72.34% and 100%, whereas of TBLB were 87.74%, 59.57% and 100%. The diagnostic yield of PTCNB and TBLB were 50.32% and 25.16%, respectively. For the TBLB-based negative cases, PTCNB provided a definite diagnostic yield of 37.93%. There were 45 (29.03%), 22 (14.19%) and 13 (8.39%) patients who experienced pneumothorax, intrapulmonary hemorrhage and hemoptysis, respectively, in PTCNB, while there were only 5 (3.22%) cases of mild intraprocedural bleeding occurring in TBLB.ConclusionsCT-guided co-axial needle biopsy is an effective and safe modality, associated with higher diagnostic yield and better diagnostic accuracy compared to transbronchial lung biopsy for malignancy presenting as persistent consolidation, especially as the complementary method for TBLB-based negative lung lesions.Key PointsBoth PTCNB and TBLB showed high diagnostic accuracy for malignancy.PTCNB had a higher diagnostic yield than TBLB for persistent pulmonary consolidation.PTCNB could provide a complementary diagnosis for TBLB-based negative lung consolidation.