Application of the combined problem-based learning and case-based learning teaching in urinalysis course of diagnostics

Abstract

Background Traditional lecture-based teaching is the most commonly used approach in Chinese medical curricula. Novel teaching methods that are more educationally effective and academically satisfactory are warranted. Problem-based Learning (PBL) and case-based learning (CBL) have been widely researched and utilized worldwide. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness and acceptability of combined PBL and CBL methods in second-year undergraduate students in the nephrology experiment module of the Medical Diagnostics course. Methods We enrolled 150 second-year clinical medicine students from the First Clinical College of Sun Yat-sen University. Participants were assigned to either the PBL or CBL combined group (92 students, two classes) or the traditional group (58 students, one class) for a Urine Analysis course. The learning effects were compared through a post-class quiz, and student evaluations and perceptions of PBL and CBL methods were gathered via an anonymous questionnaire. Results The combined PBL and CBL group outperformed the traditional lecture group, with significantly higher post-class quiz scores (P<0.001). Regarding acceptance and perception, 67.4% found PBL-CBL to be more acceptable, 78.3% believed it stimulated critical thinking, 82.6% agreed that it enhanced practicaleth abilities, and 83.7% believed it led to better learning outcomes. Regarding open feedback, 51.1% appreciated its clinical connection, 34.8% recognized its effectiveness, 32.6% found it novel and interesting, and 30.4% noted positive learning encouragement. Conclusion The PBL-CBL binding mode is a feasible and effective teaching mode, which can help improve both medical teaching quality and academic satisfaction of students.