Assessment of metabolic activity of single bacterial cells — new developments in microcolony and dehydrogenase assays

Abstract

Some bacteria lose culturability in natural environments but retain measurable metabolic activity and are thus considered viable. Several techniques have been proposed to determine the activity of nonculturable cells. Due to the considerable physiological heterogeneity of bacterial populations in the environment, it is imperative to apply methods which measure cellular activity at the single cell level. This review focuses on two promising methods: the microcolony assay and the respiration assay based on reduction of 5-cyano-2,3-ditolyl tetrazolium chloride (CTC). In the microcolony assay, viable cells are identified by their ability to perform a limited number of cell divisions and this approach is thus related to conventional culture techniques. Some recent methodological developments of the technique aiming at improving the incubation conditions and the detection of microcolonies are presented. Results obtained by the microcolony technique are used to introduce its advantages and limitations. The CTC-reduction assay determines a central cellular metabolic activity, but does not measure cell growth. Results of studies using this assay are presented, and it is emphasized that great care should be taken to optimize assay conditions for the studied organisms. Finally, the results obtained by different viability assays are compared. For a specific bacterium, several assays, addressing different aspects of cell metabolism, can provide comparable results suggesting that they provide meaningful viability estimates. On the other hand, the use of viability assays on complex indigenous populations may be ambiguous.