Assessing the accuracy and efficacy of multiscale computational methods in predicting reaction mechanisms and kinetics of SN2 reactions and Claisen rearrangement

Abstract

This study investigates the application of quantum mechanical (QM) and multiscale computational methods in understanding the reaction mechanisms and kinetics of SN2 reactions involving methyl iodide with NH2OH and NH2O−, as well as the Claisen rearrangement of 8-(vinyloxy)dec-9-enoate. Our aim is to evaluate the accuracy and effectiveness of these methods in predicting experimental outcomes for these organic reactions. We achieve this by employing QM-only calculations and several hybrids of QM and molecular mechanics (MM) methods, namely QM/MM, QM1/QM2, and QM1/QM2/MM methodologies. For the SN2 reactions, our results demonstrate the importance of explicitly including solvent effects in the calculations to accurately reproduce the transition state geometry and energetics. The multiscale methods, particularly QM/MM and QM1/QM2, show promising performance in predicting activation energies. Moreover, we observe that the size of the MM active region significantly affects the accuracy of calculated activation energies, highlighting the need for careful consideration during the setup of multiscale calculations. In the case of the Claisen rearrangement, both QM-only and multiscale methods successfully reproduce the proposed reaction mechanism. However, the activation free energies calculated using a continuum solvation model, based on single-point calculations of QM-only structures, fail to account for solvent effects. On the other hand, multiscale methods more accurately capture the impact of solvents on activation free energies, with systematic error correction enhancing the accuracy of the results. Furthermore, we introduce a Python code for setting up multiscale calculations with ORCA, which is available on GitHub at https://github.com/iranimehdi/pdbtoORCA.