Assessing Wildlife Impact on Forest Regeneration Through Drone-Based Thermal Imaging

Density-related effect of red deer browsing on palatable and unpalatable tree species and forest regeneration dynamics

Effects of ungulate pressure on the development of young generation of trees is one of the most important issues in ecology and forestry. Ungulate pressure influence on the development of natural regeneration has been also reported from several national parks. Our study on the effects of ungulate browsing on the young generation of trees was conducted on more than 500 sample plots controlled during one growing season. The overall browsing pressure ranged from 7.6% in seedlings to 20.3% in low saplings. The pressure of ungulates on the regeneration of Picea abies, the dominant species in the Tatra National Park, was by and large below 1%. Broadleaved species were browsed more frequently. The relationship between the plot altitudes and browsing intensity was statistically significant for seedlings and low saplings; at the higher altitudes, the browsing pressure was greater. There was also observed a statistically significant relationship between the type of former management and the browsing degree in seedlings; in the areas subjected to “landscape protection”, the intensity of browsing was higher when compared to strictly protected areas. Pressure exerted by ungulates on tree regeneration was very unevenly distributed, i.e. some plots were heavily browsed and many others - not browsed at all. The most affected tree species were Salix caprea and Sorbus aucuparia, although the percentage of browsed individuals rarely exceeded 50%. Other species favored by ungulates was Acer pseudoplatanus; despite the high browsing pressure, this species was present among seedlings and tall saplings, suggesting that it would be able to recruit to the tree layer. Abies alba was browsed less frequently than the deciduous trees; however, among the tall saplings it was the third most browsed species.

Increasing wild ungulate populations in the northern hemisphere led to extensive research on their influence on forest regeneration. According to the results of different studies, high ungulate densities may alter forest structure and composition, as well as inhibit forest regeneration. However, little is known about the long-term impact of large herbivores on forest dynamics at the landscape scale. Therefore, we studied forest regeneration in conifer forests of the highly protected Swiss National Park. We assessed sapling densities and apical shoot loss by repeated systematic sampling in 2003 and in 2011–2012 in two valleys featuring exceptionally high densities of wild ungulates of up to 86 individuals per vegetation-covered square kilometre during summer and 28 individuals per vegetation-covered square kilometre during winter. Mean apical shoot loss ranged between 2.9% and 10.6% depending on study site and assessment year. In addition to the increasing sapling densities, these results suggest that ungulates had little impact on tree establishment in the studied subalpine conifer forests. Additionally, sapling diversity was higher on plots repeatedly influenced by ungulates (apical shoot loss), suggesting rather positive effects of ungulates on sapling diversity. Habitat containing a mixture of forest and grassland without livestock or human disturbance provides a high-quality environment for ungulates, which likely explains the low impact of ungulates on forest regeneration in our study area.

Heavy browsing pressure by moose (Alces alces) can interfere with the objectives of ecosystem-based forest management

The impact of ungulate browsing on tree saplings has been found to have a negative effect on the regeneration of temperate forests. However, it remains ambiguous whether a relationship exists between browsing intensity and soil quality in natural forests. Therefore, we conducted a study in Roztoczańskie National Park to investigate the relationship between soil quality and browsing intensity for tree saplings. The aim was to gain a better understanding of how soil quality affects the browsing of ungulates on tree species. Baseline data (sapling height, basal diameter, crown length and width, browsed-shoot diameter, and soil samples) were collected from the 22 belt transects established in the permanent research plots. The soil quality index was calculated using physical and chemical soil properties. Twig dry mass was determined using allometric equations. Species relative density and browsing intensity were assessed through field measurements. Relationships between the variables were established using a linear regression model. The results suggest that browsing intensity is influenced by the gradient of the soil quality index and that it varies between tree species. Along the increasing soil quality gradient, tree species’ relative density (p = 0.012) and twig dry mass m−2 (p = 0.005) significantly decreased for A. pseudoplatanus. In contrast, browsing intensity increased significantly with an increasing species relative density for A. pseudoplatanus (p = 0.00) and C. betulus (p = 0.001) and with an increasing twig dry mass for F. sylvatica (p = 0.034) and C. betulus (p = 0.004). Browsing intensity increased significantly with an increasing soil quality index for F. sylvatica (p = 0.027) and decreased significantly for A. pseudoplatanus (p = 0.036). Notably, there was a significant positive relationship between browsing intensity and species relative density and twig dry mass, indicating that ungulate browsing is concentrated where browsing is abundant. These results provide insights that can be used to improve management and conservation strategies to protect tree species vulnerable to ungulate herbivory.

Wild ungulates as forest engineers

The interacting effects of ungulates and fire on forest dynamics: an analysis using the model FORSPACE

Sustainable regeneration of silver fir (Abies alba Mill.) is important for maintaining and improving the future resilience and protective capacity of mountain forests in the southern Swiss Alps. However, increasing densities of wild ungulates, such as red and roe deer, can hamper the regeneration success of silver fir. A comprehensive understanding of forest–wildlife interactions is essential to plan concrete measures for improving the adaptation potential of mountain forests. Here, we monitored the dynamics of natural silver fir regeneration in mountain protective forests. This study encompassed 30 unfenced permanent plots across two sites, Lostallo and Soazza, located in Valle Mesolcina in the southern Swiss Alps. These sites were selected for their comparable ecological characteristics related to silver fir regeneration, yet contrasting densities of mature, seed-bearing silver fir trees. We recorded the number of seedlings (<10 cm height) and saplings (10–200 cm height), and repeatedly assessed height growth, frequency, and intensity of ungulate browsing on saplings in the summers 2016, 2019, and 2022. In 2022, we additionally recorded the presence of browsing on other tree species in the unfenced plots and the height growth increments of silver fir saplings in pre-existing fences. On average, 509 silver fir seedlings/ha were present in the study area, but there was a lower density of saplings (382 saplings/ha). Between 2016 and 2022, the browsing frequency on silver fir saplings increased from 33 per cent to nearly 100 per cent, accompanied by a significant rise in browsing intensity. Furthermore, sapling height growth from 2019 to 2022 was significantly reduced or even negative in the unfenced plots as compared to the growth of saplings in the fenced plots. The observed seedling density indicated a good potential for natural regeneration of silver fir, irrespective of the differences in the density of seed-bearing trees between the two sites. However, the increased ungulate browsing impaired successful regeneration in the considered mountain forests in the southern Swiss Alps. Thus, without an effective control of ungulate browsing, silver fir may not be able to substantially contribute to the transition to more resilient and future-proof mountain forests.

Early European agriculture: Its foundations and development: M. R. Jarman, G. N. Bailey and H. N. Jarman (Eds), (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982. Pp. x + 283. £25.00)

Long-term browsing impact around diversionary feeding stations for moose in Southern Norway

Oak regeneration facing deer browsing: Can competition between saplings offset the diversion effect? A simulation experiment

Browsing of tree saplings by deer hampers forest regeneration in mixed forests across Europe and North America. It is well known that tree species are differentially affected by deer browsing, but little is known about how different facets of diversity, such as species richness, identity, and composition, affect browsing intensity at different spatial scales. Using forest inventory data from the Hainich National Park, a mixed deciduous forest in central Germany, we applied a hierarchical approach to model the browsing probability of patches (regional scale) as well as the species‐specific proportion of saplings browsed within patches (patch scale). We found that, at the regional scale, the probability that a patch was browsed increased with certain species composition, namely with low abundance of European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) and high abundance of European ash (Fraxinus excelsior L.), whereas at the patch scale, the proportion of saplings browsed per species was mainly determined by the species’ identity, providing a “preference ranking” of the 11 tree species under study. Interestingly, at the regional scale, species‐rich patches were more likely to be browsed; however, at the patch scale, species‐rich patches showed a lower proportion of saplings per species browsed. Presumably, diverse patches attract deer, but satisfy nutritional needs faster, such that fewer saplings need to be browsed. Some forest stand parameters, such as more open canopies, increased the browsing intensity at either scale. By showing the effects that various facets of diversity, as well as environmental parameters, exerted on browsing intensity at the regional as well as patch scale, our study advances the understanding of mammalian herbivore–plant interactions across scales. Our results also indicate which regeneration patches and species are (least) prone to browsing and show the importance of different facets of diversity for the prediction and management of browsing intensity and regeneration dynamics.

A comparison of riparian plant community response to herbivory by beavers ( Castor canadensis) and ungulates in Canada's boreal mixed-wood forest

Intensity of red deer browsing on young rowans differs between freshly-felled and standing individuals

Browsing of overabundant free-living herbivores often limits the natural as well as artificial regeneration of forest in Central-European Mountains. The aim of the study was to assess the efficiency of the extensive reductions of herbivore populations for protection of forest regeneration in preferred areas. We analysed the relationship between the intensity of shoot browsing and relative density of herbivores in viewpoint of natural regeneration of secondary mountain spruce stands with low proportion of broadleaved trees in Kralický Sněžnik Reserve (Czech Republic). The distribution of seasonally migrating herbivores was established by counting faecal pellet groups (standing crop method) in growing season. The intensity of browsing of spruce, beech and rowan was assessed using the proportion of browsed shoots on individual tree sapling. Density of red deer was re-counted from the number of pellet groups and it was 15–56 individual/km2. The intensity of spruce browsing was low in the whole area in all seasons. In general, the intensity of rowan and beech shoot browsing was high in the whole area. There were no correlations between deer density and browsing intensity of rowan (browsing was severe in all plots). We conclude that the natural regeneration of attractive trees and shrubs is nearly impossible in habitats where proportion of these food items is too small, even when the density of herbivores is low. Reduction of herbivores density is useful for protecting spruce and other tree species with low preference by herbivores. Forest managers should take into account the high palatability of deciduous tree species and distribution of herbivores on localities. Preference of localities is often based on grasses in the food supply. Regeneration of highly palatable tree species requires both low density of herbivores and sufficient protection of saplings.