Biomass Dynamics of Lake Superior Lake Herring (Coregonus artedii): Application of Schnute's Difference Model

Abstract

Schnute's (1985. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 42: 414–429) difference model was used to study the biomass dynamics of lake herring (Coregonus artedii) in Thunder Bay and Black Bay, Lake Superior, during 1948–79. Recruitment to both fisheries appeared to be independent of escapement during previous years. Abundance of lake herring in Black Bay varied without trend during the study period despite a strong peak in effective fishing effort during 1968–70 and a general trend of increasing effort throughout the study period. Abundance of Thunder Bay lake herring declined during 1948–50 and 1959–67 and increased when fishing effort declined. The estimated catchability coefficient for small-mesh gill nets (54–83 mm stretched measure) set in Black Bay for lake herring during November was 0.467/102 km net. The estimated catchability coefficient for small mesh gill nets set in Thunder Bay for lake herring during December was 0.132/102 km net. Estimates of natural mortality rates and recruitment levels for both fisheries were confounded and unreliable. This analysis demonstrates the utility of Schnute's model for management of Great Lakes herring stocks and some difficulties with its application.