Chemistry-Driven Integrated Innovation: Unleashing the Potential of PROTAC Technology

Therapeutic targeting of RNA-binding protein by RNA-PROTAC

Since the first small molecule proteolysis targeting chimera (PROTAC) was reported about a decade ago, great progress has been made in the field of targeted protein degradation. Specially designed, small molecules can recruit the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS) to tag a protein of interest (POI) for degradation. Based on the ability to knock down a therapeutic POI (instead of inhibiting the target protein activity), this new modality has emerged as a paradigm-shifting approach and opened new avenues for small molecule drug discovery. At Xios Therapeutics, we have applied targeted protein degradation to a number of immuno-oncology (IO) drug targets and we present here the strategy and lessons learned from building our PROTAC platform in collaboration with X-Chem. Specifically, we have leveraged a vertical integration of DNA-encoded library screening (DEL), structural biology, medicinal chemistry, biochemical binding assays and cellular biomarker readouts for the rapid identification of cell potent degraders. We exemplify a modular, ‘fit-for-purpose’ PROTAC matrix that allows for rapid exploration of optimal E3 ligase-binders conjugated to a POI-binder using either existing or novel ligands identified via DEL. We delineate the structure-activity/property relationship (SAR and SPR) analysis of linker with VHL- and CRBN-based binders for a promising IO target achieving potent protein degradation (>90% degradation and nM DC50 potency) and pathway inhibition in cancer cells. Notably, our affinity-based screening of chemical libraries of unprecedented size (~200 billion molecules) with a priori knowledge of the vector point of attachment from the DNA barcode directly informs the rational design of bifunctional PROTAC molecules. In conclusion, our integrated approach allows us to find new, unexplored compound binding sites for both E3 ligases- and POI-binders that can be utilized by the PROTAC platform to create potent selective degraders and to access targets that have previously been considered undruggable. Citation Format: Jannik N. Andersen, Andrew J. McRiner, Lynette A. Fouser, Junyi Zhang, Shilpi Arora, Michael Cordeau, Ying Zhang, John Cuozzo, Michael Briskin, Matt Clark, Diala Ezzeddine. Degradation of immuno-oncology targets via proprietary PROTAC platform integrating DNA-encoded library technology and rational drug design [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2019; 2019 Mar 29-Apr 3; Atlanta, GA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2019;79(13 Suppl):Abstract nr 981.

Since the first small molecule proteolysis targeting chimera (PROTAC) was reported about a decade ago, great progress has been made in the field of targeted protein degradation. Specially designed, small molecules can recruit the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS) to tag a protein of interest (POI) for degradation. Based on the ability to knock down a therapeutic POI (instead of inhibiting the target protein activity), this new modality has emerged as a paradigm-shifting approach and opened new avenues for small molecule drug discovery. At Xios Therapeutics, we have applied targeted protein degradation to a number of immuno-oncology (IO) drug targets and we present here the strategy and lessons learned from building our PROTAC platform in collaboration with X-Chem. Specifically, we have leveraged a vertical integration of DNA-encoded library screening (DEL), structural biology, medicinal chemistry, biochemical binding assays and cellular biomarker readouts for the rapid identification of cell potent degraders. We exemplify a modular, 'fit-for-purpose' PROTAC matrix that allows for rapid exploration of optimal E3 ligase-binders conjugated to a POI-binder using either existing or novel ligands identified via DEL. We delineate the structure-activity/property relationship (SAR and SPR) analysis of linker with VHL- and CRBN-based binders for a promising IO target achieving potent protein degradation (>90% degradation and nM DC50 potency) and pathway inhibition in cancer cells. Notably, our affinity-based screening of chemical libraries of unprecedented size (~200 billion molecules) with a priori knowledge of the vector point of attachment from the DNA barcode directly informs the rational design of bifunctional PROTAC molecules. In conclusion, our integrated approach allows us to find new, unexplored compound binding sites for both E3 ligases- and POI-binders that can be utilized by the PROTAC platform to create potent selective degraders and to access targets that have previously been considered undruggable.Citation Format: Jannik N. Andersen, Andrew J. McRiner, Lynette A. Fouser, Junyi Zhang, Shilpi Arora, Michael Cordeau, Ying Zhang, John Cuozzo, Michael Briskin, Matt Clark, Diala Ezzeddine. Degradation of immuno-oncology targets via proprietary PROTAC platform integrating DNA-encoded library technology and rational drug design [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2019; 2019 Mar 29-Apr 3; Atlanta, GA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2019;79(13 Suppl):Abstract nr 981.

Proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) represent a promising class of hetero-bivalent molecules that facilitate ubiquitination of a target protein by simultaneously binding and bringing together both the E3 enzyme and the target. These compounds consist of three structural components: two ligands one of which binds the protein of interest (POI) while the other binds an E3 ubiquitin ligase to promote POI ubiquitination, and a linker connecting both moieties. Recent developments in the field highlight the fact that linker composition and length play a crucial role in achieving optimal PROTAC properties, modulate binding kinetics and substantially impacts the potency and selectivity. In this review, the authors briefly discuss the recent findings in PROTAC design approaches with focus on the linker. For each PROTAC such linker parameters as chemical nature, length, hydrophilicity and rigidity have to be optimized to achieve improved stability, bioavailability cell membrane permeability and suitable spatial orientation between the target POI and the E3 ubiquitin ligase. Thus rational linker design with respect to composition, length and attachment sites is essential for the development of potent PROTAC compounds. Computer-aided design and novel innovative linker strategies, such as PROTAC shortening, photo-switchable PROTACs, in-cell click-formed CLIPTACs, “click chemistry” approaches are also discussed in the review.

The proteolysis targeting chimera (PROTAC) strategy results in the down-regulation of unwanted protein(s) for disease treatment. In the PROTAC process, a heterobifunctional degrader forms a ternary complex with a target protein of interest (POI) and an E3 ligase, which results in ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation of the POI. While ternary complex formation is a key attribute of PROTAC degraders, modification of the PROTAC molecule to optimize ternary complex formation and protein degradation can be a labor-intensive and tedious process. In this study, we take advantage of DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology to efficiently synthesize a vast number of possible PROTAC molecules and describe a parallel screening approach that utilizes DNA barcodes as reporters of ternary complex formation and cooperative binding. We use a designed PROTAC DEL against BRD4 and CRBN to describe a dual protein affinity selection method and the direct discovery of novel, potent BRD4 PROTACs that importantly demonstrate clear SAR. Such an approach evaluates all the potential PROTACs simultaneously, avoids the interference of PROTAC solubility and permeability, and uses POI and E3 ligase proteins in an efficient manner.

The SLAS Discovery Editor's Top 10 for 2021.

Characteristic roadmap of linker governs the rational design of PROTACs

Proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) represent a transformative class of therapeutic agents that leverage the intrinsic protein degradation machinery to modulate the hemostasis of key disease-associated proteins selectively. Although several PROTACs have been approved for clinical application, suboptimal therapeutic efficacy and potential adverse side effects remain challenging. Benefiting from the enhanced targeted delivery, reduced systemic toxicity, and improved bioavailability, nanomedicines can be tailored with precision to integrate with PROTACs which hold significant potential to facilitate PROTAC nanomedicines (nano-PROTACs) for clinical translation with enhanced efficacy and reduced side effects. In this review, we provide an overview of the recent progress in the convergence of nanotechnology with PROTAC design, leveraging the inherent properties of nanomaterials, such as lipids, polymers, inorganic nanoparticles, nanohydrogels, proteins, and nucleic acids, for precise PROTAC delivery. Additionally, we discuss the various categories of PROTAC targets and provide insights into their clinical translational potential, alongside the challenges that need to be addressed.

SummaryThe application of machine learning toward DNA encoded library (DEL) technology is lacking despite obvious synergy between these two advancing technologies. Herein, a machine learning algorithm has been developed that predicts the conversion rate for the DNA-compatible reaction of a building block with a model DNA-conjugate. We exemplify the value of this technique with a challenging reaction, the Pictet-Spengler, where acidic conditions are normally required to achieve the desired cyclization between tryptophan and aldehydes to provide tryptolines. This is the first demonstration of using a machine learning algorithm to cull potential building blocks prior to their purchase and testing for DNA-encoded library synthesis. Importantly, this allows for a challenging reaction, with an otherwise very low building block pass rate in the test reaction, to still be used in DEL synthesis. Furthermore, because our protocol is solution phase it is directly applicable to standard plate-based DEL synthesis.

Proteolysis-targeting chimaeras (PROTACs), which induce proteolysis by recruiting an E3 ligase to dock into a target protein, are acquiring popularity as a novel pharmacological modality because of the unique features of PROTAC, including high potency, low dosage, and effective on undruggable targets. While PROTACs are promising prospects as chemical probes and therapeutic agents, their discovery usually necessitates the synthesis of numerous analogues to explore variations on the chemical linker structure exhaustively. Without extensive trial and error, it is unknown how to link the two protein-recruiting moieties to facilitate the formation of a productive ternary complex. Although molecular docking-based and optimization pipelines have been designed to predict ternary complexes, guiding rational PROTAC design, they have suffered from limited predictive performance in the quality of the ternary structure and their ranks. Here, MEGA PROTAC has been designed to enhance the performance in quality and ranking of ternary structures. MEGA PROTAC employs MEGADOCK to execute docking for protein-protein complexes (PPCs). The docking establishes an initial exploration area for PPCs. A sequential filtration strategy combined with rank aggregation is employed to choose a subset of PPCs for grid search. Once candidate PPCs are selected, a grid search method is used separately for translation and rotation. The remaining proteins have been grouped into clusters, and MEGA PROTAC further filters these clusters based on the energy score of the proteins within each cluster. MEGA PROTAC utilises rank aggregation to choose the best clusters and then employs MEGADOCK to dock PROTAC into the selected PPCs, forming a ternary structure. Finally, MEGA PROTAC was tested on 22 cases to compare with the state-of-the-art method, Bayesian optimisation for ternary complex prediction (BOTCP). MEGA PROTAC outperformed BOTCP on 16 test cases out of 22 cases, achieving a higher maximum DockQ score with an 18% higher mean and 35% higher median. Also, MEGA PROTAC exhibited 75% superior ranks and a reduced cluster number for maximum DockQ score compared to BOTCP. Also, MEGA PROTAC outperforms BOTCP by achieving a twofold improvement in locating the first acceptable DockQ scores, with a more significant proportion of near-native structures within the detected cluster.

Proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs) have emerged as a breakthrough therapeutic strategy in oncology, enabling the selective degradation of traditionally "undruggable" proteins via the ubiquitin-proteasome system. However, their clinical translation remains challenging due to high molecular weight, limited aqueous solubility, and metabolic instability, which limit systemic bioavailability and tumor penetration. To address these challenges, a variety of nanocarrier systems have been developed to improve the stability, pharmacokinetics, and tumor-specific accumulation of PROTACs. Beyond delivery enhancement, nanotechnology also enables the creation of next-generation PROTAC modalities, such as mRNA-encoded and RNA-scaffolded PROTACs, thereby expanding their therapeutic potential. In parallel, stimuli-responsive nanocarriers offer spatiotemporal control over PROTAC release, maximizing therapeutic efficacy while minimizing off-target effects. This review provides a comprehensive overview of nanotechnology-enabled strategies for PROTAC delivery, highlights key translational challenges, and discusses future directions to facilitate their clinical advancement in cancer therapy.

E3 Ligase Ligands for PROTACs: How They Were Found and How to Discover New Ones

ConspectusTargeted protein degradation (TPD) technologies, exemplified by proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs), have revolutionized therapeutic strategies by facilitating the selective degradation of pathogenic proteins instead of simply inhibiting their functions. This degradation-based strategy offers significant advantages over traditional small-molecule inhibitors, which often block protein activity without eliminating the target. PROTACs function by leveraging the ubiquitin-proteasome system to selectively degrade target proteins, thus enabling the modulation of a broader range of disease-causing proteins including those that were previously considered undruggable. As a result, PROTAC-based therapies have gained considerable attention in drug discovery, especially in oncology, immunology, and neurodegenerative diseases. However, clinical translation of conventional PROTACs remains challenging due to issues such as limited target specificity, poor solubility, inadequate cellular permeability, unfavorable pharmacokinetic profiles, and the absence of spatiotemporal resolution.To address these hurdles, various innovative strategies have been developed to enhance the precision of protein degradation. These approaches focus on improving targeted delivery, solubility, membrane permeability, and spatiotemporal control with the goal of overcoming the inherent limitations of traditional PROTAC designs. For instance, aptamer-conjugated PROTACs have shown great promise by improving tumor selectivity and reducing off-target effects through tumor-specific receptor recognition and subsequent internalization. Moreover, the development of drugtamer-PROTAC conjugates enables more precise codelivery with small-molecule agents, optimizing the synergistic effects of both modalities while minimizing systemic toxicity. Additionally, RGD peptide-based PROTAC conjugation strategies capitalize on the use of tumor-homing peptides to enhance cellular uptake, improve tumor penetration, and increase degradation specificity in tumor cells, further reducing off-target toxicities in healthy tissues.Another critical advancement is the development of photocontrolled PROTACs, which allow for precise temporal regulation of protein degradation in vivo. By leveraging light-responsive molecules, these systems provide the ability to trigger protein degradation at specific time points, offering unparalleled control over therapeutic interventions. Furthermore, theranostic PROTACs, which combine both diagnostic and therapeutic functions, facilitate real-time monitoring of protein degradation events in living cells and animal models, enabling simultaneous assessment of the therapeutic efficacy and biomarker visualization.This Account reviews recent advancements in the design of smart PROTACs, highlighting strategies that improve their tumor specificity, solubility, permeability, and spatiotemporal control. These innovations provide promising solutions to address the limitations of traditional PROTACs, paving the way for progress in drug discovery and the evolution of precision medicine. While the discussed strategies present significant opportunities, we also explore the challenges, limitations, and future directions for clinical translation, offering insights into the potential for degrader-based precision therapies in a clinical setting.

PROteolysis TArgeting Chimeras (PROTACs) are heterobifunctional molecules consisting of two ligands; an “anchor” to bind to an E3 ubiquitin ligase and a “warhead” to bind to a protein of interest, connected by a chemical linker. Targeted protein degradation by PROTACs has emerged as a new modality for the knock down of a range of proteins, with the first agents now reaching clinical evaluation. It has become increasingly clear that the length and composition of the linker play critical roles on the physicochemical properties and bioactivity of PROTACs. While linker design has historically received limited attention, the PROTAC field is evolving rapidly and currently undergoing an important shift from synthetically tractable alkyl and polyethylene glycol to more sophisticated functional linkers. This promises to unlock a wealth of novel PROTAC agents with enhanced bioactivity for therapeutic intervention. Here, the authors provide a timely overview of the diverse linker classes in the published literature, along with their underlying design principles and overall influence on the properties and bioactivity of the associated PROTACs. Finally, the authors provide a critical analysis of current strategies for PROTAC assembly. The authors highlight important limitations associated with the traditional “trial and error” approach around linker design and selection, and suggest potential future avenues to further inform rational linker design and accelerate the identification of optimised PROTACs. In particular, the authors believe that advances in computational and structural methods will play an essential role to gain a better understanding of the structure and dynamics of PROTAC ternary complexes, and will be essential to address the current gaps in knowledge associated with PROTAC design.

The tedious synthesis and limited throughput biological evaluation remain a great challenge for discovering new proteolysis targeting chimera (PROTAC). To rapidly identify potential PROTAC lead compounds, we report a platform named Auto-RapTAC. Based on the modular characteristic of the PROTAC molecule, a streamlined workflow that integrates lab automation with "click chemistry" joint building-block libraries was constructed. This facilitates the autonomous generation of a variety of PROTACs, each with distinct linkers and E3 ligase ligands, all stored in biocompatible solutions. The ready-for-screening (R4S) approach, when paired with fluorescence-based assays, enables the efficient assessment of the PROTAC degradation activity in a high-throughput manner. To further test the capability of the platform, we identify six new PROTACs that target CDK2, CDK12, and BCL6 within a mere 8-day time frame for each target. In all, this platform could find broad application not only in discovering new PROTACs but also in the rapid development of novel heterobifunctional modalities.