Coastal topography and rates of mussel recruitment: a comparison of bay versus open-coast sites

Abstract

The recruitment of intertidal benthic organisms that have planktonic larvae is influenced by hydrodynamics at multiple nested spatial scales, ranging from tens of centimetres to kilometres. Intertidal mussel populations on the south coast of South Africa are known to exhibit higher cover within bays than on open-coast shorelines. This study tested the hypothesis that topographically driven differences in hydrodynamics will result in comparatively higher recruitment within bays. Specifically, we estimated recruitment rates of the native brown mussel Perna perna and the invasive Mediterranean mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis (family Mytilidae) over five spring tidal cycles at bay and open-coast sites at both Algoa Bay and St Francis Bay, and the data were then correlated with upwelling indices derived from wind data. We recorded 3 313 P. perna and 2 485 M. galloprovincialis recruits individually and found that mussel recruitment within bays was as much as two orders of magnitude higher than on open coast. The relationship between recruit numbers and upwelling indices was positive, although non-significant, and markedly stronger for the open-coast sites (where r 2 values were 0.51–0.59). These results indicate that better mussel cover within bays can be at least partially explained by higher recruitment rates.